
Horror Soup: A Horror Movie Podcast
150 episodes listed below
Horror movies, loudly overthought.
The gist
Horror Soup treats horror movies as raw material for messy, fast-talking comedy rather than tidy criticism. The show is strongest when a strange prop, sloppy plot point, or sequel sends the room into an argument that barely stays on track.
PRESS PLAY
Find your next episode
About Horror Soup: A Horror Movie Podcast
Horror Soup is a horror-movie discussion show that treats bad decisions, strange props, cheap effects, and baffling franchise choices as comic fuel. Its sampled episodes move through slashers, campus horror, crossover oddities, and a recurring Amityville fixation. The tone is loose from the first minute. Introductions can turn into arguments about hats, baldness, silent episodes, or whether the episode should have been recorded at all. Then the movie arrives, though usually sideways. A scene from Shredder becomes a debate about which characters map onto another cast. Happy Hell Night turns a giant match and a metal door into a ridiculous forensic exercise. The Mutilator prompts a long incredulous riff on a vacation home covered in empty bottles and ominous weapons. Pledge Night becomes a parade of fraternity-horror nonsense, flashback jokes, and Anthrax references. The Evil Bong and Gingerdead Man episodes lean into repetitive franchise music, background-noise plotting, gas masks, greasy characters, and the odd rhythm of movies built mostly from people sitting around talking. Amityville gets special treatment, with the show presenting those entries as a running obsession rather than just another assignment. The show is not trying to be a clean critical guide. It is more interested in what a movie accidentally reveals when several people talk over its logic until the seams show. The comedy is blunt. The pacing is jagged. The best moments come from escalation: one tossed-off observation becomes a whole invented framework, then collapses under another joke. There are named voices across the excerpts, which matches the show’s casual-room energy. Horror Soup works for listeners who enjoy friends heckling obscure genre movies with high tolerance for crude tangents and chaotic callbacks. It is less useful for spoiler-free recommendations or elegant analysis. Its value is personality, momentum, and the willingness to chase the dumbest detail in the room until it becomes the main event.
Made for: Best for horror fans who enjoy chaotic group banter, sequels, slasher oddities, and long riffs on tiny production choices. It is not aimed at listeners seeking careful criticism or spoiler-free guidance.
What sets it apart: Horror Soup stands apart by making the derailments feel like the core format: Amityville lore, franchise bits, prop logic, character mapping, and in-room teasing all compete with the recap itself.
In their own words
Do expect: discussions about strange and amusing occurrences in horror moviesDo not expect: intelligent reviewsWe're hardly ever right… unless we’re talking Amityville. We know everything about every Amityville ever made and we've never been wrong about anything that has even the slightest association to the house, story, or lore of Amityville.
Why you'd press play
A giant match becomes the star witness, and you get the full cross-examination.
Press play if you want
- scene-by-scene horror talk that treats every absurd prop choice like evidence
- friends derailing a slasher recap to litigate baldness, gas masks, and sitcom casting
Talks about
Podcasts like Horror Soup: A Horror Movie Podcast
Horror VanguardHorror movies meet critical theory, and the jokes keep interrupting.
THE LASSER CASTHorror films and monster shows, talked through by two friends.

American ScandalAudibleMulti-part dramatized retellings of scandals like OceanGate's Titan and the Lehman Brothers collapse.


Episodes
- 1
#185 Wolf Creek (2005) Doesn't Include Wolf
·1h 59m - 2
#173 An Evil Bong Smoking on a Tommy Chong (2006)
·1h 26m - 3
#215 Amityville: No Escape (2016)
·2h 13m - 4
#214 Shredder (2001) | (ft. Keanu & Nathan)
·1h 36m - 5
#213 Happy Hell Night (1991) | (ft. Keanu)
·2h - 6
#212 The Mutilator (1984)
·1h 52m - 7
#211 Pledge Night (1988) | (ft. Caleb's Grandpa & Keanu)
·1h 41m - 8
#210 StageFright (1987)
·1h 30m - 9
#209 Surf Ninjas (1993)
·1h 19m - 10
#208 Matilda (1978)
·1h 19m - 11
#207 Splice (2009) | (ft. Caleb's Grandpa)
·1h 34m - 12
#206 Ben (1972)
·1h 29m - 13
#205 Willard (1971)
·1h 12m - 14
#204 Saw (2004)
·1h 41m - 15
#203 Skinner (1993)
·1h 14m - 16
#202 The Boy (2016)
·1h 6m - 17
#201 The Hunt (2020)
·1h 21m - 18
#200 The Blair Witch EXTRAVAGANZA (ft. Kim)
·2h 15m - 19
#199 The Amityville Terror (2016)
·2h 15m - 20
Tales of Albert James | The Soup Kitchen #8
·46m - 21
#198 Leviathan (1989)
·2h 28m - 22
#197 Willy's Wonderland (2021)
·1h 36m - 23
#196 The Haunting (1999)
·1h 28m - 24
#195 Wolf Creek 2 (2013) | (ft. Suriah)
·1h 40m - 25
#194 Amityville Toybox (2016)
·1h 40m - 26
#193 Apostle (2018)
·2h 40m - 27
#192 Barbarian: How long IS Justin?? | (ft. Hannah)
·2h 5m - 28
#191 Rogue 2007 Isn't Even All That Rogue
·1h 59m - 29
#190 Dashcam (2021) | (The Bad One)
·1h 36m - 30
#189 The Wicker Man (2006) | (ft. Daniel, Sophia, and BEES)
·2h 25m - 31
#188 Amityville: Vanishing Point (2016)
·1h 42m - 32
An Update
·2m - 33
Three Guys and a Kangaroo | The Soup Kitchen #6
·1h 8m - 34
#187 The Invisible Man (1933) | (ft. Lane)
·1h 33m - 35
#186 Carrie and a Bucket of PIGS BLOOD (1976)
·2h 41m - 36
Baddies Part 3 | The Soup Kitchen #5
·1h 8m - 37
#174 The Conjuring 2 (2016) | More Amityville, Less Entertainment.
·1h 38m - 38
Baddies Part 2 | The Soup Kitchen #4
·53m - 39
#184 Leprechaun 2: A Buckle on Me Shoe (1994)
·2h 3m - 40
Baddies Part 1 | The Soup Kitchen #3
·57m - 41
#183 The Human Centipede & One Gastrointestinal Track (2009)
·1h 56m - 42
Helen Keller in The Attic | The Soup Kitchen #2
·1h 9m - 43
#182 Evil Bong: High 5 Sent us to High Hell (2016)
·1h 3m - 44
CHICKENS ARE EATING OUR BABIES | The Soup Kitchen #1
·56m - 45
#181 Evil Bong 420 (2015) | Charles BANNED
·1h 18m - 46
#180 Gingerdead Man vs. Evil Bong (2013)
·1h 15m - 47
#179 Gingerdead Man 3: Roller Boogie Man\Saturday Night Cleaver (2011)
·1h 25m - 48
#178 Tough Guy Runs Caleb Down (Pt. Twice)
·1h 21m - 49
#177 Scary Movie 2 (2001) | Here, Take My Little Hand! (ft. Kim Wilson)
·2h 28m - 50
#176 Evil Bong 3D: The Wrath of Bong/Reefer Madness (2011)
·1h 39m - 51
#175 I'm A Doobie Maaaan | Evil Bong 2: King Bong (2009)
·1h - 52
#172 Gingerdead Man 2: Passion of the Crust (2008)
·1h 30m - 53
#171 Where's That Rundown, Jim?
·1h 50m - 54
#170 Christmas with Cookie: Locked Away (2017)
·1h 37m - 55
#169 Amityville Thanksgiving (2022) Has a Jump Scare Dere wit da Ghost
·2h 9m - 56
#168 Going BUCK WILD... for Thankskilling (2008) | ft. Kim and Niah
·1h 52m - 57
#167 Halloween Kills (2021)
·2h 19m - 58
#166 Amityville: The Final Chapter (Sickle) (2015)
·1h 58m - 59
Horror Soup Update
·4m - 60
#164 Halloween Ends (2022)
·1h 43m - 61
#163 Idle Hands (1999)
·2h 17m - 62
Underworld: Blood Wars (2016) - I'll Suck Your Blood
·1h 25m - 63
Underworld: Awakening (2012) - I'll Suck Your Blood
·1h 32m - 64
#162 Corn 2: Electric Boogaloo
·1h 16m - 65
#161 Channel Zero: Season 1, Episode 6 - (Part 4)
·1h 24m - 66
Osmosis Jones (temporary ep)
·1h 18m - 67
#160 Channel Zero: Season 1, Episodes 4 & 5 - (Part 3)
·1h 36m - 68
#159 Channel Zero: Season 1, Episode 3 - (Part 2)
·1h 8m - 69
#158 Channel Zero: Season 1, Episodes 1 & 2 - (Part 1)
·1h 13m - 70
#157 The Blob (1988) with James from Nite Shift Video
·1h 46m - 71
#156 No Exit (2022) with James from Nite Shift Video
·1h 45m - 72
I'm Taking a Break
·4m - 73
#155 Bones (2001) with Kim Wilson & James from Nite Shift Video
·1h 47m - 74
#155 Bones (2001) with Kim Wilson & James from Nite Shift Video
·1h 35m - 75
#154 Sharknado (2013) with James from Nite Shift Video
·1h 27m - 76
#153 Amityville Death House (2015) with Kim Wilson
·1h 57m - 77
#154 Sharknado (2013) with James from Nite Shift Video
·1h 27m - 78
#153 Amityville Death House (2015) with Kim Wilson
·1h 57m - 79
#152 Killer Condom (1996) with James from Nite Shift Video
·1h 10m - 80
#151 Holla If I Kill You (2003) with Kim Wilson
·1h 11m - 81
#150 Jason X (2001) & Current Friday the 13th Legal Issues
·2h 7m - 82
#149 Werewolves Within (2021) with James from Nite Shift Video
·1h 35m - 83
Underworld: Rise of the Lycans (2009) - I'll Suck Your Blood
·1h 9m - 84
#148 Hellraiser (1987) with Marisa John
·2h 16m - 85
Underworld: Evolution (2006) - I'll Suck Your Blood
·1h 10m - 86
#147 Amityville Playhouse (2015) with Kim Wilson (Amityville Theater)
·1h 39m - 87
#146 Ginger Snaps (2000) with Calvin Brooks
·2h 27m - 88
#145 Altered States (1980) with James from Nite Shift Video
·1h 55m - 89
#144 Mirrors 2 (2010) with Bodacious Bri
·1h 25m - 90
#143 The Conjuring ISN'T an Amityville Movie with Kim Wilson
·1h 43m - 91
Underworld (2003) - I'll Suck Your Blood
·1h 10m - 92
#142 Mirrors (2008) with Bodacious Bri
·2h 7m - 93
#141 The Happening (2008) with my Brother Jedd
·1h 36m - 94
#140 Hobo with a Shotgun (2011) with James from Nite Shift Video
·1h 54m - 95
#139 I Know Who Killed Me (2007) with Bodacious Bri and Niah
·1h 42m - 96
#138 Repo! The Genetic Opera (2008) with James from Nite Shift Video
·1h 21m - 97
#137 Signs (2002) with James from Nite Shift Video
·1h 47m - 98
#136 Hell Comes to Frogtown (1988) with James from Nite Shift Video
·2h - 99
#165 Amityville: The Unspoken (2015) with Kim Wilson
The hosts banter about re-recording an old Amityville episode and plan to watch the remaining Amityville films.
·1h 47m - 100
Floods and Butt Plugs | The Soup Kitchen #7
The hosts engage in humorous, off-topic banter before discussing horror movies, with a focus on comedy rather than serious critique.
·57m - 101
#215 Amityville: No Escape (2016)
Apr 11, 2025·2h 13m - 102
#214 Shredder (2001) | (ft. Keanu & Nathan)
Hidden gemHorror Soup #214 covers Shredder (2001) with Caleb, Nathan, and Keanu while Key opens by saying the episode may not be worth listening to.
Mar 14, 2025·1h 36m·5 clips - 103
#213 Happy Hell Night (1991) | (ft. Keanu)
Horror Soup’s episode on Happy Hell Night (1991), also called Frat Fright, examines a Canadian-Yugoslavian slasher with a 2.6 Letterboxd rating, 4.8 IMDb rating, and 33% Rotten Tomatoes audience score.
Feb 28, 2025·2h·5 clips - 104
#212 The Mutilator (1984)
Hidden gemHorror Soup: A Horror Movie Podcast examines The Mutilator (1984), a slasher directed and written by lawyer Buddy Cooper with John Douglas.
Feb 16, 2025·1h 52m·5 clips - 105
#211 Pledge Night (1988) | (ft. Caleb's Grandpa & Keanu)
Hidden gemHorror Soup: A Horror Movie Podcast reviews Pledge Night (1988), a low-budget fraternity horror film that the hosts describe as dominated by homoerotic hazing rituals.
Jan 31, 2025·1h 41m·5 clips - 106
#210 StageFright (1987)
Sep 23, 2024·1h 30m - 107
#209 Surf Ninjas (1993)
Aug 19, 2024·1h 19m - 108
#208 Matilda (1978)
Jul 17, 2024·1h 19m - 109
#207 Splice (2009) | (ft. Caleb's Grandpa)
Jun 20, 2024·1h 34m - 110
#206 Ben (1972)
May 20, 2024·1h 29m - 111
#205 Willard (1971)
Apr 22, 2024·1h 12m - 112
#204 Saw (2004)
Apr 8, 2024·1h 41m - 113
#203 Skinner (1993)
Mar 25, 2024·1h 14m - 114
#202 The Boy (2016)
Mar 11, 2024·1h 6m - 115
#201 The Hunt (2020)
Feb 26, 2024·1h 21m - 116
#200 The Blair Witch EXTRAVAGANZA (ft. Kim)
Feb 12, 2024·2h 15m - 117
#199 The Amityville Terror (2016)
Jan 29, 2024·2h 15m - 118
Tales of Albert James | The Soup Kitchen #8
Jan 23, 2024·46m - 119
#198 Leviathan (1989)
Jan 8, 2024·2h 28m - 120
#197 Willy's Wonderland (2021)
Oct 16, 2023·1h 36m - 121
#196 The Haunting (1999)
Oct 9, 2023·1h 28m - 122
#195 Wolf Creek 2 (2013) | (ft. Suriah)
Aug 7, 2023·1h 40m - 123
#194 Amityville Toybox (2016)
Jul 24, 2023·1h 40m - 124
#193 Apostle (2018)
Jul 3, 2023·2h 40m - 125
#192 Barbarian: How long IS Justin?? | (ft. Hannah)
Jun 26, 2023·2h 5m - 126
#191 Rogue 2007 Isn't Even All That Rogue
Jun 19, 2023·1h 59m - 127
#190 Dashcam (2021) | (The Bad One)
Jun 12, 2023·1h 36m - 128
#189 The Wicker Man (2006) | (ft. Daniel, Sophia, and BEES)
Jun 5, 2023·2h 25m - 129
Floods and Butt Plugs | The Soup Kitchen #7
Jun 1, 2023·57m - 130
#188 Amityville: Vanishing Point (2016)
May 22, 2023·1h 42m - 131
An Update
May 6, 2023·2m - 132
Three Guys and a Kangaroo | The Soup Kitchen #6
May 4, 2023·1h 8m - 133
#187 The Invisible Man (1933) | (ft. Lane)
May 1, 2023·1h 33m - 134
#186 Carrie and a Bucket of PIGS BLOOD (1976)
Apr 24, 2023·2h 41m - 135
Baddies Part 3 | The Soup Kitchen #5
Apr 20, 2023·1h 8m - 136
#185 Wolf Creek (2005) Doesn't Include Wolf
Apr 17, 2023·1h 59m - 137
Baddies Part 2 | The Soup Kitchen #4
Apr 13, 2023·53m - 138
#184 Leprechaun 2: A Buckle on Me Shoe (1994)
Apr 10, 2023·2h 3m - 139
Baddies Part 1 | The Soup Kitchen #3
Apr 6, 2023·57m - 140
#183 The Human Centipede & One Gastrointestinal Track (2009)
Apr 3, 2023·1h 56m - 141
Helen Keller in The Attic | The Soup Kitchen #2
Mar 30, 2023·1h 9m - 142
#182 Evil Bong: High 5 Sent us to High Hell (2016)
Mar 27, 2023·1h 3m - 143
CHICKENS ARE EATING OUR BABIES | The Soup Kitchen #1
Mar 23, 2023·56m - 144
#181 Evil Bong 420 (2015) | Charles BANNED
Mar 20, 2023·1h 18m - 145
#180 Gingerdead Man vs. Evil Bong (2013)
Hidden gemHorror Soup's "Gingerdead Man vs.
Mar 13, 2023·1h 15m·5 clips - 146
#179 Gingerdead Man 3: Roller Boogie Man\Saturday Night Cleaver (2011)
Feb 27, 2023·1h 25m - 147
#178 Tough Guy Runs Caleb Down (Pt. Twice)
Feb 20, 2023·1h 21m - 148
#177 Scary Movie 2 (2001) | Here, Take My Little Hand! (ft. Kim Wilson)
Jan 23, 2023·2h 28m - 149
#176 Evil Bong 3D: The Wrath of Bong/Reefer Madness (2011)
Jan 16, 2023·1h 39m - 150
#175 I'm A Doobie Maaaan | Evil Bong 2: King Bong (2009)
The hosts humorously discuss the movie Evil Bong 2: King Bong, critiquing its dialogue and plot.
Jan 9, 2023·1h