Courtroom chaos, case updates, sharp reactions.
True Crime Squad follows multiple crime stories with a live-stream urgency and a low tolerance for sloppy facts. Katie Weaver and Christy Brower move from camping stories and family updates into missing-person timelines, preliminary hearings, police work, indictments, and sentencing details.
PRESS PLAY
True Crime Squad is a fast case-analysis show with a live-stream pulse. Katie Weaver and Christy Brower work through multiple crime stories, trial developments, and courtroom moments with the looseness of a long-running conversation. The show does not begin in documentary mode. It may start with camping plans, dogs reacting to a motorhome, a grandchild’s birthday, a shopping errand, a craft project, or a technical apology about a watch party link. Then the tone pivots. A missing person timeline, a preliminary hearing, a sentencing argument, or a new indictment takes over, and the hosts begin pressing on the details. The show is strongest when it is asking basic practical questions out loud. Why would friends leave someone behind on an island? Why was evidence sitting on the ground after a shooting? What does a legal sanity finding actually say, and what does it leave out? Those questions give the episodes their momentum. The hosts are comfortable saying when testimony is dull, when police work seems careless, or when a public explanation feels too neat. They also make room for uncertainty. In cases like Nolan Xavier Wells, Andrea, Tyler Robinson, Samuel Bateman, Jeffrey Smerer, and Kouri Richins, the show separates what is known from what is still murky, even when the reaction is heated. Courtroom clips and quoted proceedings often become fuel for back-and-forth commentary. Legal process matters here, but the show is not clinical. It is interested in hearings, evidence handling, 911 calls, sentencing, and trial calendars because those are the places where stories change. The pacing can be chaotic. That is part of the appeal. True Crime Squad feels made for listeners who follow cases while doing real life, not for people who want pristine narration and carefully sanded edges. It can be funny around grim material, but the humor usually points at absurd behavior, bad excuses, platform problems, or the hosts’ own exhaustion. The show also knows when a case is simply awful. Episodes involving children, sexual violence, murder, mental health, and family trauma are handled with visible emotional reaction, even when the banter keeps moving. It is true crime with notes scattered on the desk and the livestream still running.
Made for: For true-crime followers who want updates, legal-process context, and candid reactions to developing cases. It suits listeners who prefer conversational energy over polished documentary distance.
What sets it apart: Its appeal is the collision of everyday banter and detailed case tracking. Katie Weaver and Christy Brower make evidence, hearings, livestreams, and unanswered questions feel like an active group discussion instead of a finished report.
Come join our squad! Kristi and Katie share true crime stories, teach you about the legal system, and give you practical ways to help, all with a wicked sense of humor!
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Christy Brower and Katie Weaver pair candid case updates with close attention to legal proceedings, investigative choices, and unresolved facts.
True Crime Squad follows active cases through court proceedings, police interviews, evidence disputes, indictments, and missing-person developments.
A rooftop screwdriver versus a stray bullet: come question the evidence with Christy and Katie.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A missing friend, a returned phone, and evidence that keeps the story unsettled.
Nolan's disappearance gives True Crime Squad a clear, uneasy pull: a last confirmed sighting around 3 p.m. on Horn Island, friends heading back to the mainland with his phone, and no 911 call saying he had been left behind.
Camping chatter gives way to a blunt, skeptical look at a hearing marked by shoddy evidence handling.
True Crime Squad opens with a loose desert-camping stretch and a fair bit of horse talk before settling into a preliminary hearing tied to a shooting at a Charlie Kirk rally.
Camping chatter opens into a skeptical look at a trailer door, camera footage, and disputed testimony.
The episode starts in camping chaos, with Christy Brower and Katie Weaver sorting through dogs pacing, luggage coming out, and the motorhome moving into the front yard before the case really takes hold.
A chatty episode that shifts from light banter to a grim case update and later grand jury action.
True Crime Squad starts with easy banter about shopping, camping groceries, and keeping the dogs clear of fireworks over the Fourth of July before turning to a May 1, 2025 death investigation.
Loose opening banter gives way to a grounded account of Mr. Smear's mental health, guilty plea, and the life sentence the law requires.
True Crime Squad opens with loose banter, then settles into Mr. Smear's depression, anxiety, and the claim that he stopped taking prescribed medication about five days before the incident.
Weather talk leads into a careful read of a police interview and the body language around it.
This episode moves from weather chatter about rain in the UK or Ireland, snow in southeast Idaho, and an uneasy February that feels too warm for comfort into a close reading of a police interview.
Strange cases, loud banter, no polish.
Behavior, evidence, and accountability.
Case files with a psychological verdict.
Old crimes, formally brought to judgment.
True crime, hauntings, horror, and Sunday Scaries.
Kristi and Katie analyze excerpts from the police interview of Edrick Faust, the defendant in the Tara Baker murder trial.
Kristi from True Crime Squad reports on a brief court hearing in the Caleb Flynn murder case.
The hosts discuss true crime investigations, encourage listener suggestions for cases, and share personal anecdotes about windy weather and travel.
Two true crime hosts discuss Day 11 of the Kouri Richins trial, focusing on the defense's aggressive efforts to exclude Carmen Lauber's interviews and the chaotic nature of the proceedings.
This episode discusses day 12 of the Kouri Richins trial, focusing on the defense's confusing tactics and their impact on the jury.
True Crime Squad starts with a desert camping detour and plenty of horse talk.
Christy Brower and Katie Weaver open with commentary on the Tyler Robinson preliminary hearing before covering the case of Delwayne Turner, whose tattooed arm was found floating in Lake Mattoon, Illinois, leading to the arrest of his wife Robin and half-brother James Adams, who admitted to stabbing him and claimed self-defense.
Christy Brower opens on camping chaos.
Katie Weaver and Christy Brower open with shopping talk, camping groceries, and the Fourth of July dog-fireworks problem.
The hosts open by tripping over who is supposed to go first.
The hosts discuss technical issues with a watch party, mention a co-host's return to true crime content, and share casual banter about pets and travel.
The hosts introduce a true crime podcast episode with a playful rhyme, then share a personal anecdote about the host's granddaughter.
The hosts discuss their deep dive into true crime, specifically highlighting the Rob Tejas trial as one of the most entertaining cases they've watched, and share plans to create trial throwback content with commentary for their Trials channel.
This true crime podcast episode introduces cases like the Tracy Grist trial, Lego Heist, and Kouri Richins, featuring sleuths who analyze clues and alibis with a humorous tone.
This episode is a true crime roundup covering bizarre cases involving alligators, Taco Bell crimes, nude sunbathing incidents, hide-and-seek criminals, and other unusual stories.
The hosts discuss day 6 of the Kouri Richins trial, focusing on a contentious argument where the defense cited irrelevant case law, humorously linking it to recent news about attorneys using AI like ChatGPT to write briefs.
This solo episode of True Crime Squad discusses the Edrick Faust police interview and an AI-related failure by Utah police, with the host covering the case in place of her co-host.