The Crit Talkers Podcast

Crit Talkers Enterprises

87 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

Fast dice, weird creatures, louder table.

The gist

The Crit Talkers Podcast runs fantasy adventures with the table fully in the room: dice math, scene corrections, bad ideas, and all. Its best moments turn tactical confusion into comedy, then let the danger snap back into focus.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About The Crit Talkers Podcast

The Crit Talkers Podcast is a D&D actual play with the shape of a real table left intact. It does not hide the dice. It lets rules questions, character bits, bad rolls, and tactical confusion live beside the fantasy scenes. Recent episodes show a group that can be knee-deep in danger and still make room for a throwaway voice, a creature-name debate, or a joke about the exact wrong mutation arriving at the exact wrong time. That loose rhythm gives the show its identity. In Kingdom of Legacy, the action moves through strange caves, goblin crowds, fireworks, trolls in security shirts, magic swords, portal warnings, and a flame creature that becomes part of the problem. In the Overgrown play sessions with creator Ben Newbon, the table leans hard into transformed bodies, animal senses, cavern eggs, snapping pincers, and the practical absurdity of solving problems without the right limbs. The comedy is quick. The danger is still present. Characters get blinded, bitten, confused, damaged, and forced into choices that sound ridiculous until the mechanics make them serious. Jake the GM gives the scenes enough structure to keep them moving, while Britt, Shane, Chris, Ryan, and others push at plans from inside the mess. The show is especially good when a tactical decision turns into a bit and then, a moment later, becomes the thing the whole encounter depends on. It has sponsor reads and community updates around the edges, but the main draw is the table energy. The feed favors fantasy action with oddball horror color, comedy in the middle of combat, and players who sound comfortable derailing themselves before finding the plot again. It suits listeners who like actual play with visible seams, audible laughter, and enough rules chatter to feel like sitting near the battle map.

Made for: Best for tabletop role-playing fans who like actual-play podcasts with audible mechanics, quick jokes, and messy group problem-solving. It fits listeners who enjoy fantasy combat and strange creature encounters without needing polished audio-drama formality.

What sets it apart: Its edge is the openly game-like texture: rolls, corrections, tactical talk, sponsor breaks, and running bits all stay in the frame. The table turns odd creature design and failed plans into momentum instead of smoothing them away.

In their own words

The Crit Talkers Podcast is a fiction forward D&D actual play podcast. Campaign one is about 3 new adventurers with powerful gifts they don’t fully understand set on a path to discover a secret that may cause the destruction of the last kingdom in the world. If you like stories with comedy, action and adventure but with an undercurrent of dark, ancient Eldritch secrets, Then look no further! Britt plays Frey the rogue, a street urchin who decides to step up when his beloved orphanage is threatened. Shane plays Uther Dukem the Bard, a guardsman turned dockworker that accepted an...

As heard by us

Based on 5 episodes we listened to · August 2026

A lively actual play for listeners who enjoy tactical rulings, character chaos, and fantasy problems worked out at the table.

The Crit Talkers Podcast fits Leisure's gaming shelf as an actual play with long scenes, visible rules talk, and a taste for fantasy trouble that gets stranger the longer the table sits with it.

Read our full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A lobster-bunny menace and a mosh-pit battle make your standard fantasy quest look underdressed.

Press play if you want

  • your fantasy peril interrupted by dice jokes and gloriously questionable tactical choices
  • combat turns with fireworks, troll security, and a flame creature that powers up when burned
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
D&D actual playKingdom of Legacy adventuresOvergrown play sessionsfantasy combat mechanicsstrange animal mutationsgoblin and kobold encountersRoll20 and tabletop toolscommunity announcements

Talks about

Best episodes of The Crit Talkers Podcast

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

KoL Vignette 2 Let's Play Overgrown Part 3 (w/creator Ben Newbon!)Apr 15, 2026

A cave fight, an empty egg, and a mewing mystery keep the table off balance.

Crit Talkers Podcast's Overgrown Part 3 keeps its cave fight moving through body-joke comedy and a very suspicious egg. Hugh heads up into a tree for a better vantage point, the table keeps noting that there are more creatures than expected, and the action is tracked out loud as…

KoL Vignette 2 Let's Play Overgrown Part 2(w/creator Ben Newbon!)Apr 8, 2026

A messy, funny crawl that turns a fight into shared dungeon riffing.

This episode keeps its focus on a table that is clearly having fun with the chaos. It opens with sponsor housekeeping and a reset from the previous part, then moves into a fight that gets noisy, tactical, and a little ridiculous in the best way.

KoL Vignette 2 Let's Play Overgrown Part 1 (w/creator Ben Newbon!)Mar 25, 2026

A carnival crawl where one bad roll turns the scene into a running creature joke.

The Crit Talkers Podcast settles into Heckna, a 5e carnival horror adventure that blends court gestures, Victorian circuses and sideshows, and the campy energy of 1980s flicks.

C1 Season 2 Ep 57 KoL Fuel for the FlameJan 28, 2026

A chaotic carnival fight where table banter carries the scene.

Crit Talkers here favors momentum over polish, and that is the point. Goblin parades, troll bouncers in security shirts, fireworks that can blind, and a scene that keeps mutating give the episode a carnival-fantasy charge.

C1 Season 2 Ep 56 KoL Visions in the SnowJan 14, 2026

A snowy cave brawl with messy tactics, bad dice, and a very odd cliffhanger.

This episode leans into a snowy cave scramble where confusion, frost, and poor sightlines do as much harm as the creatures themselves. Its main draw is how clearly the mechanics stay in view: Uther wonders whether clearing the spores might help, patches himself up, and keeps…

Podcasts like The Crit Talkers Podcast

Episodes

  1. 1

    Sound the Gjallarhorn Horn! | Project Infinite ep 2 | Ragnaborg

    Jul 22, 2026·44m
  2. 2

    A Sad Disney Like Movie | Project Infinite ep 1 | Ragnaborg

    Jul 15, 2026·34m
  3. 3

    Don't Talk About My Stick | Kingdom of Legacy ep 65 | D&D5.5

    Jul 8, 2026·30m
  4. 4

    Dance, Dance | Kingdom of Legacy ep 64 | D&D5.5

    Jul 1, 2026·39m
  5. 5

    Little Bit of Dance Revenge | Kingdom of Legacy ep 63 | D&D5.5

    Jun 24, 2026·29m
  6. 6

    Announcement

    Jun 10, 2026·1m
  7. 7

    The House of Sic Beats! | Kingdom of Legacy ep 62 | D&D5.5

    Jun 3, 2026·33m
  8. 8

    Deeper down the Spider's Hole | Kingdom of Legacy ep 61 | D&D5.5

    May 27, 2026·32m
  9. 9

    Spooky Spider, Kinda Scary | Kingdom of Legacy ep 60 | D&D5.5

    May 20, 2026·33m
  10. 10

    The Engineer (no, not that one)| Kingdom of Legacy ep 59 | D&D5.5

    May 13, 2026·36m
  11. 11

    More Secrets Laid Bare | Kingdom of Legacy ep 58 | D&D5.5

    May 6, 2026·30m
  12. 12

    Rufus at last | Kingdom of Legacy | Overgrown RPG 5

    Apr 29, 2026·31m
  13. 13

    Where's Rufus? | Kingdom of Legacy | Overgrown RPG 4

    Apr 22, 2026·35m
  14. 14

    KoL Vignette 2 Let's Play Overgrown Part 3 (w/creator Ben Newbon!)

    Hidden gem

    The table drops back into a cavern skirmish full of strange bodies and improvised tactics.

    Apr 15, 2026·34m·2 clips
  15. 15

    KoL Vignette 2 Let's Play Overgrown Part 2(w/creator Ben Newbon!)

    Hidden gem

    Ben takes over the table.

    Apr 8, 2026·46m·3 clips
  16. 16

    KoL Vignette 2 Let's Play Overgrown Part 1 (w/creator Ben Newbon!)

    Hidden gem

    Heckna opens the door.

    Mar 25, 2026·34m·2 clips
  17. 17

    KoL Vignette 1 Explosive Bargaining Part 2

    This episode continues a Dungeons & Dragons actual play adventure where players, using characters created on KOL.com, are tasked by Legacy Coffer Co.

    Mar 11, 2026·59m
  18. 18

    KoL Vignette 1 Explosive Bargaining

    This episode features a sponsor segment for Roll20's Curse of Strahd Remastered module and introduces the misfits group in a gaming context.

    Feb 25, 2026·46m
  19. 19

    Announcement

    Feb 11, 2026·2m
  20. 20

    C1 Season 2 Ep 57 KoL Fuel for the Flame

    Hidden gem

    Heckna opens with a carnival grin.

    Jan 28, 2026·48m·3 clips
  21. 21

    C1 Season 2 Ep 56 KoL Visions in the Snow

    Hidden gem

    The cave fight opens cold.

    Jan 14, 2026·54m·3 clips
  22. 22

    C1 Season 2 Ep 55 KoL Initiating Payload

    Dec 31, 2025·39m
  23. 23

    C1 Season 2 Ep 54 KoL Derailed Plans

    Dec 17, 2025·46m
  24. 24

    C1 Season 2 Ep 53 KoL The Great Train Robbery

    Dec 3, 2025·1h 5m
  25. 25

    C1 Season 2 Ep 52 KoL To Hold or Let Go

    Nov 19, 2025·54m
  26. 26

    C1 Season 2 Ep 51 KoL The Shadowy Figure

    Nov 5, 2025·49m
  27. 27

    C1 Season 2 Ep 50 KoL A Shark in the Wheat Field

    Oct 22, 2025·55m
  28. 28

    C1 Season 2 Ep 49 The 'Ole Dusty Trail

    Oct 8, 2025·54m
  29. 29

    C1 Season 2 Ep 48 KoL Everyone is the Bad One

    Sep 24, 2025·1h 6m
  30. 30

    Companion Episode to Ep 47

    This companion episode announces a new Roll20 partnership with free content updates, the release of an official trailer, and the launch of a Discord community with special perks for early joiners.

    Sep 15, 2025·22m
  31. 31

    Trailer for Kingdom of Legacy

    Sep 14, 2025·2m
  32. 32

    C1 Season 2 Ep 47 KoL Church League Baller

    Sep 10, 2025·1h 12m
  33. 33

    C1 Season 2 Ep 46 KoL Cat, Keg, Cake, Kaoroke

    Aug 27, 2025·58m
  34. 34

    C1 Season 2 Ep 45 KoL Casino Calamity

    Aug 13, 2025·1h
  35. 35

    C1 Season 2 Ep 44 KoL Pineapple Upside Down Cake

    This episode features a sponsor segment for Roll20's Curse of Strahd Remastered module and continues the narrative of the Kingdom of Legacy campaign, including character interactions and plot developments.

    Jul 30, 2025·1h 2m
  36. 36

    C1 Season 2 Ep 43 KoL Beach Group Hang

    Jul 16, 2025·1h 2m
  37. 37

    C1 Season 2 Ep 42 KoL King's Quest

    Jul 2, 2025·52m
  38. 38

    C1 Season 2 Ep 41 KoL 2 Curses, 1 Disease

    Jun 20, 2025·47m
  39. 39

    C1 S2 Ep 41 KoL 2 Curses, 1 Disease

    Jun 18, 2025·48m
  40. 40

    A Quick Primer on the Kingdom of Legacy

    Jun 11, 2025·11m
  41. 41

    Season 1 KoL Recap: Cutscenes part 2

    This episode continues Season 1 cutscenes exploring what characters Jim, Mark, Stacy Bishop, and Malice were doing while others dealt with creatures, murder, and the Shard Realm.

    Jun 4, 2025·24m
  42. 42

    KoL Blooper Reel 1

    This episode features a blooper reel from the podcast, including unused player introduction clips and an ad for Roll20's Curse of Strahd Remastered module.

    May 28, 2025·26m
  43. 43

    Tavern Talk Jen and Ryan Edition

    May 21, 2025·1h 3m
  44. 44

    Season 1 KoL Recap: Cutscenes

    This episode consolidates cutscenes from Season 1 of a D&D campaign to provide a continuous story flow, featuring flashbacks and narrative elements that tie into the main plot.

    May 14, 2025·35m
  45. 45

    C1 Ep 40 KoL Secrets Laid Bare

    May 7, 2025·1h 58m
  46. 46

    Tavern Talk 2 (Looking back at Ep 7-12)

    Apr 30, 2025·1h 33m
  47. 47

    C1 Ep 39 KoL Welcome To Your Worst Nightmare

    Apr 23, 2025·52m
  48. 48

    Tavern Talk 1 (Looking back at Ep 1-6)

    Apr 16, 2025·1h 4m
  49. 49

    C1 Ep 38 KoL A Battle at the Gala Part 2

    Apr 9, 2025·1h 2m
  50. 50

    C1 Ep 37 KoL A Battle at the Gala part 1

    Apr 2, 2025·1h
  51. 51

    C1 Ep 36 KoL Gala Part 3 (Basking Bay)

    Mar 26, 2025·39m
  52. 52

    C1 Ep 35 KoL Gala Part 2 (Single and Ready to Mingle)

    Mar 19, 2025·33m
  53. 53

    C1 Ep 34 KoL Gala part 1

    Mar 12, 2025·34m
  54. 54

    C 1 Ep 33 KoL GUY Hates Mods

    Mar 5, 2025·1h
  55. 55

    Divergent Lore Content (DLC) 1 KoL

    Feb 26, 2025·45m
  56. 56

    C1 Ep 32 KoL Let Your Freak Flag Fly

    Feb 19, 2025·48m
  57. 57

    C1 Ep 31 KoL The Gang Splits Up

    Feb 12, 2025·53m
  58. 58

    C1 Ep 30 KoL Soup and Suit Deal

    Feb 5, 2025·43m
  59. 59

    C1 Ep 29 KoL Listened Too Hard

    Jan 30, 2025·38m
  60. 60

    C1 Ep 28 KoL Still Toadally Confused

    Jan 22, 2025·49m
  61. 61

    C1 Ep 27 KoL The Rat, The Book, and the Flesh

    Jan 15, 2025·47m
  62. 62

    C1 Ep 26 KoL Research Hard, Party Harder

    Jan 8, 2025·49m
  63. 63

    C1 Ep 25 KoL Don't Listen Too Hard

    Jan 1, 2025·51m
  64. 64

    Mixed Drinks at Marc's Place | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 24 | D&D 5E

    Dec 25, 2024·47m
  65. 65

    Shard Realm Quandry | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 23 | D&D 5E

    Dec 18, 2024·50m
  66. 66

    Come Undone | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 22 | D&D 5E

    Dec 11, 2024·58m
  67. 67

    KoL Put a Bird On It | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 21 | D&D 5E

    Dec 4, 2024·47m
  68. 68

    Guy and Ruby | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 20 | D&D 5E

    Nov 27, 2024·45m
  69. 69

    Oops, All Murder | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 19 | D&D 5E

    Nov 20, 2024·58m
  70. 70

    Uther's Tall Tales | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 18 | D&D 5E

    Nov 13, 2024·43m
  71. 71

    The NETwork Makes Connections | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 17 | D&D 5E

    Nov 6, 2024·45m
  72. 72

    The Boys Are Back In Town | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 16 | D&D 5E

    Oct 30, 2024·46m
  73. 73

    KoL Ridin' Dirty | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 15 | D&D 5E

    Oct 23, 2024·47m
  74. 74

    Weird Creatures Strike Back | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 14 | D&D 5E

    Oct 16, 2024·48m
  75. 75

    Can't See Past the Weekend | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 13 | D&D 5E

    Oct 9, 2024·49m
  76. 76

    Late Night Legalese | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 12 | D&D 5E

    Oct 2, 2024·39m
  77. 77

    Tasty Pastries and a Feline Fiesta | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 11 | D&D 5E

    Sep 25, 2024·46m
  78. 78

    Rise of the NETwork | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 10 | D&D 5E

    Sep 18, 2024·42m
  79. 79

    Big Pink Bird | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 9 | D&D 5E

    Sep 11, 2024·53m
  80. 80

    Toadally Confused | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 8 | D&D 5E

    Sep 4, 2024·53m
  81. 81

    Catchin' Crabs | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 7 | D&D 5E

    Aug 28, 2024·45m
  82. 82

    Drinks With Frank | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 6 | D&D 5E

    Aug 21, 2024·45m
  83. 83

    The Ostrich Dance | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 5 | D&D 5E

    Aug 14, 2024·41m
  84. 84

    Any Weird Creature | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 4 | D&D 5E

    Aug 7, 2024·54m
  85. 85

    Dipping Through the Alley | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 3 | D&D 5E

    Jul 31, 2024·50m
  86. 86

    Find The Pretty Lady | Kingdom Of Legacy Ep 2 | D&D 5E

    Jul 24, 2024·42m
  87. 87

    The Beginning-ing | Kingdom of Legacy EP 1 | D&D 5E

    Jul 21, 2024·39m