PRESS PLAY
Find your next episode
In their own words
An independent podcast based in Cleveland, Ohio primarily focused on the lower Great Lakes region but ventures out from time to time. No banter. No schedule. Short episodes. Socials: X and Facebook Email: [email protected] Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/great-lakes-true-crime/id1387687232 Spotify: https://open.spo
Talks about
Podcasts like Great Lakes True Crime
Off the TrailsMaegan Moaratty and Danielle FalaganOutdoor mysteries, mapped with human common sense.
Politically GeorgiaGeorgia politics from inside the room.
Forensic TalesTrue crime measured by the evidence.
Red WebMysteries, lore, and nervous laughter.
Episodes
- 1
Ep.58 - Chelsea Bruck
This episode investigates the disappearance and murder of Chelsea Bruck, a young woman from Michigan, exploring the details of the case and the ongoing search for justice.
Mar 31, 2026·13m - 2
Ep.57 - Cheryl Hughes (Unsolved)
Hidden gemCheryl Hughes, a 32-year-old mother of three from Chillicothe, Ohio, left Giovanni's around 12:45 a.m.
Jan 23, 2026·26m·1 clip - 3
Ep.56 - Case Updates: Amy Mihaljevic and Beverly Jarosz
This episode provides updates on two unsolved murders of young girls in Ohio: Amy Mihaljevic (1989) and Beverly Jarosz (1964).
Jan 11, 2026·15m - 4
Ep.55 - The Vanishing of Cindy Anderson (Unsolved)
Hidden gemThe episode recounts the unsolved disappearance of Cynthia 'Cindy' Anderson from her office in Toledo, Ohio, on August 4, 1981.
Nov 11, 2025·24m·1 clip - 5
Ep.54 - Katrina Smith
This episode recounts the disappearance of Katrina Smith in Rockford, Illinois, in 2012.
Jun 17, 2025·17m - 6
Ep.53 - Kalee Bruce
Feb 16, 2025·16m - 7
Ep.52 - Missing: Brian Shaffer
Brian Schaefer vanished from a Columbus bar despite cameras covering nearly every possible exit.
Dec 15, 2024·20m·1 clip - 8
Ep.51 - Maria Marshall
Jul 30, 2024·18m - 9
Ep.50 - Hazel Burns
Two dentists found blood, clothing, and Hazel Burns's body in a shallow Mentor Marsh grave.
Apr 21, 2024·21m·1 clip - 10
Ep.49 - Ronald Tammen
Jan 15, 2024·18m - 11
Ep.48 - The Ghost Cat of Fairport Harbor
Nov 6, 2023·15m - 12
Ep.48 - The Ghost Cat of Fairport Harbor
Oct 31, 2023·12m - 13
Ep.47 - Theresa Andrews
Michelle Bika’s hospital story collapsed when the FBI found no hospital visit and no tuberculosis scare.
Oct 9, 2023·18m·1 clip - 14
Ep.46 Noelle Paquette
Sep 11, 2023·23m - 15
Ep.45 - Carnell Sledge and Kate Brown (Unsolved)
Jun 12, 2023·18m - 16
Ep.44 - The Indiana Dunes Disappearances (Unsolved)
May 22, 2023·31m - 17
Ep.43 - The King of Beaver Island
Apr 5, 2023·17m - 18
Ep.42 - Mystery at Long Point Cut Lighthouse
Nov 22, 2022·19m - 19
Ep.41 - The Defiance Werewolf (Halloween Episode 2022)
Oct 31, 2022·13m - 20
Ep.40 - Dana Rosendale
Sep 12, 2022·19m - 21
Ep.39 - Derrick Robie
Jul 6, 2022·22m - 22
Ep.38 - Florence Unger
Apr 27, 2022·19m - 23
Ep.38 - Florence Unger
Apr 25, 2022·18m - 24
Ep.37 - Parma School Teachers
Mar 25, 2022·22m - 25
Ep.36 - Jennifer Teague
Feb 13, 2022·23m - 26
Ep.35 - Angela Hicks
Jan 23, 2022·19m - 27
Ep.34 - The Kelleys Island Murders
Dec 10, 2021·30m - 28
Ep.33 - Ghost Stories
Oct 30, 2021·16m - 29
Ep.32 - Joan, Michelle, & Christe Rogers
Oct 15, 2021·31m - 30
Ep. 31 - JoAnn Matouk Romain
Sep 16, 2021·23m - 31
Ep. 30 - Anna Marie Hahn
Aug 26, 2021·24m - 32
Ep. 29 - Beverly Potts
May 31, 2021·50m - 33
Ep. 28 - Introducing truecrime216
May 23, 2021·27m - 34
Ep. 27 - Lynda Shaw
Apr 19, 2021·21m - 35
Ep. 26 - Sister Margaret Ann Pahl
Mar 30, 2021·21m - 36
Ep. 25 - Missing in Muskoka
Feb 10, 2021·32m - 37
Ep. 24 - Beverly Jarosz
Dec 16, 2020·21m - 38
Ep. 23 - Nancy Ludwig
This episode recounts the 1991 murder of flight attendant Nancy Ludwig at a Detroit airport hotel.
Nov 11, 2020·24m - 39
Ep. 22 - Irene Izak
A true crime podcast focusing on a 1968 murder case of a teacher traveling from Cleveland to Quebec.
Aug 16, 2020·23m - 40
Ep.21 - Lisa & Devon Manderach
Jul 9, 2020·20m - 41
Ep.20 - Judy Martins
Jun 22, 2020·14m - 42
Ep.19 - Ceely Rose
The episode recounts the 1896 murder of the Rose family in Richland County, Ohio, setting up the case with historical context.
Mar 27, 2020·23m - 43
Ep.18 - Barry and Honey Sherman
This episode covers the mysterious deaths of Canadian billionaires Barry and Honey Sherman.
Feb 17, 2020·28m - 44
Ep.17 - The Berlin Lake Murders
Aug 19, 2019·19m - 45
Ep.16 - Geauga's Baby
Jul 4, 2019·15m - 46
Ep.15 - Amish Hate Crimes
Jun 2, 2019·27m - 47
Ep.14 - Heather Bogle
Apr 25, 2019·21m - 48
Ep.13 - London Ontario Serial Killer Victims
A true crime podcast focusing on cases from the Great Lakes region, with this episode covering the 1969 murder of Jane Woolley in London, Ontario.
Apr 3, 2019·25m - 49
Ep.12 - Lynne Harper & Steven Truscott
Feb 26, 2019·24m