SundanceTV and Sundance Now
41 episodes listed below
Crime stories, retold by someone the system got wrong.
Amanda Knox, who was tried and convicted of murder twice and spent four years in prison before her case was put right, examines how crimes become stories and how justice goes wrong. The seasons here include Killing for Love, Vigilante Justice and The Preppy Murder.
PRESS PLAY
The Truth About True Crime is an investigative series led by Amanda Knox, and the premise is personal. Knox was tried and convicted of murder twice. Four years of prison and eight years of trial passed before official justice, in her words, got it right, and she brings that history to other cases. Each season in this window carries its own title and its own case or theme. Killing for Love centers on Jens Soering and Elizabeth Haysom, two young lovers caught up in a brutal knife killing in a small town. Knox names the parallels outright: the flawed forensics, the media spectacle, the suspects turned into characters. She puts questions to Soering herself, including about the femme fatale image attached to Haysom, and she notes that in her own case she was cast in that role. She is careful with the record. Where the evidence against someone is only circumstantial, she says so. Where a claim cannot be verified, she says that too. The season widens to the human cost of error. Knox cites 2,438 U.S. exonerations at the time of recording and points out that Black people make up 13% of the population but 47% of exonerees. Vigilante Justice changes the angle without changing the core question. In Skidmore, Missouri, Ken Rex McElroy was shot dead in 1981, and the town's long silence becomes a way into frontier history and the legend of Jesse James. Elsewhere a father shoots Jeff Doucette, his son's abuser, in front of a television camera, and the son speaks about what actually helped him heal. Marv Hemeier's bulldozer rampage through a town's batch plant and town hall appears in the same episode. Knox calls vigilantism fundamentally selfish because it bypasses agreement and due process. A guest discusses how such stories split public opinion. The Preppy Murder returns to the killing of Jennifer Levin and the trial of Robert Chambers. A bonus conversation features Lorena (Bobbitt) Gallo. Knox keeps herself in view without taking over. That includes admitting how waiting for a European Court of Human Rights ruling on her slander conviction sent her back into fear.
Made for: Suits a listener who wants true crime that questions police methods, media labels and due process rather than simply reconstructing a crime, and who is comfortable with uncertainty about some allegations.
What sets it apart: Its host's own case took four years of prison and eight years of trial to resolve, so wrongful conviction, tabloid framing and the cost of error are examined from lived experience rather than from a distance.
In 1986, the body of affluent, beautiful, 18-year-old Jennifer Levin was found dead in Central Park. Her killer: Robert Chambers, a tall, handsome prep from the Upper East Side. He claimed she attempted to rape him and her death was an accident. Join host Amanda Knox as she deconstructs the stories behind the victim-blaming, privilege and media sensationalism that surrounded this murder and trial, as seen in the SundanceTV docu-series The Preppy Murder: Death in Central Park. The views, information or opinions expressed during this podcast are solely those of the individuals involved and do not necessarily represent those of AMC...
Based on 5 episodes we listened to · October 2026
Amanda Knox weighs wrongful convictions and vigilante killings through her own prison years, flagging thin evidence and refusing the labels that once stuck to her.
Amanda Knox spends her seasons asking how a crime turned into a story, and the question carries weight because she was once the story. She was tried and convicted of murder twice.
Amanda Knox, once the headline herself, investigates other people's cases and flinches at the femme fatale label.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A tense Orphan Black sample where a vague research job starts to sound like recruitment into something dangerous.
This sample drops Orphan Black: The Next Chapter back into a world where the clone secret has gone public, with Tatiana Maslany returning to voice the clones and Jordan Gavaris and Evelyn Brochu joining as Felix and Delphine.
A sober look at revenge, trauma, and why understanding a motive is not the same as endorsing it.
Vigilante Justice: Vendettas uses Gary Poche's attack on Jeff Doucette to sit with a hard tension: revenge can feel emotionally legible and still fail as justice. The clearest voice is Jody's adult perspective.
A sharp, reflective look at how Skidmore's vigilante silence fits into a much older Missouri history.
Vigilante Justice: No One Saw a Thing traces the Skidmore killing of Kendricks McElroy into a colder question: what happens when a community treats silence as justice. Amanda Knox frames the episode through the Sundance TV docuseries, then pulls back with Dr.
A restrained look at how punishment keeps taking pieces of a life after the case has become familiar.
Killing for Love: The Cost stays with the quieter damage of punishment after the headline version of a case has hardened. Amanda Knox centers the losses that rarely fit cleanly into true crime shorthand: a man losing fluency and ease in his native German, struggling for access…
A sharp chapter about labels, coercive pressure, and how character judgments can harden into a story that feels like proof.
The Black Box turns Killing for Love toward the language wrapped around Elizabeth: psychopath, femme fatale, disturbed young woman, the kind of labels that can start to feel like proof if they are repeated often enough.
Two friends narrate true crime cases, listener stories, and archived live-tour shows.
Multi-part true crime narration, from BTK's Wichita letters to Australian cold-case disappearances.
ABC Audio's Theranos fraud series that also introduces its other true-crime podcasts.
LA Times reporter Christopher Goffard traces con man John Meehan's fraud, abuse, and its Bravo TV adaptation.
Orphan Black comes back with the clones exposed.
Amanda Knox hosts this episode of The Truth About True Crime examining two vengeance-motivated vigilante cases: Gary Ploche, who shot his son Jody's child molester in the Baton Rouge airport in 1984 and received only five years probation, and Marvin Hemeyer, who spent years building an armored bulldozer to destroy Granby, Colorado in 2004 over a decade-long property dispute.
Skidmore's silence becomes the thing everything turns on.
Things you never expect to lose.
Labels do damage.