Draft-week Giants talk that stays loose, live, and grounded in roster questions.
This hour finds The Giants Collective in draft-week mode, with the conversation centered on what the Giants might do if the roster starts getting trimmed hard.
The Giants Collective: A Show About the New York Giants
Creator Collective, HMA
149 episodes listed below
Listen to the show on
Giants arguments with roster math attached.
The gist
The Giants Collective turns New York Giants news into a rolling group debate. Bad Dog, Anthony, Chris, Adriana, and The Entertainer work through draft boards, roster tension, depth-chart gaps, and fan chat questions with brisk, informal energy.
PRESS PLAY
Find your next episode
About The Giants Collective: A Show About the New York Giants
The Giants Collective is a New York Giants roundtable with the pace of a live stream and the patience of fans who have argued through every roster hole already. It is not polished desk analysis. It is messier, more immediate, and more useful for listeners who want to hear how a take gets stress-tested in real time. Episodes often begin with whatever is loudest in Giants world: Dexter Lawrence trade tension, Joe Schoen comments, John Harbaugh remarks, owner-meeting updates, draft rumors, or a new signing such as Daniel Faalele. From there, the group starts sorting consequences. A possible Dexter Lawrence move becomes a debate about defensive tackle depth, Kayvon's long-term value, trade compensation, and whether the team would be forced back into the draft for interior help. A draft-board question becomes a discussion about need versus value. A right guard concern turns into a bigger look at whether the roster can survive another thin spot up front. The show is especially comfortable in draft season. Mock drafts, top-five scenarios, running back arguments, Ohio State pro day chatter, and trade-back math all show up as recurring pressure points. The live chat is part of the texture, not a side channel. Questions and comments feed the next tangent, and the group answers them with a mix of fan frustration and cap-and-depth-chart reasoning. Bad Dog, Anthony, Chris, Adriana, and The Entertainer give the show its rotating-room feel. Some episodes lean into absence and substitution, with Anthony filling in or the group noting who is away, which adds to the casual, stream-adjacent rhythm. The result is Giants coverage for fans who want the emotional temperature left in. It is blunt, busy, and heavily invested in what every rumor would actually mean on Sundays.
Made for: Built for New York Giants fans who follow draft boards, roster construction, trade rumors, and live fan debate closely. It best suits listeners who already know the names and want opinionated discussion rather than a slow news recap.
What sets it apart: The show stands out through its roundtable chemistry and live-chat rhythm. It turns every Giants rumor into a practical argument about contracts, depth charts, positional value, and what the team would have to do next.
In their own words
Welcome to The Giants Collective, a roundtable show that provides an authentic and entertaining look at New York Giants. Every Wednesday and Friday, YouTube personalities Baddog Sports, The Entertainah, Empire State Sports Report and Fireside Giants discuss and dissect all things Big Blue.
As heard by us
Based on 5 episodes we listened to · September 2026
A candid Giants roundtable that traces draft and roster decisions through their consequences across the depth chart.
The Giants Collective turns New York Giants roster questions into open roundtable arguments. Baddog Sports, The Entertainah, Empire State Sports Report and Fireside Giants weigh draft choices, free agency, injuries and possible reunions, with enough disagreement to expose the…
Why you'd press play
Giants roster dominoes keep falling until your imaginary depth chart needs its own emergency meeting.
Press play if you want
- your draft crush tested against roster needs, trade value, and the unforgiving NFC East
- multiple Giants obsessives arguing through picks instead of handing you one polished verdict
Giants mock draftsDexter Lawrence trade talkJoe Schoen roster decisionsright guard competitionrun defense needstrade-back valueowner-meeting updateslive chat Q&A
Talks about
Best episodes of The Giants Collective: A Show About the New York Giants
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A loose Giants update that turns meeting-room chatter into the football details that matter.
The Giants talk gets its best footing when it moves through the owners meetings and lands on Harbaugh, Shane, OBJ, and JPP as names with real weight.
A Giants draft discussion that keeps coming back to run defense as the central need.
This Giants discussion keeps circling back to one point: the run has to get stopped. Caleb Downs comes off as the elite run defender, while Sunny Styles is presented as the better pick if the grades match.
A Giants-heavy draft debate that turns roster pressure and Shane's contract into a sharp, focused listen.
The show stays firmly in Giants territory, with right guard competition, the draft clock, and the unsettled question of what Joe Shane can do with the fifth pick. It turns a roster hole into a careful argument about value, leverage, and the risks of trading down. The St.
A blunt, conversational Giants free-agency recap with fan-side debate and a little wandering.
Giants Collective takes a loose, conversational pass through free agency, with Audrana, Anthony, and Chris offering competing reads on the Giants' haul and where it leaves the team.
Podcasts like The Giants Collective: A Show About the New York Giants
49ers Rush Podcast with John Chapman49ers Chapman Media LLC49ers draft talk with real roster stakes.
Episodes
- 1
Giants vs. Cardinals Preview + Cowboys Land Joey Porter Jr.
Oct 2, 2026·1h 2m - 2
Giants TRADE for J.J. McCarthy + Titans Recap & What’s Next at QB?
Sep 30, 2026·1h 5m - 3
Is the Giants’ Season Already Over? QB Options + Giants vs. Titans Preview
Sep 25, 2026·1h 15m - 4
Giants-Rams Recap: Injury Scares & MAJOR Defensive Concerns
Sep 23, 2026·1h 43m - 5
Are the Giants for Real? Giants vs. Rams Preview + Q&A
Sep 18, 2026·1h 14m - 6
Giants Week 1 Preview: Will Malik Nabers Play? + Score Predictions & Q&A
Sep 12, 2026·1h 7m - 7
Giants vs. Cowboys Week 1 Preview: Slayton Released, Jameis & Runyan Extended
Sep 10, 2026·1h 23m - 8
Giants 2026 Season Preview: Expectations, Breakout Players & Q&A
Sep 4, 2026·1h 5m - 9
Giants 53-Man Roster Reaction: Biggest Surprises, Cuts & Takeaways
Sep 2, 2026·1h 21m - 10
Giants vs. Jets Preview | Who Will Make the Final 53?
Aug 28, 2026·1h 22m - 11
Giants vs. Dolphins Recap + Malik Nabers Is Full Go
Aug 26, 2026·1h 31m - 12
Giants Defense Dominates, Dart's Best Practice Yet + Dolphins Preview
Aug 21, 2026·1h 8m - 13
New York Najee + Preseason Performances | Giants Collective
Aug 19, 2026·1h 10m - 14
Giants Preseason Preview: QB Matchup, CB Rotation & Can Harbaugh Stay Undefeated?
Aug 14, 2026·1h 26m - 15
Giants Camp Update: Dart Praised, Injury News & Kyler Murray Named Starter
Aug 12, 2026·1h 16m - 16
Giants Practice Recap: Injury Updates, RRH to IR & Beaux Collins Waived
Aug 7, 2026·1h 8m - 17
Arvell Reese Is DOMINATING Giants Camp + Offensive Struggles
Aug 5, 2026·1h 7m - 18
Giants Training Camp Underway: Nabers & Skattebo Return, Jaxson Dart Shines
Jul 31, 2026·1h 25m - 19
Giants Training Camp Begins: Biggest Storylines, Position Battles & Players to Watch
Jul 29, 2026·1h 13m - 20
Giants Training Camp Takeaways + A Positive Malik Nabers Update
Jul 24, 2026·1h 5m - 21
Giants Training Camp Preview: Key Battles & Skattebo’s Backflip
Jul 23, 2026·1h 3m - 22
Giants Stock Up, Stock Down | Players to Watch Before Training Camp
Jun 19, 2026·1h 12m - 23
Giants Collective Q&A + Knicks Finals Talk
Jun 12, 2026·1h 1m - 24
Giants Kick Off Minicamp!
Jun 10, 2026·1h 7m - 25
OBJ Is Back | Giants WR Signings + Kicker Competition
Jun 3, 2026·1h 6m - 26
New York Giants News + BIG Q&A!
May 30, 2026·1h 7m - 27
New York Giants Off-Season Q&A + Knicks Talk
May 28, 2026·1h 3m - 28
Joe Schoen Extension Talk + Giants DL Depth Concern
May 24, 2026·1h 6m - 29
Giants Town Hall Reaction | OTA Takeaways, Nabers & Skattebo Injury Updates + Q&A
May 21, 2026·1h 1m - 30
Reacting to the Giants’ 2026 Schedule + Nabers’ 2nd Surgery
May 15, 2026·1h 16m - 31
Giants Home Opener | Rookie Minicamp + Brown Presser
May 13, 2026·1h 7m - 32
Giants Sign Shelby Harris | OBJ Next_ + Schedule Predictions
May 8, 2026·1h 5m - 33
Giants DL Signings Are NOT Done | DJ Reader Next? + OBJ Talk + Q&A
May 1, 2026·1h 3m - 34
New York Giants Draft Recap!
Apr 29, 2026·1h 23m - 35
Final Giants Collective Mock Draft + Q&A
Apr 24, 2026·1h 1m - 36
Dexter Lawrence TRADED | Odell Beckham Back with Giants?! + Q&A
Apr 22, 2026·1h 32m - 37
The NFL Draft Is One Week Away! Giants Collective Mock Draft
Hidden gemThe panel starts with the Giants sitting a week out from the NFL Draft and quickly gets into pre-draft roster math.
Apr 17, 2026·1h 37m·5 clips - 38
Cowboys Trying to Jump Giants?! | Schoen Presser + Dexter Lawrence Update
The hosts discuss NFL draft rumors involving the Cowboys and Giants, provide updates on Dexter Lawrence and Joe Schoen's press conference, and promote their upcoming mock draft series.
Apr 16, 2026·1h 5m - 39
Giants Sign Daniel Faalele! New Starting Guard?
The hosts discuss the New York Giants' signing of offensive lineman Daniel Faalele and analyze his potential role as a starting guard.
Apr 10, 2026·1h 16m - 40
Dexter Lawrence Demands a TRADE!
The hosts of Giants Collective react to Dexter Lawrence's trade request from the New York Giants, discussing its implications and whether it's a negotiation tactic.
Apr 8, 2026·1h 25m - 41
Should Giants Take an RB at #5? Draft Targets, Roster Holes + Q&A
The hosts discuss the New York Giants' draft strategy, including whether to take a running back at pick #5, and answer fan questions about roster needs.
Apr 3, 2026·1h 10m - 42
Giants Owners Meetings: OBJ Reunion, Playoff Plans + Skattebo & Leek Updates
Hidden gemThe show opens with casual Giants banter, noting that the usual host is out and that Bad Dog is away on his yearly Disney World trip.
Apr 1, 2026·1h 9m·4 clips - 43
John Harbaugh & Giants Scout Ohio State Pro Day!
Hidden gemThe panel opens with its familiar loose banter.
Mar 27, 2026·1h 5m·4 clips - 44
RG Competition Is Weak! | Waddle Traded… Is AJ Brown Next?
Hidden gemGiants Collective opens with St.
Mar 18, 2026·1h 10m·4 clips - 45
Giants Free Agency Recap!
Hidden gemGiants Collective opens on the Giants' free agency haul.
Mar 13, 2026·1h 29m·5 clips - 46
Giants are COOKING in Free Agency! | Recap & Reaction
Mar 11, 2026·1h 11m - 47
Giants Getting Ready for Free Agency!
Mar 6, 2026·1h 12m - 48
Giants Scouting Combine Recap! | Sonny Styles at 5?!
Mar 4, 2026·1h 7m - 49
Giants Getting Ready for the Scouting Combine!
Feb 25, 2026·1h 1m - 50
Giants Free Agency Is Coming!
Feb 18, 2026·1h 23m - 51
The 2025 NFL Season Is Over | What’s Next for the Giants?
Feb 11, 2026·1h 1m - 52
Harbaugh Continues to Fill Out Giants Staff!
Feb 7, 2026·1h 44m - 53
Giants Coaching Staff Coming Together!
Feb 5, 2026·1h 19m - 54
Giants OC Search + Eli Manning Snub Reaction | Live Q&A
Jan 30, 2026·1h 28m - 55
Giants Coaching Shakeup, DC Hire & What to Do With Pick #5? Q&A
Jan 28, 2026·1h 35m - 56
Major Changes Coming: Giants Fire Kevin Abrams
Jan 23, 2026·1h 19m - 57
Giants Make it Official!
Jan 21, 2026·1h 10m - 58
BREAKING: THE GIANTS HAVE HIRED JOHN HARBAUGH
Jan 16, 2026·1h 44m - 59
The Waiting Game
Jan 14, 2026·1h 22m - 60
Harbaugh in play
Jan 10, 2026·1h 5m - 61
Giants Head Coaching Search Begins
Jan 8, 2026·1h 30m - 62
The end is near.
Jan 5, 2026·1h 3m - 63
Even when The Giants Win, they Lose!
Dec 31, 2025·1h 22m - 64
Wan’Dale 1,000 Yards_ Dart Bounce-Back + Injury Updates
Dec 27, 2025·1h 6m - 65
One step closer
Dec 24, 2025·1h 14m - 66
Giants at a Crossroads: Dart Concussion CONTROVERSY & Vikings Preview
The hosts discuss the New York Giants' recent game, including cold weather conditions and a quiet atmosphere, while teasing upcoming topics about a concussion controversy and a Vikings preview.
Dec 19, 2025·1h 10m - 67
Should Joe Schoen Be FIRED Before the End of the Giants’ Season?
Dec 17, 2025·1h 10m - 68
Giants keep 1st pick in draft
Dec 15, 2025·1h 10m - 69
One GIANT Mess..
Dec 12, 2025·1h 44m - 70
4 Games to go!
Dec 10, 2025·1h 18m - 71
A Giant Letdown..
Dec 3, 2025·1h 25m - 72
Giants take on Patriots
Nov 29, 2025·1h 2m - 73
New York Giants finally fire Shane Bowen
Nov 26, 2025·1h 35m - 74
Giants have a shot at Lions?
Nov 21, 2025·1h 8m - 75
New York Giants nightmare season continues
Nov 19, 2025·1h 11m - 76
Brian Daboll Was a Tyrant!
Nov 14, 2025·1h 31m - 77
New York Giants Fire Brian Daboll
Nov 12, 2025·1h 37m - 78
Giants vs Bears Preview! Will Gano Play
This episode previews the upcoming Giants vs Bears NFL game, discussing whether kicker Graham Gano will play, while acknowledging the team's tough season and engaging with fans.
Nov 7, 2025·1h 21m - 79
New York Giants Season Over
Nov 5, 2025·1h 37m - 80
Injury Bowl: Giants vs Niners
The hosts discuss the New York Giants' disastrous season, focusing on injuries to key rookies like Malik Neighbors and Cam Scadamore, and provide updates on their recovery timelines.
Oct 31, 2025·1h 3m - 81
New York Giants Destroyed in Philly
Oct 29, 2025·1h 13m - 82
Can The Giants Shock The World Again
Oct 24, 2025·1h 13m - 83
New York Giants Get Avalanched in Denver
Oct 22, 2025·1h 22m - 84
Will Giants Make Blockbuster Trade For A Wide Receiver? | Broncos Preview
This episode previews the Giants' upcoming game against the Broncos while discussing potential trades for a wide receiver and analyzing the NFC East standings.
Oct 17, 2025·1h 19m - 85
New York Giants DESTROY Philadelphia Eagles!
Oct 15, 2025·1h 17m - 86
Giants vs Eagles TNF Preview
A preview of the Giants vs Eagles Thursday Night Football game, focusing on the Giants' challenges with a shorthanded team and the growth of rookie quarterback Jackson Dart.
Oct 10, 2025·1h 1m - 87
Giants Disappointing Loss In New Orleans...
Oct 8, 2025·1h 5m - 88
Can The Giants Make It 2 In A Row?
Oct 3, 2025·59m - 89
A Giant Start!
Sep 26, 2025·1h 8m - 90
Giants Starting Jaxson Dart in Week 4!!
Sep 24, 2025·1h 23m - 91
Can the Giants Actually Beat The Chiefs?
Sep 19, 2025·1h 11m - 92
Recapping the Giants’ heartbreaking loss to the Cowboys
Sep 17, 2025·1h 38m - 93
Can The Giants Bounce Back vs Cowboys In Week 2?
Sep 12, 2025·1h 2m - 94
New Year, Same Giants?
Sep 11, 2025·1h 8m - 95
Giants vs. Commanders: Everything You Need to Know
Sep 5, 2025·1h - 96
Giants Week 1 Preview: Yards, TDs & Final Score Predictions
Sep 3, 2025·1h 20m - 97
Giants News: Andrew Thomas Injury, Parsons Trade & NFC East Preview
Aug 30, 2025·1h 1m - 98
Giants Final Roster Breakdown: Who Made the 53?
Aug 28, 2025·1h 10m - 99
Giants Crush Patriots | Dart Shines | Roster Cuts Looming?
Aug 23, 2025·1h 16m - 100
Giants Destroy Jets! Daboll, Russ & Pats Game Talk!
Aug 21, 2025·1h 21m - 101
Everything You Need to Know Before Giants vs. Jets Showdown...
Aug 16, 2025·1h 25m - 102
Breaking Down The Giants First Preseason Game
Aug 14, 2025·1h 21m - 103
Everything You Need To Know Before Giants Vs Bills + Jaxson Dart Debut
Aug 9, 2025·1h 5m - 104
New York Giants Cornerback Battle Heats Up!
Aug 7, 2025·1h 3m - 105
The Giants Continue To DOMINATE Training Camp!!
Aug 2, 2025·1h 16m - 106
Top STANDOUTS From New York Giants Training Camp!
Jul 31, 2025·1h 5m - 107
Who is STANDING OUT in New York Giants Training Camp?!
Jul 26, 2025·1h 8m - 108
New York Giants Training Camp Day One REACTIONS! How is the Giants Roster Taking Shape?
Jul 24, 2025·1h 3m - 109
New York Giants Minicamp Takeaways! How Do YOU Think the Team is Progressing??
Jun 19, 2025·1h 1m - 110
New York Giants OTA's Recap! Potential of the Giants Defense
Jun 14, 2025·1h 2m - 111
New York Giants Minicamp Analysis! What's Happening Around Giants Minicamp?
Jun 12, 2025·1h 2m - 112
New York Giants OTA Recap! How Did Jaxson Dart Do With the Second Team Offense??
Jun 7, 2025·1h 2m - 113
The LATEST on the New York Giants OTA's! What Are YOUR Expectations for the Giants Defense??
Jun 5, 2025·1h 5m - 114
New York Giants OTA Day One REVIEW & RECAP! What Stood OUT From Today?
May 29, 2025·1h 4m - 115
New York Giants Mailbag! Send in YOUR Questions For the Giants Collective!
May 24, 2025·1h 3m - 116
What are YOU Expecting for New York Giants OTA's?? Who Do You Think Will STAND OUT?
May 22, 2025·1h 4m - 117
New York Giants Mailbag! What are YOU Looking to See from Rookie/Training Camp?
May 17, 2025·59m - 118
New York Giants SCHEDULE LEAKS with Bobby Skinner!
May 15, 2025·58m - 119
New York Giants Q&A! What Are Your Expectations for the Giants This Year??
May 10, 2025·1h 5m - 120
New York Giants UDFA BREAKDOWN | Should the Giants Have Interest in Gabe Davis??
May 8, 2025·1h - 121
New York Giants MAILBAG! How Would YOU Grade the Giants' Offseason?
May 3, 2025·1h 1m - 122
New York Giants Draft Recap! How do YOU Think the Giants Did??
May 1, 2025·1h 5m - 123
Welcome to the New York Giants, Abdul Carter and Jaxson Dart! Who is Next?
Apr 26, 2025·1h 11m - 124
NFL Draft PREVIEW! Could the New York Giants TRADE BACK UP to the First Round?!
Apr 24, 2025·1h 18m - 125
New York Giants Collective Mock Draft! Which Prospects Make the MOST SENSE for NY??
Apr 19, 2025·1h 5m - 126
Joe Schoen New York Giants Press Conference REACTIONS! Top 30 Visits Insights
Apr 17, 2025·1h 17m - 127
Latest Giants Draft Rumors - Could the Giants TRADE UP for a QB?!
Apr 11, 2025·1h 5m - 128
Latest New York Giants Draft RUMORS
Apr 9, 2025·1h - 129
New York Giants NEWS & RUMORS Surrounding Colorado's Pro Day
Apr 5, 2025·1h 18m - 130
Who Should the New York Giants Select at #3 Overall?
Apr 3, 2025·1h 8m - 131
New York Giants Mailbag: Answering Your Most URGENT Draft Questions
Mar 31, 2025·1h 6m - 132
BREAKING: NEW YORK GIANTS SIGN RUSSELL WILSON
Mar 26, 2025·1h 31m - 133
BREAKING: Giants SIGN Jameis Winston
Mar 24, 2025·1h 36m - 134
What's Next for the New York Giants QB Situation?!
Mar 21, 2025·1h 7m - 135
Giants Mock Draft: Schoen Predicted to Land A Franchise Quarterback
Jan 30, 2025·1h 2m - 136
Giants Mailbag: Answering Your Most URGENT Offseason Questions
Jan 23, 2025·1h 4m - 137
What Do the Giants Need to Do to Have a GREAT Offseason?
Jan 16, 2025·1h 2m - 138
Brian Daboll and Joe Schoen Are BACK: Will it Work for the Giants?
Jan 9, 2025·1h 4m - 139
Will the Giants WIN another MUST LOSE Game in Week 18?
Jan 3, 2025·59m - 140
Will the Giants LOSE Their Draft Position Over the Next Two Weeks?
Dec 27, 2024·1h 15m - 141
Will the Giants Draft Shedeur Sanders if They Have The First Overall Pick?
Dec 19, 2024·1h 19m - 142
Who Should Coach the New York Giants in 2025?
Dec 6, 2024·1h 1m - 143
A GIANT MESS Before Thanksgiving Showdown with the Cowboys
Nov 28, 2024·1h 2m - 144
What Is the Impact of Benching Daniel Jones?
Nov 21, 2024·1h - 145
Giants WON'T Commit to Daniel Jones as the Team's QB Moving Forward
Nov 14, 2024·1h 5m - 146
Will This Be Daniel Jones' Last Start as a Giant?
Nov 7, 2024·1h - 147
Can the Giants Pull it Together for Week 9 Against the Commanders?
Oct 31, 2024·58m - 148
Concerns About Daniel Jones Grow After Eagles Demolish Giants
Oct 24, 2024·59m - 149
Saquon Barkley Returns, Andrew Thomas Out for Season, Will Malik Nabers Play?
Oct 17, 2024·1h