TV pilots, judged by their first impression.
The Pilot's Club watches first episodes and asks whether they may or may not be worth a watch. Its conversations move through story setup, casting, tone, cultural context, and the odd details that make pilots revealing.
PRESS PLAY
The Pilot's Club is a television review show with a very specific obsession: the pilot episode. It treats first episodes as promises, sales pitches, rough drafts, and sometimes strange little artifacts that explain why a series did or did not survive. The format is simple. Kyle Springer and Melissa Wilkinson pick a pilot, watch it, and talk through what it seems to be trying to do. The conversation moves quickly. One moment may focus on story mechanics, and the next may jump to casting, production texture, channel context, old fandom habits, or whether a joke has aged into something funnier or flatter. That looseness is part of the appeal. The show does not sound like a lecture, but it does keep returning to craft. Shogun becomes a discussion of language barriers, pacing, insult, and the difference between a limited series and a film. Welcome to Eltingville opens up questions about early-2000s nerd culture, Adult Swim, comic shops, VHS, DVD, Pokemon, and whether the pilot gives its characters enough world to grow. Heat Vision & Jack brings out the pleasure of a deliberately cheap-looking cult comedy, complete with Jack Black, Christine Taylor, Vincent Schiavelli, gas station bits, and highly quotable absurdity. Reboot lets the discussion bounce between sitcom expectations, surprise reveals, Judy Greer, Keegan-Michael Key, and the show's attempt to signal that it has sharper teeth than its premise suggests. The Amazing Screw-On Head brings in gothic visuals, wordplay, Abraham Lincoln, and the odd fit between heavy Mignola-style design and very silly comedy. Animation is a recurring lane, but not the only one. Unaired pilots, short-lived experiments, prestige launches, and cult curios all belong here. The hosts are comfortable disagreeing lightly or refining each other's points. They also leave room for small digressions, which makes the analysis feel lived-in rather than overproduced. It is best for viewers who have watched too much TV and still like asking why a first episode works. The show finds drama in the earliest version of a series, before the formula settles and before the audience knows what will matter.
Made for: For TV fans who like conversational criticism, cult curiosities, animation history, sitcom structure, and the odd business of how first episodes sell a series. It especially suits listeners who enjoy analysis that keeps room for jokes and side paths.
What sets it apart: Instead of reviewing whole seasons, The Pilot's Club stays with the pilot as its own object. That narrow focus makes familiar shows feel newly unstable and gives failed, unaired, or overlooked projects a fair shot at being interesting.
The Whatnauts present The Pilot's Club, a Patreon exclusive podcast all about the first episodes of television shows. Join Melissa and Kyle as they watch and discuss a variety of TV pilots that catch their interest for a number of reasons. Some of the pilots may not have made it to air, others may have been particularly expensive to make, maybe the series was changed drastically after filming, or even something else just as interesting.
One television pilot, two verdicts, and enough strange details to keep your watchlist honest.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A sharp chat about Shogun's multilingual tension and ritual stakes.
The Pilot's Club frames Shogun as a study in how tension comes from translation, hierarchy, and public face-saving. Kyle Springer and Melissa Wilkinson keep circling the mix of English, Japanese, Spanish, and Portuguese, and that layering gives the discussion more shape than a…
An Adult Swim pilot talk that uses VHS, DVD, and Pokemon as era markers.
Pilots Club treats Welcome to Eltingville as an Adult Swim pilot grounded in a comic-book-store world, with anime on the shelves, VHS and DVD mentioned side by side, and a Pokemon joke that works as a clear era marker.
A sharp, detail-minded review of how Heat Vision & Jack makes cheapness part of the joke.
Heat Vision & Jack gives Pilots Club an easy way into a very odd one-off: Kyle Springer and Melissa Wilkinson treat its cheap-looking style as a deliberate comic tool, not just a limitation.
A lively Reboot pilot discussion about family secrets, tonal swings, and a sitcom finding its bite.
The Pilot's Club turns to Reboot, Hulu's 2022 sitcom, as Kyle Springer and Melissa Wilkinson track a pilot that keeps changing shape beneath them.
A gothic pilot is weighed for whether its jokes can keep pace with its own art style.
The Pilot's Club takes on The Amazing Screw-On Head with a sharp eye for its dark, heavy-lined art, eerie gothic shadow, and jokes about Mr. Groin, Emperor Zombie, and Abraham Lincoln.
Pop culture watch-alongs with managed chaos.
Retro TV, derailed with purpose.
British TV reviews with dry weekly friction.
Doctor Who talk with side roads.
Kyle Springer and Melissa Wilkinson revisit the two-part Lost pilot (ABC, September 22, 2004) for its 20th anniversary.
Kyle Springer and Melissa Wilkinson dig into the pilot.
Kyle Springer and Melissa Wilkinson spend the episode on Welcome to Eltingville.
Kyle Springer and Melissa Wilkinson review Heat Vision & Jack, a 1999 pilot created by Rob Schrab and Dan Harmon, directed by Ben Stiller, and starring Jack Black with Owen Wilson’s voice.
Kyle Springer and Melissa Wilkinson review Hulu’s 2022 sitcom Reboot, which brings the cast of the fictional 2002 family show Step Right Up back together almost 20 years later.
This episode of the Pilots Club podcast discusses the pilot episode of the Genndy Tartakovsky cartoon 'Unicorn Warriors Eternal' on Cartoon Network.
Melissa Wilkinson picks The Amazing Screw-On Head.
This episode of The Pilots Club discusses the unaired 2011 Wonder Woman pilot episode, analyzing its merits and whether it's worth watching.
This episode introduces The Pilots Club podcast, which analyzes pilot episodes of TV shows, focusing on the show Yasuke, and explains its release schedule and updates to the format.
This episode of The Pilots Club discusses the pilot episode of the NBC show The Endgame, analyzing its merits and initial impressions.
This episode introduces The Pilots Club podcast, which discusses pilot episodes of TV shows, with a focus on Doom Patrol, while explaining its Patreon release model and a brief, unrelated tangent about Band-Aids.
This episode introduces The Pilots Club, a podcast that reviews the pilot episodes of television shows, explaining its Patreon-exclusive release model and format evolution.