Case files told through the evidence trail.
The Crime Shack tells notorious murders and disappearances by following the evidence: timestamped texts, stops caught on surveillance video, autopsy findings, a maid's account of a replaced sofa. Host Michelle Pence narrates cases involving Thomas Capano, Suzanne Morphew, Timothy Jones Jr. and others in a plain, steady register.
PRESS PLAY
The Crime Shack is a true crime podcast hosted by Michelle Pence, and it tells its cases through evidence. Episodes move from one finding to the next. Small facts carry much of the weight: a purchase, a timestamp, a piece of furniture that has been swapped out. The Timothy Jones Jr. episode shows the method at full stretch. It follows a father driving through South Carolina, Georgia, Alabama and Mississippi with the bodies of his five children in the back seat of his Cadillac Escalade. Along the way he stops for gas and meals, buys trash bags, chemicals, goggles and a jabsaw, and searches online for extradition laws and dump sites. The narration notes that surveillance video caught him at several stops behaving as if nothing were wrong. The Suzanne Morphew episode runs on the clock instead. First a message at 2:03 p.m., then a move to WhatsApp and a bikini photo investigators called her last proof of life, and finally a 2:26 p.m. text from her husband Barry that got no reply. In the Thomas Capano case the telling details are domestic: a maid who noticed a replaced sofa and carpet, an oriental rug bought two nights after Anne was reported missing, a dumpster emptied at a brother's request, a fishing boat sold. The FBI and a federal grand jury enter that story too. Some of the material is hard going. The Christopher Porco episode gives Peter Porco's autopsy findings in clinical detail. The episode on Greg Mulvihill and Diana Lovejoy follows a shooting that investigators came to treat as intentional, and Diana's odd reaction to the news drew their attention. Forensic and digital threads recur across cases, from a towel sent for DNA analysis to the phone behind an anonymous call to a suspect's search history. Sometimes the context goes beyond a single case, as when the Natascha Kampusch episode cites missing-children figures from the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, the FBI and the International Center for Missing and Exploited Children. The register is plain and direct. The narration stays close to the record and lets the order of events build the tension. Episodes come with listener-discretion advisories, and one flags crimes against children specifically. It suits a listener who wants to understand how a case was actually put together, one piece of evidence at a time.
Made for: Suits a listener who wants true crime told through the record, with timestamps, search histories, witness accounts and forensic findings laid out in clear order.
What sets it apart: The episodes are built from small, concrete details, like a maid noticing a replaced carpet, a text sent at 2:03 p.m. or a stop caught on surveillance video, so each case builds the way an investigation does.
The Crime Shack is a true crime podcast covering cold cases, unsolved murders, missing persons, infamous crimes, and current cases with clear, fact-based storytelling. We focus on real victims, verified sources, and updates when new information emerges. Topics we cover: cold cases, unsolved murders, missing persons, serial killers, current investigations, case updates, wrongful convictions, forensics, trials, crime psychology.
A burner phone points to Best Buy; you get the clue trail, minus the detective badge.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A father's eight-day drive turns a missing-person case into a grim account of concealment and relentless movement.
Five children vanish after a missed planned exchange visit, and the episode follows how their father became the focus of an eight-day drive through South Carolina, Georgia, Alabama, and Mississippi with their bodies in his Cadillac Escalade.
A family crime story built around conflicting statements, digital traces, and the painful overlap of evidence and emotion.
The Crime Shack returns with the Christopher Porco case, following the attack on Peter and Joan Porco and the questions that gathered around their son's role in it.
ABC Audio's Theranos fraud series that also introduces its other true-crime podcasts.
LA Times reporter Christopher Goffard traces con man John Meehan's fraud, abuse, and its Bravo TV adaptation.
The Crime Shack opens on the 2014 Alabama recovery of five children ages 1 to 8, after their father led investigators to the bodies near Camden.
This episode investigates the unsolved murder of Agnes Wanjiru, a Kenyan woman allegedly killed by a British soldier.
Host Michelle Pence introduces a listener-supported true crime podcast covering cold cases and unsolved murders, with a focus on victim stories and case updates.
The Crime Shack ties Christopher Porco to the November 2004 attack on Peter and Joan Porco with a yellow Jeep Wrangler, toll tickets, and a 911 call that Christopher says began with a Times Union tip.
Greg Mulvihill followed a fake investigator's instructions and found a camouflaged rifleman waiting near a Carlsbad trail.
The Crime Shack examines Suzanne Morphew’s May 2020 disappearance from Maysville, Colorado, after her mountain bike was found undamaged and her family could not reach her on Mother’s Day.
The Crime Shack examines Thomas Capano, a wealthy Delaware lawyer and political figure accused of killing Anne Marie Fahey after she tried to end their affair.
The episode discusses global statistics on missing children and introduces the show's focus on cold cases and unsolved crimes.
Host Michelle Pence introduces her new true crime podcast, which will cover cold cases, unsolved murders, and current investigations with fact-based storytelling.