50 episodes listed below
Blunt true crime with awkward sister energy.
Serialholic Sisters covers murders, unsolved cases, solved cases, and notorious investigations with a loose, conversational rhythm. Crystal and Samantha move from timelines and police missteps to personal tangents, letting each episode feel more like a late-night case discussion than a formal report.
PRESS PLAY
Serialholic Sisters is built around two recurring voices, Crystal and Samantha, talking through true-crime cases with a blunt, informal rhythm. The show is not a sleek documentary. It leaves in the pauses, detours, reactions, technical mishaps, and awkward jokes that happen around the casework. That gives the episodes a loose, kitchen-table feeling, even when the material is severe. Recent entries move through the JonBenet Ramsey investigation, Donna Doll, Tyler Hadley, Libby German and Abby Williams, The Watcher, Kelly-Anne Bates, and John Joubert. The case selection mixes infamous stories with names that may be less familiar to casual listeners. Some installments linger over unsolved questions. Others trace how a crime was eventually understood or remembered. The speakers tend to focus on timelines, suspicious behavior, police decisions, family dynamics, online clues, and the gaps that make a case hard to settle. They are quick to question assumptions. They are also quick to interrupt themselves with a joke, a personal story, or a reaction that undercuts the heaviness for a moment. That tonal swing is central to the show. It can move from a botched investigation to a joke about coffee, then back into the facts without pretending the transition is elegant. The result is conversational true crime for listeners who like personality in the room. It does not hide the discomfort of the subject matter. It also does not turn every case into a solemn lecture. The show’s strongest episodes come when the speakers are actively testing theories against details from the story, especially around family behavior, police response, and public suspicion. The humor is irreverent, but the cases are treated as serious events with real victims and lasting damage. Listeners looking for tight narration may find the looseness distracting. Listeners who like true crime that feels reactive, personal, and unfiltered will understand the appeal quickly.
Made for: For true-crime listeners who prefer conversational case talk over polished narration, especially those who like theory-testing, side commentary, and visible reactions. Best for audiences comfortable with dark cases handled in an irreverent but case-focused style.
What sets it apart: The show stands apart through its unvarnished back-and-forth: serious case details share space with jokes, family-life interruptions, and on-mic uncertainty. It feels less like a produced report and more like listening to two recurring voices reason through disturbing stories together.
Settle in and get all cozy with your morning coffee or your end of the day cocktail and just hang out and listen to two awkward sisters, sitting around talking about true crime shit.
A ransom-note timeline becomes a coffee debate; you get Crystal and Samantha thinking out loud together.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
Crystal and Samantha revisit troubling behavior, limited interviews, and theories that still leave the case open.
Serialholic Sister's second JonBenet Ramsey installment returns after a jokingly acknowledged delay, with Crystal and Samantha sorting through the few interviews they say are available. The episode centers on childhood psychologist interviews and a Dr.
Serialholic Sisters revisits the JonBenet Ramsey case through the ransom note, Patsy's timeline, and the first police response.
Serialholic Sisters revisits the JonBenet Ramsey case through the first hours inside the Ramsey home, with Crystal and Samantha picking up a story listeners had been waiting on for about two years.
A loose, questioning review of Donna Doll's case, focused on the car, body identification, Charles, and unresolved doubt.
Donna Doll: All The Potato Talk centers Donna's unsolved case on details that never quite settle: a possible trip to Pennsylvania, uncertainty over whether she had a car, and the choice to have Charles identify her body before her parents were called.
A casual case discussion finds Tyler Hadley's violence lingering in the people left trying to trust again.
Tyler Hadley's killing of his parents comes through as a grim sequence of preparation, intoxication, and aftermath: phones taken away, three ecstasy pills swallowed, "Feel Lucky" used to build courage, and a five-minute wait behind his mother with a claw hammer.
A grounded look at the Anthony Shots profile and scene evidence gives this conversational true crime episode its clearest pull.
The episode works best when it treats the case as a story of pressure held in place: investigators withholding key details, a small-town police department carrying public scrutiny, and families still waiting for answers.
Grave questions, carefully organized.
Paranormal talk with room to wander.
Oz reimagined, then argued with afterward.
Crime memory with prison-wall detail.
Irish true crime, evidence first.
True crime with forensic bite and blunt banter.
Detective Steve Thomas said the case became a 'nearly impossible investigation' because of political alliances and professional egos.
["Crystal and Samantha return after a break tied to Crystal's mother-in-law's cancer death, then open a two-part look at the unsolved murder of JonBenet Ramsey.", "The episode places JonBenet Patricia Ramsey in Atlanta, Georgia, with John Ramsey, Patsy Ramsey, and brother Burke, and explains Patsy's Miss West Virginia pageant background.", "It contrasts the public pageant image with John Ramsey's description of JonBenet as a child who liked piano, violin, dance, rock climbing, sparkles, fruit roll-ups, and cardboard hill slides.", "The timeline turns to December 26, 1996, when Patsy finds a two-and-a-half-page ransom note at 5:30 a.m., calls 911 at 5:52 a.m., and the hosts focus on the disputed audio and odd note language."]
Serialholic Sisters: True Crime Shit centers on Donna Dahl, a 21-year-old Northern Illinois University student in DeKalb, Illinois, and the October 1970 disappearance that followed her library shift.
Serialholic Sisters covers Tyler Hadley, Mary Jo Hadley, and Blake Hadley in Port St.
Libby German recorded a man on the Monon High Bridge saying, "down the hill."
Two sisters catch up on personal news before diving into a true crime discussion.
Two sisters catch up on their busy lives before diving into a true crime discussion, starting with a baseball-related joke.
Two sisters introduce their true crime podcast and discuss their decision to cover a solved case instead of an unsolved one.
Two sisters casually chat about true crime cases while sharing personal anecdotes and drink preferences.