Never Found Never Forgotten

50 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

Unsolved disappearances, remembered case by case.

The gist

Never Found Never Forgotten focuses on unsolved disappearances, often pairing cases by place, circumstance, or a possible connection. Melanie works through reported sightings, search details, contact information, and a plainspoken mix of research and human reaction.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About Never Found Never Forgotten

Never Found Never Forgotten is centered on unsolved disappearances, with a strong emphasis on children, young adults, and families who remain without answers. Melanie presents the cases in a direct, research-forward style. She usually begins with a place, a date, and the ordinary detail that makes the disappearance feel close: a store down the road, a crib in the morning, a walk to a grocery store, a hike that should have ended. From there, the show builds timelines out of reported sightings, searches, agency actions, family statements, and known identifiers. The case selection ranges across places named in the episodes. Some installments deliberately pair cases, such as two disappearances in Bremerton or two California wilderness cases. Others connect cases through a possible suspect, an updated missing-persons campaign, or a wider pattern around a location. The show does not treat every mystery as neatly solvable. Melanie often pauses over gaps in public information, contradictory place names, compromised sketches, thin reporting, and timelines that remain muddled. That uncertainty becomes part of the editorial value. Instead of forcing a theory, the show marks what is known, what is alleged, what police believed, and where families disagreed. The most distinctive moments come when procedural detail and personal response sit side by side. A missing backpack, a vehicle description, a deleted gas-station recording, a court filing, or a law-enforcement phone number can carry as much weight as the larger narrative. The episodes also show recurring frustration with assumptions made about missing children and teens, especially when runaway theories or stereotypes appear in the record. Melanie's delivery is plain, sometimes blunt, and emotionally transparent, but the focus stays on the missing person rather than spectacle. The show is comfortable admitting when there is not enough information. It is also persistent about repeating physical descriptions and agency contacts. That gives the program a practical missing-persons function alongside its storytelling. Never Found Never Forgotten is best understood as case-by-case remembrance: careful enough to note uncertainty, personal enough to show the toll, and grounded in the belief that unresolved disappearances still deserve attention.

Made for: Suits a listener who wants missing-person stories built from timelines, reported evidence, and unresolved questions rather than theatrical reconstruction. It also fits listeners who can handle emotionally heavy cases involving children and families.

What sets it apart: The show stands out through Melanie's solo-research transparency: she names gaps, conflicting reports, and thin sourcing instead of smoothing them over. Practical identifiers and law-enforcement contacts remain part of the storytelling, keeping the cases tied to real-world searches.

In their own words

Never Found Never Forgotten began as a weekly podcast hosted by sisters, Melanie and Kayla. Now, it's primarily hosted by Melanie and Kayla sometimes joins as a guest host!

Why you'd press play

A missing-person spreadsheet leads to a horse-ranch feud, and Melanie takes you along for the detour.

Press play if you want

  • Melanie to flag muddled timelines instead of pretending every account fits
  • the individual missing-person stories behind the original and rereleased "Runaway Train" videos
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
unsolved disappearancesmissing childrenfamily searcheslaw-enforcement investigationsreported sightingscase uncertaintyphysical identifierspublic tips

Talks about

Best episodes of Never Found Never Forgotten

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

Rilya WilsonMay 21, 2022

A child-disappearance case traced through foster care, disputed records, and the people still keeping Rillia Wilson's story in view.

Rillia Wilson's disappearance is handled as a case shaped by systems as much as by mystery: child welfare records, changing caregivers, disputed paperwork, and the adults entrusted with her care.

Podcasts like Never Found Never Forgotten

Episodes

  1. 1

    Tammy Belanger & Christy Luna

    Jun 9, 2022·16m
  2. 2

    Joseph Pichler & Francis Cantea

    May 28, 2022·12m
  3. 3

    Rilya Wilson

    Hidden gem

    ["Never Found, Never Forgotten follows the disappearance of Rillia Wilson, a four-year-old from Miami, Florida, whose case sat inside Florida DCF and foster care records.", "Melanie traces Gloria Wilson's loss of parental rights after cocaine abuse and neglect, then tracks how Pamela Kendrick, Gerilyn Graham, and Pamela Graham became part of a case with shifting explanations and incomplete files.", "Dora Bentacourt's March 2002 review uncovered a missing monthly visit record, while Gerilyn Graham said an African woman from DCF took Rillia away for evaluation.", "The episode also covers Pamela Graham's testimony about switches, a dog cage, and handcuffs, plus the later Aurelia Wilson Act tied to child-care visibility in foster homes."]

    May 21, 2022·31m·2 clips
  4. 4

    Pearl Pinson

    May 14, 2022·10m
  5. 5

    Ayla Reynolds & Lisa Irwin

    May 8, 2022·18m
  6. 6

    Diamond Bynum & King Walker

    Dec 20, 2021·13m
  7. 7

    Stacy Arras & Jonathan Aujay

    Dec 13, 2021·14m
  8. 8

    Runaway Train Part 2

    Police lost surveillance footage that could have shown what happened after Alexandria Lowitzer left her bus.

    Dec 5, 2021·30m·2 clips
  9. 9

    Steven Pearsall

    Dec 5, 2021·16m
  10. 10

    Runaway Train: Part 1

    Christopher Kersey’s handwritten notes shifted his 1990 disappearance from a family joke toward a desperate search.

    Nov 14, 2021·29m·2 clips
  11. 11

    Amber Swartz-Garcia

    Oct 31, 2021·14m
  12. 12

    Kelly Wilson

    Oct 24, 2021·18m
  13. 13

    Jeremy Bright & Derek Engebretson

    Never Found Never Forgotten pairs Jeremy Bright’s 1986 disappearance from Myrtle Point with Derek Engebretson’s 1998 disappearance near Bonanza, Oregon.

    Oct 17, 2021·19m·1 clip
  14. 14

    The Martin Family

    Oct 9, 2021·15m
  15. 15

    Serenity Dennard

    Oct 3, 2021·16m
  16. 16

    Ray Robinson

    Sep 28, 2021·17m
  17. 17

    Ann Miller, Patricia Blough, Renee Bruhl & Helen Brach

    Hidden gem

    Never Found, Never Forgotten follows the 1966 disappearance of Ann Miller, Patricia Blau, and Renee Bruhl from Indiana Dunes State Park, where witnesses reported seeing them near a white boat.

    Sep 18, 2021·48m·3 clips
  18. 18

    Season 1 & 2 updates

    Aug 27, 2021·17m
  19. 19

    Robert Pilsen-Rahier

    Aug 21, 2021·14m
  20. 20

    Michael Chambers

    Aug 6, 2021·18m
  21. 21

    Kristal Reisinger

    Jul 30, 2021·13m
  22. 22

    Linda Skeek (Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women)

    Jul 24, 2021·18m
  23. 23

    Dannette & Jeannette Millbrook

    Jul 16, 2021·12m
  24. 24

    D'Wan Sims

    Jul 10, 2021·10m
  25. 25

    Linden Murders

    Jul 3, 2021·12m
  26. 26

    (Historical) William Morgan

    Jul 3, 2021·19m
  27. 27

    Jared Negrete & Theresa "Trenny" Gibson

    Host Melanie discusses the disappearances of Jared Negrete and Trenny Gibson from national parks.

    Jun 28, 2021·24m
  28. 28

    Cleashindra Hall

    Jun 20, 2021·15m
  29. 29

    Monique "Nikki" Daniels

    Host Melanie recounts the heartbreaking case of 15-year-old Monique 'Nikki' Daniels, who disappeared from Moore, Oklahoma, amid a troubled home life.

    Jun 11, 2021·21m
  30. 30

    Karen Wilson & Suzanne Lyall

    Jun 6, 2021·16m
  31. 31

    Skelton Brothers

    The hosts celebrate their 50th episode by reflecting on the show's journey and the impact of sharing missing persons stories.

    Jun 1, 2021·22m
  32. 32

    Charlie Allen, Jr/ Neo Babson Maximus

    May 21, 2021·17m
  33. 33

    Felipe Santos & Terrance Williams

    May 14, 2021·16m
  34. 34

    Brandon Swanson

    May 8, 2021·14m
  35. 35

    Jonathan Fraser

    Apr 30, 2021·14m
  36. 36

    Robert Mayer

    Apr 24, 2021·11m
  37. 37

    Sara Anne Wood

    Apr 16, 2021·11m
  38. 38

    Yolanda Panek

    Apr 9, 2021·9m
  39. 39

    Toni Sharpless

    Apr 9, 2021·8m
  40. 40

    Anthonette Cayedito

    Mar 27, 2021·13m
  41. 41

    Angela Hammond

    Mar 20, 2021·10m
  42. 42

    Johnny Gosch

    Mar 12, 2021·12m
  43. 43

    Kyron Horman

    Mar 5, 2021·15m
  44. 44

    Lilli Dunn

    Mar 1, 2021·5m
  45. 45

    Taylor/ Jose/ McClerkin

    Feb 23, 2021·18m
  46. 46

    Sabrina Aisenberg

    Feb 17, 2021·10m
  47. 47

    Gary Mathias

    Feb 14, 2021·16m
  48. 48

    Laureen Rahn

    Jul 28, 2020·13m
  49. 49

    Missing Native American Women

    Host Melanie discusses the epidemic of missing Native American women, sharing several specific cases to raise awareness.

    Jul 21, 2020·21m
  50. 50

    Maria Elizalde & Brent Acomb

    Jul 14, 2020·9m