
Movie criticism after the bit takes over.
The gist
The Maestro Movie Podcast treats film criticism like a sleepover that wandered into a haunted video store. Episodes move from serious reads of Scream, Sky Captain, or 9 into running bits, fake calls, cursed party logic, and the Curiosity Wheel.
PRESS PLAY
Find your next episode
About The Maestro Movie Podcast
The Maestro Movie Podcast is a movie-review show with the wiring exposed. It sounds like a group conversation that begins with a film and keeps daring itself to become a sketch. That looseness is the point. Recent episodes move through Scream sequels, Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow, and 9 with a mix of genuine film literacy and reckless comic invention. The speakers can stop to admire Ortega’s consistency across a disrupted production schedule. They can also spend a cold open spiraling through a parody horror call, a favorite-scary-movie quiz, and a strange bit about clowns stealing a car. The criticism is more substantial than the chaos first suggests. Scream gets discussed through character choices, survivor logic, performances, killer reveals, and the way the series plays with audience suspicion. Sky Captain becomes a conversation about retro aesthetics, Lawrence Olivier’s image, old movies, digital sets, and whether the film arrived at the wrong cultural moment. Even 9 is framed against prior Bionicle viewing and questions of why some tiny animated figures are charming while others feel unsettling. Then the show immediately swerves. A bathroom break becomes time distortion. A fake weapon gag becomes wordplay. A closing sign-off mutates into a bizarre chant. The result is deliberately uneven in a way that gives the show personality: the film talk keeps anchoring the episode while the improvised nonsense keeps trying to pull it apart. It suits listeners who enjoy horror, genre oddities, cult-film detours, and conversations where a sincere observation can be interrupted by a bit and still survive. It is blunt, crude, and frequently absurd. It is also attentive to the movies. That combination is its identity: a review podcast that lets the room become part of the review.
Made for: Best for listeners who like loose, irreverent movie conversations with real genre analysis underneath the chaos. It especially fits fans of horror sequels, cult curios, and comedy that treats derailment as part of the format.
What sets it apart: The show’s edge is the way improvised lore and movie criticism share the same space. A scene breakdown can sit beside a fake horror call, a Curiosity Wheel tease, or a running absurd premise without the episode losing its movie-review core.
In their own words
Four guys discuss movies, attempt improv, and subject themselves to omnipotent roulette wheels that decide what movies they review.
Talks about
Podcasts like The Maestro Movie Podcast
ShxtsNGigsPressure, teasing, and chaotic comic timing.
Smosh MouthSmosh chaos, left in the room.
Hey Riddle RiddleRiddles as bait, derailments as sport.
supermegashowFast riffs, bad premises, committed chaos.
JAR Media PosdactAbsurd riffs, ranked badly and fast.
Nerd PokerD&D at Brian Posehn's table, jokes included.
Episodes
- 1
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Scream (2022)
Hidden gem["The Maestro Movie Podcast uses Scream (2022) to trace how Radio Silence went from early YouTube shorts and branching choose-your-own-adventure videos to directing Scream 5.", "Chris and Alex spend much of the episode on Matt Bettinelli-Ophine, Tyler Gillett, Justin Martinez, and Chad Bleyha, including the VHS short, Devil's Due, Southbound, and Ready or Not.", "The review also covers the Scream rights shift after the Weinstein collapse, the three-season MTV series, and the cast-and-writers meetings that brought Neve Campbell, Courteney Cox, David Arquette, and Kevin Williamson back.", "Alex and Chris emphasize the film's \"for Wes\" tribute, the brutality of the kills, and the toxic-fandom jokes around Stab 8 and Rian Johnson without spoiling the ending."]
May 29, 2025·1h 45m·5 clips - 2
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Scream 4
May 29, 2025·2h 7m - 3
The Maestro Movie Podcast: March 24th, 2024
May 29, 2025·3h 28m - 4
The Maestro Movie Podcast: March 17th, 2024
Apr 28, 2024·2h 40m - 5
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Scream 3
Four friends prank call each other and discuss favorite scary movies in a comedic improv style.
Apr 28, 2024·1h 41m·2 clips - 6
The Maestro Movie Podcast: March 10th, 2024
Apr 28, 2024·2h 35m - 7
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Scream 2
Apr 28, 2024·2h 22m - 8
The Maestro Movie Podcast: March 3rd, 2024
Apr 13, 2024·3h 32m - 9
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Scream
Apr 13, 2024·2h 16m - 10
The Maestro Movie Podcast: February 25th, 2024
Apr 4, 2024·2h 1m - 11
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Labyrinth
Apr 4, 2024·3h 30m - 12
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow
Hidden gemThe Maestro Movie Podcast examines Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow, a 2004 film made with a reported $70 million budget that earned about $58 million.
Feb 25, 2024·1h 49m·5 clips - 13
The Maestro Movie Podcast: January 14th, 2024
Feb 25, 2024·2h 47m - 14
The Maestro Movie Podcast: December 3rd, 2023
Feb 25, 2024·2h 32m - 15
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Starcrash
Feb 25, 2024·2h - 16
The Maestro Movie Podcast: December 17th, 2023
Feb 25, 2024·2h 14m - 17
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Gangs of New York
Feb 25, 2024·2h 27m - 18
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Varsity Blues
Feb 25, 2024·2h 28m - 19
The Maestro Movie Podcast: February 18th, 2024
Feb 25, 2024·3h 26m - 20
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Fight Club
Feb 25, 2024·2h 7m - 21
The Maestro Movie Podcast: February 4th, 2024
Feb 25, 2024·3h 7m - 22
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Bumblebee
Feb 25, 2024·2h 35m - 23
The Maestro Movie Podcast: January 28th, 2024
Feb 25, 2024·3h 13m - 24
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Hard Ticket To Hawaii
Feb 25, 2024·2h 16m - 25
The Maestro Movie Podcast: January 21st, 2024
Feb 25, 2024·2h 7m - 26
The Maestro Movie Podcast: 9
Hidden gemFour friends improvise a ridiculous scenario about dolls scratching at the door and a DNA-enabled gun.
Jan 21, 2024·1h 32m·2 clips - 27
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Bionicle: The Legend Reborn
Jan 21, 2024·3h 57m - 28
The Maestro Movie Podcast: November 9th, 2023
Jan 21, 2024·3h 35m - 29
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Doom (2005)
Sep 21, 2023·2h 59m - 30
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Bionicle Web of Shadows
Sep 21, 2023·4h 26m - 31
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Bionicle Legends of Metru Nui
Sep 21, 2023·4h 41m - 32
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Bionicle Mask of Light
Sep 21, 2023·4h 40m - 33
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Josee, The Tiger, and The Fish
Sep 21, 2023·4h 6m - 34
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Little Bigfoot
Sep 21, 2023·2h 53m - 35
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Beetlejuice
Sep 21, 2023·4h 46m - 36
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Office Space
Sep 21, 2023·3h 16m - 37
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Limbo
Sep 21, 2023·3h 36m - 38
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Army Of Darkness
Jul 3, 2023·3h 39m - 39
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Evil Dead II: Dead By Dawn
Jul 1, 2023·4h 48m - 40
The Maestro Movie Podcast: The Evil Dead
Jul 1, 2023·4h 16m - 41
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Toys
Jul 1, 2023·3h 7m - 42
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Cop Car
Jun 30, 2023·4h 8m - 43
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Pinocchio: A True Story
Jun 30, 2023·4h 4m - 44
The Maestro Movie Podcast: A League Of Their Own
Jun 29, 2023·4h 32m - 45
The Maestro Movie Podcast: The Wicker Man (2006)
Jun 29, 2023·4h 33m - 46
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Ravenous
Jun 29, 2023·3h 26m - 47
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Booksmart
Jun 29, 2023·5h 15m - 48
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Chopping Mall
Jun 29, 2023·5h 55m - 49
The Maestro Movie Podcast: The Princess Bride
Jun 29, 2023·4h 42m - 50
The Maestro Movie Podcast: Pride, Prejudice, and Zombies
Jun 29, 2023·4h 23m