Presidential Fight Club answers the least dignified question in American history with real research: if the presidents fought each other one on one, who would be left standing? Scott Rank and James Early, introduced on the show as two history professors with too much time on their hands, run the answer as a knockout tournament. Matchups move through regional rounds and semifinals, with titles such as 'Western Regional Semifinal 1- Dwight D. Eisenhower vs. Ulysses S. Grant' and 'NE Regional 6- Kennedy vs. Chester A. Arthur'. The scouting reports are where the history comes in. Size comes first, so Lyndon B. Johnson's height and weight go on the record, along with Chester A. Arthur's bulk, which was large for his time. Health counts as well. Johnson's kidney stones earn a warning to protect the kidneys, and the Kennedy bout raises the question of whether the sick Kennedy or the tough one turns up. Military service carries weight too, from Johnson's Silver Star to Grant's two major wars. Then comes temperament, and the show treats it as a real weapon. The 'Johnson treatment', Johnson's habit of pushing into someone's personal space, is scored as an advantage in the ring. Arthur's earlier win over Calvin Coolidge is credited partly to the mental game. Grant is cast as a man with ice water in his veins, and the hosts push back on his reputation as a drunk, calling it blown out of proportion. Some pairings come with a backstory. Ronald Reagan against George H.W. Bush means a president facing his own vice president after an ugly 1980 primary, and the hosts joke that the former actor would suggest they fake it and make it look good. They also bring up the father-and-son bout between the two Adams presidents in the northeast regional. The final puts Teddy Roosevelt against Dwight D. Eisenhower. The research turns up a letter from Roosevelt to his son about boxing with a sparring partner who had become a champion middleweight wrestler, and about how jujitsu compares with wrestling. The talk drifts, too. A tangent about the name Kermit comes up mid-bout, and one host openly tries to throw the other off his game to help Ike. An epilogue flips the premise. The hosts argue that a chip on the shoulder and a refusal to stay down matter more in a great president than a good punch. They point to Andrew Jackson as a fighter whose competitive streak went to bad ends, and they say his standing in a C-SPAN poll has dropped over his treatment of Native Americans and his slaveholding. The premise is a joke, but the preparation is serious.