The Immaculate Deception

22 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

In their own words

Fertility doctor Jan Karbaat was renowned for getting amazing results. Women who were desperate for children would visit him at his Rotterdam clinic and leave pregnant. But when the clinic closed, rumours began about the methods Karbaat used to achieve his success. The children conceived at the clinic - the Karbaat Kids - began asking difficult questions about what happened to their mothers. What happened in Dr Karbaat’s clinic? From Somethin’ Else, The Immaculate Deception is a story about a doctor who was determined to create life - by any means possible. Reported and hosted by Jenny Kleeman.This is a Somethin' Else production.

Why you'd press play

A dead doctor's recorded interview can only go so far; you'll want to hear his children's questions.

Press play if you want

  • to understand what an anonymous father means when you need your family's medical history
  • to hear Jenny Kleeman test the doctor's "client happy" defense against the mothers' accounts
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Talks about

Best episodes of The Immaculate Deception

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

BONUS : Making The Immaculate DeceptionMay 13, 2020

Jenny Kleeman revisits the reporting choices, ethical pressure, and personal interviews behind The Immaculate Deception.

This making-of bonus returns Jenny Kleeman to spring 2017, when reporting on the Carbat case and Tim Booters' effort to have Carbat's DNA extracted first pulled her into the story.

7: The KarbastardsApr 29, 2020

Natalie's search for her donor father turns a fertility scandal into a family question with medical stakes.

Jan Corbat's fertility-clinic abuses are framed through mothers who say they carried his children and donor-conceived people trying to absorb what it means to share his DNA.

6: The Nose Hair TrimmerApr 22, 2020

A donor-conception investigation turns darker when the doctor at its center is confirmed dead.

A search for identity darkens into a more troubling investigation as donor-conceived adults press for answers about the doctor at the center of their case.

Podcasts like The Immaculate Deception

  • Crime JunkieAudiochuck

    Cold cases, hard questions, and the paperwork behind them.

  • My Favorite MurderExactly Right and iHeartPodcasts

    Crime stories with room for the tangent.

  • Casefile True CrimeCasefile Presents

    Lives, evidence and the cost of missed warnings.

  • The DropoutABC News

    ABC Audio's Theranos fraud series that also introduces its other true-crime podcasts.

  • Dirty JohnLA Times Studios

    LA Times reporter Christopher Goffard traces con man John Meehan's fraud, abuse, and its Bravo TV adaptation.

  • Dr. DeathAudible

    Spoon tricks, stock charts, and a snowbank in Vermont

Episodes

  1. 1

    Fatal Beauty - Dead Husbands, Stolen Identities, and a Socialite on the Run

    Apr 22, 2025·5m
  2. 2

    From Cradle to Cash: The Dark Dealings of the Baby Broker

    Feb 19, 2025·8m
  3. 3

    Night Shift - Inside A Hospital's Deadly Mystery

    Sep 9, 2024·4m
  4. 4

    Doctor Miracle - Inside the Luxury Wellness Ranch With a Dark Secret

    Jul 2, 2024·5m
  5. 5

    Introducing Power: Don King

    Mar 17, 2022·11m
  6. 6

    Introducing: BioHacked: Family Secrets

    Mar 11, 2022·8m
  7. 7

    Introducing Power: Hugh Hefner

    Nov 1, 2021·5m
  8. 8

    Introducing Hemingway's Picasso

    Oct 18, 2021·7m
  9. 9

    Introducing The Fault Line: Dying for a Fight

    Sep 13, 2021·7m
  10. 10

    Introducing... Cheat!

    May 27, 2021·7m
  11. 11

    Introducing... The Doodler

    Apr 1, 2021·8m
  12. 12

    Introducing... Power: The Maxwells

    Jan 13, 2021·8m
  13. 13

    BONUS : Making The Immaculate Deception

    Hidden gem

    ["Jenny Kleeman and producer Paul Smith use this bonus episode of The Immaculate Deception to explain how a spring 2017 Dutch DNA dispute over Carbat became a story about mothers, secrecy, and fertility medicine.", "Kleeman says pregnancy with her second child made the case visceral, because she kept thinking about women lying back during gynecological exams and trusting doctors who told them not to tell anyone.", "The reporting widened from Joey and Natalie to Marsha, Inga, and Lydia in Benidorm, while the team also visited the Barendrecht clinic and kept pushing for a mother willing to speak.", "The episode lands on Rita Carbat, the appetite for apology over damages, and the lingering taboo around male infertility and donor sperm."]

    May 13, 2020·24m·1 clip
  14. 14

    BONUS: An Update from Anne

    May 6, 2020·22m
  15. 15

    7: The Karbastards

    Hidden gem

    The Immaculate Deception episode 7, “The Karbastards,” follows Jenny Kleeman as she traces Jan Corbat’s legacy through Dutch families he affected.

    Apr 29, 2020·39m·2 clips
  16. 16

    6: The Nose Hair Trimmer

    Hidden gem

    The Immaculate Deception episode "The Nose Hair Trimmer" follows Laura Bosch and Tim Butos as they try to prove that Dutch fertility doctor Jan Carbat used his own sperm and altered donor records.

    Apr 22, 2020·31m·2 clips
  17. 17

    5: The Mother

    An investigation into Dutch fertility doctor Jan Karbaat who fathered over 60 children using his own sperm without patients' consent.

    Apr 15, 2020·37m
  18. 18

    4: The American Connection

    Jenny Kleeman investigates whether Jan Corbat transported his own sperm to Miami and San Francisco, after reports of thousands of samples passing through customs once and being destroyed another time.

    Apr 8, 2020·36m·2 clips
  19. 19

    3: The Last Interview

    Hidden gem

    Camille Balluck describes his 2016 interview with fertility doctor Jan Carbat, who had used his own sperm to father at least 60 children without mothers’ knowledge or consent.

    Apr 1, 2020·35m·2 clips
  20. 20

    2: The Super Donor

    The episode begins with a Home Depot ad, then the host describes discovering a photo grid of the Karbaat kids and reflecting on the doctor's motives.

    Mar 25, 2020·27m
  21. 21

    1: The Clinic

    The episode introduces the story of Dr.

    Mar 18, 2020·30m
  22. 22

    Introducing The Immaculate Deception

    Mar 2, 2020·3m