True crime argued through the evidence.
The Prosecutors treats true crime like a case file argued out loud. Brett and Alice move from jokes and side stories into timelines, search warrants, physical evidence, and the uncomfortable places where a neat theory starts to crack.
PRESS PLAY
The Prosecutors is a true-crime commentary show with courtroom instincts and conversational momentum. It is less interested in spooky texture than in what can be proved, challenged, or reasonably inferred. Brett and Alice bring a rhythm that moves fast, wanders freely, and then tightens around the evidence. The banter is part of the machinery. A pun, a weather complaint, a story about a cockpit, or an Olympic side road can sit beside a serious argument about wounds, timelines, or search warrants. That mix gives the show its shape: casual at the surface, legalistic underneath. Recent episodes show the range clearly. The Jade Beasley coverage centers on a brutal child murder, the claims around an intruder, trial materials, photos, and the meaning of injuries. The show repeatedly pushes listeners toward primary material where possible, which makes the analysis feel less like a fixed verdict and more like a guided review of the file. The Afroman legal brief shifts into criminal procedure, explaining probable cause, seized cash, returned money, and the ordinary machinery behind an extraordinary-feeling raid. Flight 19 broadens the frame into disappearance and aviation mystery, with dead reckoning and navigational uncertainty treated as the key facts before the Bermuda Triangle aura gets much room. Other episodes lean into cases where investigators reached incompatible conclusions that still appear to rest on coherent evidence. That is the show's sweet spot. It likes contradiction. It likes pressure-testing a story until the weak beams show. The tone can be dry, amused, blunt, and grave within minutes. It is not polished like a scripted documentary, and that is part of the appeal. The show feels like a long case conference where personality keeps the facts moving. The result is true crime for people who want the law, the evidence, and the argument, not just the mystery.
Made for: Best suited to true-crime listeners who enjoy legal reasoning, timeline work, and hosts who can move from jokes to grim facts without losing the thread. It fits people who want evidence weighed out loud rather than a hushed documentary treatment.
What sets it apart: Its edge is the prosecutor-minded case discussion: search warrants, probable cause, transcripts, physical evidence, and competing conclusions all get treated as part of the story. The loose banter makes the analysis feel conversational without draining the legal substance.
A true crime podcast with a different point of view. Every week, Alice and Brett bring their unique perspective as prosecutors to the most famous cold case mysteries of all time. Murder, mayhem, disappearances, you name it. If it's true crime, they're on the case. Custom case art by Hannah Hill. https://instagram.com/serious_moonlite?igshid=lhy8ijowoc9p
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Alice and Brett translate legal and evidentiary mechanics into clear case analysis while leaving room for listeners to assess source material themselves.
Alice and Brett make complicated case material easier to follow by pausing over the mechanics that can change an interpretation. In the Flight 19 discussion, they explain dead reckoning before considering the disappearance.
A trial transcript awaits you; Brett and Alice want you to check their work.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
An evidence-first look at wounds, the timeline, and the public record around a brutal killing.
The episode keeps its focus on the killing of a young girl, moving through the injuries, the forensic questions, and what the evidence can really support. The hosts are at their best when they slow the case down and explain the wound pattern without leaning on mood or spectacle.
A raid, a returned cash seizure, and a disputed $390 anchor the episode's legal argument.
The Prosecutors keeps this episode tightly on Afroman's raid, the seized $4,000, and the claim that $390 was missing when the cash came back. It follows the search warrant, the probable-cause logic behind civil asset forfeiture, and the fact that no charges were ever brought for…
A crude Olympic joke becomes a clear, curious look at ski-jump suits, tiny measurements, and competitive distance.
The Prosecutors After Dark takes a crude Olympic joke and turns it into a surprisingly practical question: how can a few extra centimeters of ski-jump suit material translate into real distance?
A Bermuda Triangle mystery that treats navigation as the real story.
The Prosecutors treats the Flight 19 story from the angle that matters first: five planes vanish into the Bermuda Triangle. From there, Brett and Alice move into the practical questions of navigation, dead reckoning, headings, wind, maps, and what a pilot could reasonably know…
A live year-end look back that mixes favorite cases, listener questions, and the practical messiness of making the show.
The episode revisits favorite cases, interviews, and listener questions, with Brett and Alice keeping the conversation loose and unmistakably their own.
A warm year-end check-in that makes the show's staying power feel earned.
The episode offers a warm, grateful look back at how The Prosecutors kept moving after many listeners expected it to end with West Memphis 3. It opens with thanks to the people who stayed, then settles into a clear account of how much has changed around the show, from shifting…
True crime with receipts and side-eye.
True crime with memory, evidence, and consequence.
Brett and Alice continue their deep dive into the West Memphis Three case, discussing the Hutchinsons and noting this is their longest series yet.
Hosts Brett and Alice, both prosecutors, review their fifth year of podcasting in 2025.
The Prosecutors Episode 281 is a year-in-review live conversation where Brett and Alice revisit 2024 cases, answer listener questions, and break down where their audience lives.
This episode analyzes the trials of the West Memphis 3, covering the legal proceedings and key evidence.
In 2014, out-of-work inventor Kenny Veach commented that a cave shaped like a "perfect Capital M" near Nellis Air Force Base made his "whole body" vibrate.
The Prosecutors' episode 358 on Jade Beasley turns on a 31-minute gap between Julia's phone returning home at 11:53 a.m.
A confidential informant told Adams County, Ohio deputies that Afro Man kept marijuana and women in a basement called the 'dungeon.' The warrant led a large armed team to break down his door, search the house, and seize $4,000 even though they found no marijuana, no captive women, and no charges followed.
The Prosecutors podcast introduces the case of 11-year-old Jade Beasley, who was stabbed to death, and questions the stepmother's story about an intruder.
Brett and Alice introduce a murder case where investigators reached four different but seemingly correct conclusions.
Brett and Alice continue their investigation into the mysterious disappearance of Flight 19, a squadron of five Navy torpedo bombers that vanished in 1945.
The Prosecutors hosts move from Birmingham's Sloss Furnaces and the Vulcan statue into a long Winter Olympics conversation about curling, skeleton, and bobsled.
The Prosecutors focus on Flight 19, five TBM Avenger torpedo bombers that left Fort Lauderdale on December 5, 1945 for navigation problem number one.
Brett and Alice introduce a true crime case about a man who murders his wife and daughter with unexpected twists.
Brett and Alice reflect on their fifth year in review episode, expressing gratitude for their listeners and discussing personal changes like having another child.
The prosecutors review alternative suspects in the West Memphis Three case.