Presidential Fight Club

46 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

The presidents throw the punches; the historians keep score.

The gist

Presidential Fight Club puts American presidents into one-on-one fights and moves the winners through regionals and semifinals until only Teddy Roosevelt and Dwight D. Eisenhower remain. Scott Rank and James Early argue each bout from the historical record, weighing heights, illnesses, war service and even a letter Roosevelt wrote to his son about his boxing sessions.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About Presidential Fight Club

Presidential Fight Club answers the least dignified question in American history with real research: if the presidents fought each other one on one, who would be left standing? Scott Rank and James Early, introduced on the show as two history professors with too much time on their hands, run the answer as a knockout tournament. Matchups move through regional rounds and semifinals, with titles such as 'Western Regional Semifinal 1- Dwight D. Eisenhower vs. Ulysses S. Grant' and 'NE Regional 6- Kennedy vs. Chester A. Arthur'. The scouting reports are where the history comes in. Size comes first, so Lyndon B. Johnson's height and weight go on the record, along with Chester A. Arthur's bulk, which was large for his time. Health counts as well. Johnson's kidney stones earn a warning to protect the kidneys, and the Kennedy bout raises the question of whether the sick Kennedy or the tough one turns up. Military service carries weight too, from Johnson's Silver Star to Grant's two major wars. Then comes temperament, and the show treats it as a real weapon. The 'Johnson treatment', Johnson's habit of pushing into someone's personal space, is scored as an advantage in the ring. Arthur's earlier win over Calvin Coolidge is credited partly to the mental game. Grant is cast as a man with ice water in his veins, and the hosts push back on his reputation as a drunk, calling it blown out of proportion. Some pairings come with a backstory. Ronald Reagan against George H.W. Bush means a president facing his own vice president after an ugly 1980 primary, and the hosts joke that the former actor would suggest they fake it and make it look good. They also bring up the father-and-son bout between the two Adams presidents in the northeast regional. The final puts Teddy Roosevelt against Dwight D. Eisenhower. The research turns up a letter from Roosevelt to his son about boxing with a sparring partner who had become a champion middleweight wrestler, and about how jujitsu compares with wrestling. The talk drifts, too. A tangent about the name Kermit comes up mid-bout, and one host openly tries to throw the other off his game to help Ike. An epilogue flips the premise. The hosts argue that a chip on the shoulder and a refusal to stay down matter more in a great president than a good punch. They point to Andrew Jackson as a fighter whose competitive streak went to bad ends, and they say his standing in a C-SPAN poll has dropped over his treatment of Native Americans and his slaveholding. The premise is a joke, but the preparation is serious.

Made for: Suits a listener who likes presidential biography and trivia mixed with jokes, and who would enjoy hearing Grant's memoirs or the 'Johnson treatment' weighed up like a boxer's stats rather than presented as a lecture.

What sets it apart: It takes biographical details that usually count as trivia, such as heights, illnesses, medals and personal habits, and turns them into fight analysis. The joke runs through a full tournament and ends on a sincere question about whether toughness and presidential greatness are connected.

In their own words

Historians have ranked U.S. presidents on leadership, economic management, and pursuing justice, but they have never asked themselves which one could beat up all the others. This show will change that. Hosted by two history professors—James Early and Scott Rank—this is an NCAA-style tournament in which all presidents fight each other one-on-one until there is one champion. You'll see Barack Obama fight William Howard Taft (who literally weights twice as much), Abraham Lincoln try to knock the wooden teeth out of George Washington, and several other rumbles among the commander-in-chiefs.James and Scott narrate each of these 44 fights by comparing the physical abilities of each president, mili…

Presidents' height, weight and healthMilitary service and combat recordsTemperament and intimidation as fighting assetsRegional and semifinal tournament matchupsPresidential reputations and how they have shiftedAnecdotes and letters from presidential lives

Talks about

Best episodes of Presidential Fight Club

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

Epilogue: Is There a Connection Between Fighting Ability and Being a Great President?Jul 21, 2018

A playful presidential tournament turns into a thoughtful look at toughness, perseverance, and leadership.

Presidential Fight Club wraps its tournament with Teddy Roosevelt still standing, then turns the roughhouse setup toward a broader question: whether physical toughness has much to do with presidential greatness.

Podcasts like Presidential Fight Club

Episodes

  1. 1

    Epilogue: Is There a Connection Between Fighting Ability and Being a Great President?

    Hidden gem

    Presidential Fight Club’s epilogue asks whether physical toughness helps explain why Abraham Lincoln, George Washington, Theodore Roosevelt, and Dwight Eisenhower ranked highly as presidents.

    Jul 21, 2018·17m·1 clip
  2. 2

    The Final Match

    Two history professors analyze the final match of a hypothetical tournament where all U.S.

    Jul 20, 2018·10m
  3. 3

    Final 4 - Washington vs. Eisenhower

    Jul 19, 2018·12m
  4. 4

    Final 4 - Teddy Roosevelt vs. Abraham Lincoln

    Two history professors humorously debate which U.S.

    Jul 18, 2018·12m
  5. 5

    Midwest Regional Final- Gerald Ford vs. Abraham Lincoln

    Jul 17, 2018·8m
  6. 6

    Midwest Regional Semifinal 2- Gerald Ford vs. James Garfield

    Jul 16, 2018·8m
  7. 7

    Midwest Regional Semifinal 1- Abraham Lincoln vs. William Henry Harrison

    Jul 15, 2018·9m
  8. 8

    Midwest Regional 7- James Garfield vs. Rutherford B. Hayes

    Jul 14, 2018·9m
  9. 9

    Midwest Regional 6- Gerald Ford vs. William Howard Taft

    Jul 13, 2018·8m
  10. 10

    Midwest Regional 5- William Henry Harrison vs. William McKinley

    Jul 12, 2018·6m
  11. 11

    Midwest Regional 4- Abraham Lincoln vs. Grover Cleveland

    Jul 11, 2018·8m
  12. 12

    Midwest Regional 3- Barack Obama vs. William Howard Taft

    Jul 10, 2018·7m
  13. 13

    Midwest Regional 2- Warren G. Harding vs. William McKinley

    Jul 9, 2018·8m
  14. 14

    Midwest Regional 1- Grover Cleveland vs. Benjamin Harrison

    Jul 8, 2018·8m
  15. 15

    Western Regional 1- Richard Nixon vs. George W. Bush

    Jul 7, 2018·7m
  16. 16

    Western Regional 2- Ulysses S. Grant vs. Bill Clinton

    Jul 6, 2018·9m
  17. 17

    Western Regional 3- Lyndon B. Johnson vs. Herbert Hoover

    Jul 5, 2018·9m
  18. 18

    Western Regional 4- Dwight D. Eisenhower vs. George W. Bush

    Jul 4, 2018·9m
  19. 19

    Western Regional 5- Zachary Taylor vs. Ulysses S. Grant

    Jul 3, 2018·9m
  20. 20

    Western Regional 6- Ronald Reagan vs. Lyndon B. Johnson

    Two history professors analyze a hypothetical one-on-one fight between Ronald Reagan and Lyndon B.

    Jul 2, 2018·12m
  21. 21

    Western Regional 7- George H.W. Bush vs. Harry Truman

    Two history professors analyze and debate which U.S.

    Jul 1, 2018·11m
  22. 22

    Western Regional Semifinal 1- Dwight D. Eisenhower vs. Ulysses S. Grant

    Jun 30, 2018·12m
  23. 23

    Western Regional Semifinal 2- Ronald Reagan vs. George H.W. Bush

    Two history professors debate which U.S.

    Jun 29, 2018·11m
  24. 24

    Western Regional Final- Ronald Reagan vs. Dwight D. Eisenhower

    Jun 28, 2018·8m
  25. 25

    SE Regional Final- George Washington vs. Andrew Jackson

    Jun 27, 2018·8m
  26. 26

    SE Regional Semifinal 2- George Washington vs. Thomas Jefferson

    Jun 26, 2018·9m
  27. 27

    SE Regional Semifinal 1- Andrew Jackson vs. James Monroe

    Jun 25, 2018·9m
  28. 28

    SE Regional 7- Jimmy Carter vs. Thomas Jefferson

    Jun 24, 2018·10m
  29. 29

    SE Regional 6- George Washington vs. John Tyler

    Jun 23, 2018·10m
  30. 30

    SE Regional 5- James Monroe vs. Andrew Johnson

    Jun 22, 2018·8m
  31. 31

    SE Regional 4- Andrew Jackson vs. James Buchanan

    Jun 21, 2018·7m
  32. 32

    SE Regional 3- John Tyler vs. James K. Polk

    Jun 20, 2018·9m
  33. 33

    SE Regional 2- Andrew Johnson vs. James Madison

    Jun 19, 2018·9m
  34. 34

    SE Regional 1- Woodrow Wilson vs. James Buchanan

    Jun 18, 2018·8m
  35. 35

    NE Regional Final

    Jun 17, 2018·8m
  36. 36

    NE Regional Semifinal 2- Kennedy vs. FDR

    Jun 16, 2018·9m
  37. 37

    NE Regional Semifinal 1- Teddy Roosevelt vs. Franklin Pierce

    Jun 15, 2018·8m
  38. 38

    NE Regional 7- FDR vs. Donald Trump

    Jun 14, 2018·9m
  39. 39

    NE Regional 6- Kennedy vs. Chester A. Arthur

    Two history professors analyze a hypothetical fight between Chester A.

    Jun 13, 2018·10m
  40. 40

    NE Regional 5- Franklin Pierce vs. Millard Fillmore

    Jun 12, 2018·7m
  41. 41

    NE Regional 4- Teddy Roosevelt vs. John Adams

    Jun 11, 2018·7m
  42. 42

    NE Regional 3- Calvin Coolidge vs. Chester A. Arthur

    Jun 10, 2018·7m
  43. 43

    NE Regional 2- Millard Fillmore vs. Martin Van Buren

    Jun 9, 2018·7m
  44. 44

    NE Regional 1- John Adams vs. John Quincy Adams

    Jun 8, 2018·6m
  45. 45

    Welcome to Presidential Fight Club: If All 44 U.S. Presidents Fought Each Other, Who Would Win?

    Two history professors host a tournament where U.S.

    Jun 7, 2018·14m
  46. 46

    Prologue to Presidential Fight Club

    Jun 5, 2018·2m