PJ and Nick
187 episodes listed below
Wisconsin sports, loose grip, strong takes.
The Bullpen with PJ & Nick treats Wisconsin sports like a group chat that learned how to keep score. Brewers slumps, Badgers wins, jersey curses, old baseball rants, and wrestling detours all get worked over with loose, fast, familiar banter.
PRESS PLAY
The Bullpen with PJ & Nick is a Wisconsin sports show that sounds most alive when the main topic keeps getting interrupted by better side quests. Brewers baseball drives much of the recent run. A losing streak becomes the Wisco jersey curse. An injury update turns into a room-wide sigh. A blown lead gets treated less like a box-score item and more like proof that the baseball gods have gotten personal. The show can still make the sports point, though. It talks through ballpark dimensions, record sanctity, roster quirks, and why certain numbers feel less holy once the stadium itself starts shaping the game. Then it swerves. Wrestling comes up as a generational ritual, with WrestleMania and Tyson-event watch parties framed as the kind of shared spectacle that still pulls friends into the same room. Old baseball rants become family listening material. Jersey customization turns into a miniature customer-service saga. Giveaway bat days and Wrigley road trips come back as evidence that childhood fandom had sharper edges and better souvenirs. The mood is quick and informal. Segments often begin with a bit, a song cue, a traffic-style goof, or a loose question before the sports talk fully arrives. Caller and text-line moments add to the feeling that the show is being steered by a local room rather than a clean rundown. That is part of its appeal. The Bullpen with PJ & Nick is not trying to sound national, polished, or detached. It is rooted in Wisconsin Sports, local sponsors, familiar frustrations, and the kind of sports memory that turns a single Brewers game into a running joke. The humor is irreverent but usually warm. The analysis works because it is mixed with lived-in fandom: curses, group chats, prop bits, family stories, and an ongoing willingness to admit that sports can be very serious and very silly at the same time. For the right audience, that combination is the hook.
Made for: For Wisconsin sports fans who like Brewers, Badgers, wrestling detours, local callbacks, and banter that moves faster than a formal segment sheet. Best for listeners who enjoy opinionated sports talk with local looseness.
What sets it apart: The show treats sports analysis and ridiculous side arguments as part of the same conversation. Its edge comes from turning local fandom, old broadcasts, jersey curses, caller lines, and wrestling memories into running context rather than filler.
Need a little relief? That's what the Bullpen is for! PJ & Nick will give you their thoughts on everything Wisconsin Sports and then some! Just like in real life, you never know what's coming out of the Bullpen!
Based on 5 episodes we listened to · September 2026
PJ and Nick turn Brewers frustration, Wisconsin loyalties and deep sports memory into sharp, funny conversation between friends.
PJ and Nick turn Wisconsin sports talk into an ongoing argument between friends, with the Milwaukee Brewers providing much of the fuel. They move comfortably from bullpen failures and Christian Yelich's hamstring trouble to ballpark dimensions, baseball records, Jordan Love, the…
A Brewers losing streak becomes a curse investigation, with wrestling detours waiting in the on-deck circle.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A loose WrestleMania preview that treats wrestling as a shared ritual and lets the nostalgia do the work.
PlayNext frames The Bullpen's WrestleMania preview around a simple point: wrestling still works best as something people watch together. The discussion keeps circling back to sons, friends, adults, Tyson, Logan Paul, and old-school references, and that loose movement gives it an…
A Brewers six-game skid becomes a funny, furious curse hunt.
The episode keeps circling the Brewers' six-game slide and turns it into a long, exasperated joke. It never loses sight of the plain problem: this team keeps finding fresh ways to lose, and the frustration feels local, immediate, and hard to shake.
A loose, call-driven sports hour that turns old baseball rants into the best side road.
The Bullpen with PJ and Nick spends its time doing what good sports radio does best: taking a small prompt and stretching it into a longer, funnier argument.
A loose sports-radio hang that turns one jersey gripe into a full nostalgia detour.
The episode begins with PJ and Nick circling a very specific question about the all-time favorite sports statement to the media, and that narrow hook gives the conversation a funny sense of purpose.
A sharp reminder that baseball records only mean something when the park and era stay in frame.
Sports records here are treated as products of place, not just talent or habit. County Stadium's 315 feet, Wrigley Field's thin foul room, Cecil Fielder, Richie Sexton, and the Jordan Love comparison all point in the same direction: the numbers only make sense when the setting…
Fast takes, sharp turns, loud sports arguments.
Cavaliers playoff detail, every day.
Mrs.
PJ and Nick open with their WrestleMania preview and quickly turn it into a wider conversation about why wrestling still feels like a shared event.
This episode of The Bullpen with PJ & Nick features sponsor ads, a brief introduction, and the hosts discussing their recent losing streak ending and a promotion for free burgers.
The Brewers are the whole story here.
The hosts discuss a sports injury clip from an interview on Big Brother's show, where a manager reveals a player has a strain and will miss about a month of time.
Two friends discuss the Milwaukee Brewers' poor performance while wearing new Wisco jerseys, blending sports talk with humorous banter.
PJ and Nick kick things off with weekend jokes and traffic banter, tossing around too-relatable lines about being ready to get out of work.
PJ and Nick open gently.
They kick off with the familiar baseball-record argument.
PJ and Nick open by predicting a brawl as the Brewers, 8-2, face Wilson Contreras and the other Contreras brother, who has been hit by Brewers pitchers 24 times.
PJ and Nick open The Bullpen on April 6, 2026 with vacation stories, including a 67-minute drive to a dinner seven miles away in Hilton Head and cannonball jellyfish washing up at Gulf Shores.
This episode of The Bullpen with PJ and Nick is a lighthearted sports show that humorously celebrates St.
PJ and Nick discuss the heavy snowfall and traffic conditions in Green Bay while being stranded at home during a live broadcast.
Two friends discuss humorous anecdotes about church experiences, including home parish advantages and collections, while joking about riverboat gambling and making beef jerky.
This episode features a brief interview with Jason Slade, the on-field host for the Green Bay Packers and UW-TV Phoenix, discussing the men's and women's basketball teams advancing to the tournament, Barbasol sponsorship, and ticket giveaways.
This episode discusses Team USA's opportunity to win a gold medal in men's hockey against Team Canada, referencing the historic Miracle on Ice from 46 years ago.