Odd history, solved patiently.
Futility Closet is a history-and-puzzle show built around curious episodes that sit just outside the standard classroom version of the past. Its stories range from wartime aerial reconnaissance and remote island communities to vanished inventors, mutineers, poisoners, and deliberately confounding yes-or-no puzzles.
PRESS PLAY
Futility Closet presents history as a series of well-lit curiosities: not trivia exactly, and not grand theory, but the kind of story that starts with a narrow fact and opens into a wider world. Its subjects often begin with a puzzle. A man in a full leather suit walks a precise circuit through Connecticut and New York. A tiny island in the Banda Sea becomes valuable enough to draw years of siege over nutmeg. A French inventor boards a train before showing his moving pictures and disappears. A remote Scottish community chooses to leave the islands it has occupied for generations. The show follows these cases with a measured, source-minded style, giving enough context for the oddity to make sense without sanding away its strangeness. Its historical range is broad, but the recurring attraction is the same: obscure lives under pressure from geography, war, illness, technology, bureaucracy, or simple human obstinacy. There is also a steady appetite for disputed identities and missing explanations. The Leatherman remains unnamed. Louis Leprince never gets his public moment. St. Kilda's departure is both practical and mournful. Sidney Cotton's aerial reconnaissance work becomes crucial, then politically awkward. The Lambeth Poisoner episode shows the darker edge of the catalog, tracing deaths, suspicion, and testimony with a composed seriousness. Between stories, the lateral-thinking puzzles turn the same habits of inference into play. One speaker presents a bizarre situation, and the other works through it by testing assumptions. These exchanges are dry, patient, and often funny in the smallest possible way. Futility Closet stands apart because it respects both halves of its format: the researched historical miniature and the puzzle-box conversation. It is for listeners who enjoy obscure evidence, clean structure, and the pleasure of realizing that the weird detail was the important one all along.
Made for: For listeners who like obscure history, source-based storytelling, and puzzles that reward careful assumptions. It fits people drawn to mysteries, historical footnotes, and strange but well-documented human behavior.
What sets it apart: The show combines compact historical narratives with lateral-thinking exchanges, so research and reasoning sit side by side. Its tone is dry and composed, letting the odd facts carry the charge without theatrical buildup.
Forgotten stories from the pages of history. Join us for surprising and curious tales from the past and challenge yourself with our lateral thinking puzzles.
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Futility Closet turns obscure lives and unresolved events into careful narratives that keep uncertainty visible.
Futility Closet follows historical mysteries and overlooked lives until their strangeness becomes intelligible. Greg Ross and Sharon Ross pair a sustained narrative with smaller curiosities and a lateral-thinking puzzle, moving from the isolation of St.
A four-year nutmeg siege comes with a puzzle chaser, if your history appetite likes a left turn.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
Eight yes-or-no puzzles turn strange setups into patient, quietly playful acts of inference.
Futility Closet's final episode turns oddity into a small parlor game: eight lateral thinking puzzles are posed as strange situations, then slowly opened up through yes-or-no questions.
Aerial reconnaissance is improvised under pressure, then Cotton is pushed aside.
The episode makes Sidney Cotton feel less like a spy-fi curiosity than a practical answer to a wartime problem. An Australian businessman in London is drawn in by Frederick Winterbotham, MI6's air section chief known to colleagues as Cloak and Dagger Fred, to photograph from the…
A poison case, a puzzle, and a farewell that gives the hour a heavier edge.
Episode 363 folds a bleak Victorian poison case into a wider, stranger arc. The Lambeth Poisoner story, with its pills, poor young women, and the suspicion around a Scottish-Canadian doctor with a dark North American past, gives the hour its sharpest charge.
The Leather Man remains unknown, and the episode treats that uncertainty with patience and texture.
Futility Closet uses this hour on the Leather Man, the leather-clad walker who moved through Connecticut and New York often enough to become both a local fixture and a lasting mystery.
Taliesin anchors a grim Wright story shaped by violence, reporting, and prejudice.
Taliesin serves as a stark backdrop for Julian Carlton, the attack he carried out there in 1914, and the ruin left behind at a house already marked by Wright's chaotic private life.
St. Kilda's 1930 departure becomes a careful account of isolation, labor, weather, and the cost of staying.
The episode builds a clear case for St. Kilda, the isolated Scottish archipelago where a tiny population ended a thousand-year tenure on Hirta and sailed for the mainland in 1930.
Legends tested against what can still be traced.
History interviews with dirt on the boots.
Scripted, scored true stories from the odd corners of history.
Polar rivalries and historical puzzles, told with dry wit.
This episode recounts the 1914 Taliesin murders, where servant Julian Carlton killed seven people at Frank Lloyd Wright's Wisconsin estate.
This episode explores the 19th-century efforts of France, England, and the United States to transport ancient Egyptian obelisks using forgotten techniques.
This episode explores two unverified historical stories from the 1920s about New York fruit dealers and a mythologized bank robber, discussing the strength of evidence behind them.
This episode explores historical curiosities and unanswered questions, including a Pony Express ad and the Somerton Man mystery.
This episode explores the mysterious disappearance of French inventor Louis Leprince, a pioneer of early motion pictures, and his contested place in film history.
This episode explores the macabre 19th-century New England practice of exhuming and burning the organs of tuberculosis victims, including a case of a skeleton rearranged into a skull-and-crossbones pattern.
Two English academics encounter strange characters at Versailles and believe they entered Marie Antoinette's mind.
This episode recounts the 1829 mutiny of convicts aboard the brig Cyprus in Tasmania and their daring escape across the Pacific.
This episode recounts Nicholas Winton's efforts to rescue children from Nazi-occupied Czechoslovakia in 1939.
This episode details the 1930 evacuation of St.
Futility Closet episode 365 is built around eight lateral thinking puzzles, including a DecorMyEyes SEO scheme, a Kimi Räikkönen bonus contract at Lotus, and a mark-recapture snails puzzle.
The Dutch rowing team won in Paris by replacing a 60-kilogram coxswain with a 33-kilogram boy.
Futility Closet episode 363 centers on the Lambeth Poisoner, with Ellen Donworth, Matilda Clover, Alice Marsh, and Emma Shrevelle all linked to strychnine in Lambeth in 1891.
Futility Closet episode 362 centers on the Leatherman, a mysterious man first seen in 1856 on the roads of Connecticut and New York, wearing a leather suit, carrying a tin pail, and sleeping in caves and lean-tos.
Futility Closet episode 361, "A Fight Over Nutmeg," follows Nathaniel Courthope's 1616 mission to hold Run, a tiny Banda Sea island, against the Dutch East India Company.