Tiny topics, fast tangents, excellent derailments.
Shut Up a Second turns low-stakes prompts into fast, messy comic arguments. Lemonade stands, eye floaters, spines, butter, Dalmations, bananas, and skiing all become excuses for misread words, personal detours, and escalating nonsense.
PRESS PLAY
Shut Up a Second is a comedy show built from small topics, quick interruptions, and the shared delight of making an ordinary phrase sound wrong in a useful way. It starts simply. One week the subject is eye floaters; another week it is skiing, butter, spines, bananas, Dalmations, lemonade stands, or the dermis. The topic matters, but mostly as a launchpad. A minor body oddity becomes a debate about what the eye is doing, what the brain is hiding, and whether anyone has understood the science closely enough to repeat it. A conversation about spines opens into the underrated senses, including balance and knowing where one's arms are. Then someone admits that geographical direction may be the missing sense. That is the show's preferred altitude: slightly informed, loudly uncertain, and moving fast enough that uncertainty becomes part of the joke. It has a sharp ear for repeated words. A mispronounced or over-literal phrase can become the whole room's temporary toy, passed around until it loses shape. Guests such as Adam Carnevale, Zoe Bee, Lauren Bonner, Grace Jarvis, Sammy Petersen, Maddy Weeks, and Ashley Apap give individual episodes their own charge, but the core energy remains a crowded comic conversation that keeps folding back on itself. It likes practical details. Embroidery, the function of collagen, ugly supportive shoes, bananas in cargo holds, and the social threat of a strange hat all get treated as worthy material. There are facts here, sometimes. There are also corrections, doubts, and confident guesses that get punctured almost immediately. Shut Up a Second works best when the group is fact-checking a silly idea just enough to make the silly idea stronger. It is irreverent without needing a grand target. The comedy comes from friction, bodily specificity, social embarrassment, and the panic of trying to complete a thought while several other people are improving it badly. Listeners looking for a clean topic journey may bounce off the chaos. Listeners who enjoy fast associative banter will find a show that turns every mundane object into a pile-up of callbacks, technical half-knowledge, and strangely durable phrases.
Made for: Best for comedy listeners who like loose banter, odd facts, bodily absurdity, and jokes that evolve through interruption. It suits anyone who enjoys a topic being cheerfully wrecked by the people discussing it.
What sets it apart: The show stands out by making the correction process part of the comedy. It does not just drift from topic to topic; it keeps turning misunderstandings, repeated phrases, and half-remembered facts into running bits.
Come and sit down with us as we discuss a wide variety of dumb topics. Wanna know the history of cowboys? What about facts about bread? It doesn't matter, just shut up and listen. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Everyday topics become collaborative riffs as Cass Page, Hayden and their guests turn distractions, anecdotes and stray facts into comic momentum.
Shut up a Second takes an ordinary noun, puts it within reach of Cass Page, Hayden and a guest, then watches conversational comedy overwhelm the assignment.
A breathing chat loses a guest to a backyard cat; your tolerance for detours decides the rest.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A lemonade stand bit that keeps getting dragged sideways by crop tops, collagen, and panel chaos.
Shut Up a Second turns a child's lemonade stand into a loose argument about how kids make money, and that simple setup keeps splintering into comic mess.
A Dalmatian bark question drifts into Hamnet, Shakespeare, and Bananas in Pyjamas.
Shut Up a Second opens on Dalmatians, then lets a plain dog question tip the room into stranger territory. Hayden, Cass Page, and guest Maddie Weeks turn elegant barks, long noises, noses, and sounds into a run of quick fixes and repeated misunderstandings.
Bananas, shipwrecks, and survivorship bias turn a loose panel chat into a very specific kind of chaos.
Shut Up A Second circles back to bananas and lets the odd facts stack up, from ethylene gas in the fruit bowl to bananas floating off a shipwreck and leaving the cargo hold looking cursed.
A skiing prompt slides into cocaine slang before ugly shoes take over.
Skiing turns into a test of class, pain, and footwear on Shut Up a Second, as Cass and Hayden admit they have never tried it, mark it as rich-people business, then drift straight into skiing as cocaine slang.
Burps, cream ads, TV work, and Melbourne flag grumbling keep the riff moving.
The episode settles into gross-out wordplay, with burps, dragonborn lore, digestion jokes, and a cream-based antacid gag all feeding the same loose comic run.
Lauren Bonner's firm handshake, fragrant arrival, and a House guessing game send the senses sideways.
Lauren Bonner's in-person visit gives this single-episode review an easy hook, turning a firm handshake and fragrant hair into the start of a wider conversation about the senses.
A Sydney Airbnb hangout that turns breathing into cat chaos, couple-comic riffing, and lung jokes.
Breathing with Ruby Innes and Jackson Baly starts as a Sydney Airbnb hangout and gradually folds into a scene of steady interruption: the glass doors are left open to soften the echo, a cat shows up in the backyard, Ruby climbs the fence to touch it, and Jackson arrives…
Tiny debates, treated with heroic seriousness.
This episode features a humorous conversation with guest Alasdair Tremblay-Birchall from Canada, where the hosts playfully discuss the concept of becoming twins later in life.
Hosts Cass and Hayden welcome guest Lauren Bonner for a meandering conversation that begins with sensory perception and directional disorientation.
Hosts Cas and Hayden are joined by guests Ruby Innes and Jackson Baly in a Sydney Airbnb to discuss breathing, but the conversation quickly derails with a cat wandering into the backyard.
The hosts debate whether glass is a liquid, with Adam Carnevale arguing it's not and suggesting it's an urban myth related to old window thickness.
This episode features an interview with Ruby Innes and Zoe Bee discussing rubies and precious gems.
The hosts of Shut Up a Second introduce a humorous episode about little boys, featuring banter and a song reference.
The hosts discuss the topic of nuts, with humorous banter about related ideas like seeds and bolts, and explore simple machines such as levers and wedges.
Hayden, Cass Page, and Adam Carnevale open with a crop-top bit.
The hosts discuss eye floaters, sharing personal experiences and exploring what they are, including whether they're caused by eye gunk or brain perception.
This episode features a comedic interview with Lauren Bonner discussing human senses, including balance and direction, in a lighthearted and humorous way.
Comedian Grace Jarvis discusses her merchandise ideas, including humorous hat designs and fan interactions at her shows.
The hosts discuss the complexities of friendship and sibling relationships through personal anecdotes, including a story about a friend going through a breakup who repeatedly says 'I've got no one to talk to' during phone calls.
Shut Up a Second's 'Dalmations with Maddie Weeks' opens with Hayden, Cass Page, and Maddie Weeks joking about Dalmatians' 'long noises' and whether their bark is dignified.
Hayden opens by clearing his throat, and the whole thing happily slides into nonsense from there.
Shut Up a Second's skiing episode has Cass, Hayden, and guest Ashley Apap joking that skiing is rich-people behavior, then rebranding skiing as cocaine slang with ski emojis and snow emojis.
The episode starts with burps.