Murder cases, rebuilt slowly, at the quiet end.
Jill and Dick work through murder cases the slow way, starting with marriages, jobs, money trouble and small-town geography long before the crime itself. Each episode pairs that careful reconstruction with a beer and a running back-and-forth over what the evidence actually supports.
PRESS PLAY
This is a long-form true crime show with 451 episodes behind it and a fixed, unhurried method. Jill narrates. Dick listens, interjects, and asks the question a listener would ask. The result sounds less like a produced documentary than a careful kitchen-table reconstruction that keeps circling back to the timeline. Cases are drawn from a wide net. A vibrant twenty-year-old vanishing on a summer night in a small Missouri town in 1985. A young woman killed while traveling far from home, with CCTV footage at the center of the case. A university professor and the young woman he insisted was only an acquaintance. A woman whose remains were not recovered for years, found only after her killer confessed to another murder, and whose mother spent five more years fighting to get that confession admitted at trial. What links them is the structure. The show almost always starts well before the crime, laying out jobs, marriages, money, children, and the slow accumulation of pressure inside a family. Money and shame come up constantly. So does the way silence between spouses hardens into something worse. The hosts do not treat this background as filler, because it is usually where the motive lives. When the narrative turns dark, the tone stays plainspoken. There is no melodrama and no theatrical scoring of the horror. Instead there is sober detail: dates, warnings that went unheeded, protective orders violated, interrogation-room moments where a suspect's confidence visibly drains away. Dick's asides do real work, puncturing an implausible alibi or noting when something simply seems off. Medical questions get attention too, always framed as opinion drawn from the facts of a case rather than advice. The beer segment is not a gimmick bolted on. It is chosen to suit the case, often geographically, and described with genuine attention to color, aroma and strength before the conversation moves on. Episodes end the way they begin, casually. Voicemails and emails get read when there is time, and get bumped to next week when the case ran long. A members-only episode is sometimes flagged. Then comes the sign-off about waiting down at the quiet end with plenty of room. Listeners should know the show is explicit about its subject matter from the first minute, with a standing warning about disturbing content related to real crimes. Occasional strong language appears when a host's patience runs out with a suspect's story. For anyone who prefers their true crime researched, chronological, and discussed rather than performed, the format is remarkably consistent.
Made for: For true crime listeners who want full biographical context and a clear timeline rather than atmosphere and cliffhangers. It suits people who enjoy a two-host conversation, don't mind long episodes, and appreciate a beer recommendation alongside the case.
What sets it apart: Most true crime shows open at the crime scene; this one often opens years earlier, using marriages, jobs and money pressure to explain what followed. The paired-host dynamic, with one narrator and one skeptical questioner, plus a case-matched beer, gives it a conversational rhythm that stays sober once the facts turn grim.
Welcome to the Quiet End
Based on 4 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Jill and Dick make disputed findings, forensic gaps, and unresolved questions understandable while keeping the people affected at the center.
Jill and Dick move case by case through suspicious deaths, disputed findings, and investigations complicated by lost evidence or unanswered questions.
At the quiet end of the bar, Jill and Dick give your doubts about a case a seat.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A murder case shaped by silence, bad judgment, and a family life slowly pulling apart.
True Crime Brewery presents Kevin Spann's killing as a story of domestic drift, online reinvention, and bad judgment, with the case feeling unsettled even before it is fully clear.
A sober account of Grace Mullane's death, Kempson's lies, and the police response.
True Crime Brewery presents Grace Mullane's death in New Zealand as a careful, chronological true-crime account, opening with the life she was building abroad and then tracing the case through Kempson's shifting story.
A 1929 murder case tightens around a professor, a bandaged hand, and a hard interview.
Shirttail Alley starts with the discovery of Theora Hicks's body in a field outside Columbus, Ohio, then keeps its focus on Dr. Snook as detectives work through his bandaged hand, his timeline, and the people connected to Theora.
A grim domestic case told with patience, detail, and a sober eye for pressure.
Shelley Kavlin comes across as someone who had built a life that looked steady from the outside: a high paying job, two children, and a husband who kept losing jobs, had repeated affairs, and became mentally and physically abusive.
A calm, chronological true-crime account that keeps the human cost in view.
True Crime Brewery takes the case step by step, moving through the fire scene and what follows with a calm, chronological focus. It stays close to Katie and the small details in the room, which keeps the human cost in view even when the material turns disturbing.
A family tragedy becomes a slow, unsettling case of suspicion and unanswered questions.
The episode follows the Augustine family through two shocking deaths and the uneasy questions around Kathy Augustine's death. It keeps the political backdrop, the rushed remarriage, and the hospital connection in view, while making clear how suspicion gathered around the people…
A careful, unsettling look at a death that never really added up.
Jill and Dick revisit Ellen Greenberg, the 27-year-old engaged teacher found dead in her Philadelphia apartment during a snowstorm, and they keep the focus on the facts without rushing past the parts that still do not sit right.
A measured true-crime episode that centers Flo, the investigation, and the way rumor can distort a murder case.
This episode treats Florence Unger as a person first, not just a victim, and it stays close to the details of her life, her last known moments, and the people around her. It moves through rumor, silence, and the gaps in the record with a steady hand, which suits the case well.
True stories of scams, aliases, frauds, and lives built on lies.
Payne Lindsey and Tenderfoot TV revisit the Atlanta Child Murders and the wider Monster franchise.
Host Jake Brennan traces the crimes and scandals behind musicians from Elvis to Taylor Swift.
Karina Longworth narrates the Manson murders as a story about Hollywood's collapsing 1960s dream.
iO Tillett Wright investigates her mother's boyfriend's unsolved 1982 East Village murder.
A wilderness hoax, a trusting BC town, and the brothers who fooled it.
This episode investigates the 2003 murder of Florence Unger at a Michigan lakeside resort, exploring her troubled marriage, divorce proceedings, and the suspicious death that led to her husband Mark's trial.
This episode investigates the 1957 abduction and murder of Barbara and Patricia Grimes, two teenage sisters from Chicago whose bodies were found frozen under a bridge.
The hosts investigate the mysterious death of Ellen Greenberg, a teacher found stabbed in her Philadelphia apartment in 2011.
Kevin Spann is killed in the early hours of a quiet morning.
Grace Mullane is framed as a young woman trying to live life on her own terms.
True Crime Brewery follows the 1929 murder of Theora Hicks, a 24-year-old Ohio State University medical student found beaten in Shirttail Alley outside Columbus, Ohio.
Shelley Kavlin looks successful from the outside, with a husband, two children, and a job she loves.
The episode recounts the disappearance and murder of Becky Godden Edwards, a heroin addict and sex worker, and the legal challenges in bringing her killer to justice.
A true crime podcast episode exploring the 1985 disappearance of Jackie Johns in Nixa, Missouri, and the decades-long investigation.
On May 4, 2003, at sunrise, first responders entered a fire scene and found Katie still alive, though badly burned.
True Crime Brewery hosts Jill and Dick cover Dr.
Jill and Dick discuss the HBO documentary 'How to Create a Sex Scandal' about a child sexual abuse allegation at a swingers club in Mineola, Texas.
This episode discusses the unsolved 1966 murders of the Bricca family in Ohio, exploring theories including a love triangle and a connection to a friend's murder.
The episode explores the mysterious 2009 disappearance of the Jamison family in Oklahoma, discussing evidence and theories.
Jill and Dick recap a Dateline episode about a woman who calls 911 claiming her husband fell overboard after a stroke, but the case takes a suspicious turn.
The episode follows the Augustine family through a chain of sudden deaths.