Fake Geek Girls - A Critical Look at Pop Culture

146 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

Affectionate criticism with teeth.

The gist

Fake Geek Girls treats movies, books, television, and fandom arguments as things worth taking seriously without getting precious about them. Missy and Mary move from Oscar debates to therapy jokes to adaptation politics with a chatty, exacting rhythm.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About Fake Geek Girls - A Critical Look at Pop Culture

Fake Geek Girls is a long-running pop culture criticism show where casual conversation and rigorous opinion keep interrupting each other in useful ways. Missy and Mary bring movies, books, television, and fandom discourse into a room that feels lived in. The pacing is quick. The perspective is patient enough to stay with a problem after the easy joke has landed. Recent episodes cover A Wrinkle in Time, Anora, Renfield, Watchmen, Sinners, and plans for Elementary, Wicked, Fleabag, and more of the Time Quartet. The show is especially interested in adaptation: what gets carried over, what gets sanded down, and what changes when an old story gets filtered through a new cultural moment. It can talk about Renfield as big-budget Dracula fan fiction and still pause over abuse, support groups, softness, and embarrassment. It can enjoy a performance, then ask what a comedy is asking the audience to laugh at. That combination gives the show its charge. Awards talk is similarly personal and argumentative, with Best Picture preferences tied less to checklists than to what a film leaves someone chewing on later. The hosts also push back against internet overhype, especially when a show or film arrives wrapped in a public narrative that does not match the actual experience of watching it. The conversations wander, but the wandering has a pattern. Microphone updates, therapy appointments, difficult Decembers, thrift-store books, family visits, reading education, and Taco Bell drinks sit beside comments on prison labor, white supremacy, superhero storytelling, and body horror. The result is not polished distance. It is criticism with receipts, digressions, mood swings, and old friendship in the margins. The humor is blunt. The emotional register is often more open than expected. The show can be irreverent about itself while still asking art to do better by the people and ideas it uses. It is best when affection and irritation arrive at the same time. For listeners who want cleanly segmented analysis, the route may feel winding. For listeners who like criticism that sounds like an ongoing argument between smart people with history, it has a distinct pull.

Made for: Best for pop culture listeners who like opinionated, conversational criticism of films, books, television, fandom, and adaptations. It especially suits people who want humor, personal context, and serious thematic reads in the same episode.

What sets it apart: The show’s edge comes from the way personal digressions and critical judgment feed each other instead of staying in separate lanes. It can joke about microphones or bad months, then pivot into adaptation, abuse dynamics, awards talk, or political subtext without changing its basic conversational texture.

In their own words

A podcast looking a nerdy pop culture from both a fan and critical perspective, encouraging the things we love to do better.

As heard by us

Based on 4 episodes we listened to · September 2026

Missy and Mary turn fan enthusiasm into pointed criticism without sanding away the jokes, disagreements, or complicated feelings that made the subject interesting.

Missy and Mary let affection start the argument, then keep pressing until a film or television favorite reveals its shakier assumptions. Their discussion of Renfield moves from performances and comedy to the film's treatment of abuse, asking where sympathy ends and embarrassment…

Read our full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Big-budget Dracula fan fiction lands you in bell hooks territory, with the jokes still intact.

Press play if you want

  • movie talk that admires Nicholas Hoult's range while questioning how comedy treats abuse
  • Oscar opinions driven by emotional aftertaste instead of a tasteful checklist
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
film and television criticismbook-to-screen adaptationOscar and Best Picture debatesgenre fandom and internet hypepersonal life and therapy digressionsabuse dynamics in pop culturepolitics in media storytellingplanned and commissioned episodes

Talks about

Best episodes of Fake Geek Girls - A Critical Look at Pop Culture

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

WWBUT 113 – Stalker With MannersMar 17, 2026

Missy and Miriam weigh the films they admire against the ones that move them most.

Missy and Miriam start with a joke about upcoming therapy appointments, then settle into films that have stayed with them. Wake Up Dead Man, Best Picture preferences and Sinners all come up, but their most interesting question is personal: should an awards contender be the film…

WWBUT 110 – Ted TacoSep 23, 2025

Missy and Mary move from taco jokes to books, prison labor, and period products.

A taco joke opens this Fake Geek Girls episode, followed by a loose stretch on children's television, Disney Plus, and taco preferences before Missy and Mary get to the prison discussion. Once there, the conversation becomes more pointed.

Episode 207 – RenfieldJul 15, 2025

Missy and Mary enjoy Renfield while questioning its jokes about abuse and discussing Nicholas Hoult's performance.

Missy and Mary have a good time with Renfield, calling it big budget Dracula fan fiction and a very funny movie. They also linger on a joke that troubles them: the film asks viewers to care about people dealing with abuse, then invites laughter at their support group.

WWBUT 77 – Shoulder Bracelet with Chair Pendant

Unsafe water park stories, startled hosts, and a little pop culture chat.

Missy and Mary start with Taylor Swift not releasing anything on Friday the 13th and the fan theories around it, then turn to an unsafe water park. A steep slide gave riders wedgies.

Podcasts like Fake Geek Girls - A Critical Look at Pop Culture

  • Stuff You Should KnowiHeartPodcasts

    From backyard cisterns to presidential bomb shelters.

  • American ScandalAudible

    Multi-part dramatized retellings of scandals like OceanGate's Titan and the Lehman Brothers collapse.

  • The Big PictureThe Ringer

    Two film obsessives arguing the movies that matter now

  • The RewatchablesThe Ringer

    Movies, a crowded Ringer table, endless tangents.

  • FilmspottingFilmspotting

    Two critics weighing new releases against the canon.

  • How Did This Get Made?Earwolf and Paul Scheer, June Diane Raphael, Jason Mantzoukas

    Paul Scheer, June Diane Raphael, and Jason Mantzoukas argue their way through terrible movies.

Episodes

  1. 1

    Episode 192 – Mrs. Davis

    ·2h 14m
  2. 2

    WWBUT 113 – Stalker With Manners

    ·1h 38m
  3. 3

    Episode 211 – A Wrinkle in Time

    ·1h 43m
  4. 4

    WWBUT 112 – Paddington’s Brother Eddington

    ·1h 45m
  5. 5

    Episode 210 – The Righteous Gemstones

    ·2h 5m
  6. 6

    WWBUT 111 – Deep Dive Into Nicholas Hoult’s Face

    ·1h 53m
  7. 7

    WWBUT 89 – Of Course the Fairies Come

    ·1h 35m
  8. 8

    WWBUT 88 – Thirty, Flirty, and Fliving

    ·1h 12m
  9. 9

    WWBUT 110 – Ted Taco

    ·1h 7m
  10. 10

    Episode 208 – The Substance

  11. 11

    WWBUT 109 – Stuffed-Up Vader

    ·1h 11m
  12. 12

    Episode 207 – Renfield

    ·1h 35m
  13. 13

    WWBUT 108 – Meat Guys

    ·1h 16m
  14. 14

    Episode 206 – Miss Congeniality

    ·1h 42m
  15. 15

    Episode 205 – But I’m a Cheerleader

    ·1h 48m
  16. 16

    WWBUT 106 – Big Oof

    ·1h 15m
  17. 17

    Episode 204 – Howl’s Moving Castle

  18. 18

    WWBUT 105 – Who’s the Wizard Now?

    ·1h 25m
  19. 19

    Episode 203 – Kill Bill

  20. 20

    WWBUT 104 – Sexy Lady Jail

    ·1h 12m
  21. 21

    Episode 202 – Over the Garden Wall

    ·1h 36m
  22. 22

    WWBUT 103 – We Need to Be Chewing

    ·1h 12m
  23. 23

    Episode 201 – Poor Things

    ·1h 43m
  24. 24

    WWBUT 102 – Mr. McMan

    ·55m
  25. 25

    Episode 200 – Maniac

  26. 26

    WWBUT 101 – Big Pharma, Big Fan

    ·1h 4m
  27. 27

    Episode 199 – X-Men: From the Ashes with Nola Pfau

    ·2h 21m
  28. 28

    Episode 198 – Scott Pilgrim, Part 2 with Kat Overland

    ·2h 41m
  29. 29

    Episode 197 – Scott Pilgrim, Part One with Kat Overland

    ·1h 53m
  30. 30

    WWBUT 100 – Egg Guy

    ·1h 7m
  31. 31

    Episode 196 – Ken (Or: Barbie 2.0)

    ·1h 59m
  32. 32

    WWBUT 99 – That Boy Can MOPE

    ·58m
  33. 33

    Episode 195 – Barbie

    ·2h 22m
  34. 34

    WWBUT 98 – Vapers Gonna Vape, Vape, Vape, Vape, Vape

    ·1h 11m
  35. 35

    Episode 193 – Jaws

    ·1h 32m
  36. 36

    WWBUT 97 – Picking Apples in Papa’s Orchard

    ·1h 50m
  37. 37

    Episode 209 – Anora

    ·1h 51m
  38. 38

    WWBUT 95 – Where Are the Gay Dinosaurs, Oppenheimer?

    ·54m
  39. 39

    Episode 192 – Interview With the Vampire

    ·1h 54m
  40. 40

    WWBUT 95 – We’re Still Talking About Midsommar

    ·53m
  41. 41

    Episode 191 – Spice World

    ·2h 1m
  42. 42

    WWBUT 94 – Ariana Grande is Singing About bell hooks

    ·53m
  43. 43

    Episode 190 – Magic Mike XXL

    ·1h 28m
  44. 44

    WWBUT 93 – A Low Blow by the Lobos

    ·1h 25m
  45. 45

    Episode 189 – The Amber Spyglass

    ·2h 7m
  46. 46

    WWBUT 92 – Snake Content (Snontent)

    ·1h 24m
  47. 47

    Episode 188 – Letterkenny

    ·1h 46m
  48. 48

    WWBUT 91 – The Sousaphone is the Sexiest Instrument

    ·1h 14m
  49. 49

    Episode 187 – Mean Girls

    ·1h 40m
  50. 50

    WWBUT 90 – He’s Not Aging, He’s Animorphing

    ·1h 32m
  51. 51

    Episode 186 – American Gods

    ·2h 8m
  52. 52

    Episode 185 – Russian Doll

    ·1h 28m
  53. 53

    WWBUT 87 – Just Dance

    ·55m
  54. 54

    Episode 184 – Daria

    ·1h 50m
  55. 55

    Episode 175 – Eclipse

    ·1h 48m
  56. 56

    Episode 183 – Practical Magic

    ·1h 35m
  57. 57

    Episode 182 – The Sandman

    ·1h 41m
  58. 58

    WWBUT 84 – Salad Boy

    ·1h 55m
  59. 59

    Episode 181 – Sex Education

    ·1h 37m
  60. 60

    WWBUT 83 – To Simp or Not to Simp

    ·1h 28m
  61. 61

    Episode 180 – Good Omens

    ·1h 37m
  62. 62

    WWBUT 82 – Baseball Metaphors

    ·37m
  63. 63

    Episode 179 – What We Do in the Shadows

    ·1h 32m
  64. 64

    WWBUT 81 – Hate to See a Girlboss Winning

    ·58m
  65. 65

    Episode 179 – Pushing Daisies

    ·1h 42m
  66. 66

    WWBUT 80 – I Cut Jens and O I Wan

    ·59m
  67. 67

    Episode 178 – The Matrix Part Two

    ·1h 46m
  68. 68

    WWBUT 79 – Real Spider-Man

    ·52m
  69. 69

    Episode 177 – The Matrix Part One

    ·1h 46m
  70. 70

    WWBUT 78 – Nasty Wet Shows

    ·57m
  71. 71

    Episode 176 – Saint Maud

    ·1h 26m
  72. 72

    WWBUT 76 – Something Inappropriate About the Easter Bunny

    ·54m
  73. 73

    Episode 174 – Fruits Basket Part Two

    ·1h 45m
  74. 74

    WWBUT 75 – Love It When It’s a Clown

    ·57m
  75. 75

    WWBUT 74 – Clownsexual

    ·56m
  76. 76

    Episode 173 – Fruits Basket Part One

    ·1h 35m
  77. 77

    WWBUT 73 – Ladies in the Club

    ·48m
  78. 78

    Episode 172 – Skins

    ·1h 42m
  79. 79

    WWBUT 72 – Murder Bus

    ·43m
  80. 80

    Episode 171 – Constantine and Constantine

    ·1h 44m
  81. 81

    WWBUT 71 – Let Him Have a Hook

    ·49m
  82. 82

    Episode 170 – Hellblazer

    ·1h 53m
  83. 83

    WWBUT 70 – Fake Geese Girls

    ·55m
  84. 84

    Episode 169 – The Vampire Diaries Seasons 5 – 8

    ·1h 49m
  85. 85

    WWBUT 69 – Harry Styles’s Fursona

    ·1h 22m
  86. 86

    WWBUT 68 – Passions, the Soap Opera

    ·1h 52m
  87. 87

    WWBUT 67 – Vaccine-Induced Soapboxing

    ·1h 25m
  88. 88

    Episode 168 – Derry Girls

    ·1h 32m
  89. 89

    WWBUT 66 – My Next D&D Character is a Real Estate Agent

    ·1h 27m
  90. 90

    Episode 167 – New Moon

    ·1h 50m
  91. 91

    WWBUT 65 – If You Can’t Cuddle It, I Don’t Want It

    ·49m
  92. 92

    Episode 166 – James Bond – Daniel Craig

    ·2h 5m
  93. 93

    WWBUT 64 – I Love the Frogs

    ·45m
  94. 94

    Episode 165 – The Almighty Johnsons

    ·1h 37m
  95. 95

    WWBUT 64 – Put That on My Tombstone

    ·57m
  96. 96

    Episode 164 – James Bond – Pierce Brosnan

    ·1h 46m
  97. 97

    WWBUT 86 – We’re in an Open Relationship With Kermit

    Missy and Mary discuss their open relationship with Kermit the Frog and Missy's review of Halloween Ends.

    ·1h 9m
  98. 98

    WWBUT 107 – A Vanilla Milkshake

    The hosts of Fakie Girls podcast discuss being sick and briefly mention watching the movie Conclave.

    ·1h 9m
  99. 99

    WWBUT 85 – Pin Mommy

    The hosts discuss their recent concert experiences and debate which musicians they would join a cult for, focusing on Florence Welch and Jared Leto.

    ·1h
  100. 100

    WWBUT 77 – Shoulder Bracelet with Chair Pendant

    Hidden gem

    Christine's purses were literally "a chair" and "a shoulder bracelet with a chair pendant."

    ·58m·2 clips
  101. 101

    WWBUT 113 – Stalker With Manners

    The hosts of Fake Geek Girls podcast catch up after a break, discussing personal therapy appointments and their thoughts on the new Knives Out movie.

    Mar 17, 2026·1h 38m·2 clips
  102. 102

    Episode 211 – A Wrinkle in Time

    The hosts of Fakie Girls podcast discuss their personal struggles with December and introduce their episode on 'A Wrinkle in Time'.

    Feb 17, 2026·1h 43m
  103. 103

    WWBUT 112 – Paddington’s Brother Eddington

    The hosts of Fake Geek Girls chat about their rough Novembers and Decembers, new cats, and thrift store finds.

    Jan 13, 2026·1h 45m
  104. 104

    Episode 210 – The Righteous Gemstones

    Nov 25, 2025·2h 5m
  105. 105

    WWBUT 111 – Deep Dive Into Nicholas Hoult’s Face

    The hosts of Fake Geek Girls discuss a podcast about reading education and banter about personal topics before diving into Nicholas Hoult's face.

    Oct 28, 2025·1h 53m
  106. 106

    Episode 209 – Anora

    The hosts discuss the movie Anora, arguing it shouldn't have won Best Picture at the Oscars and comparing it to the snubbed film Hustlers.

    Oct 7, 2025·1h 51m
  107. 107

    WWBUT 110 – Ted Taco

    Hidden gem

    Victoria Law's "Prisons make us safer and 20 other myths about mass incarceration" challenges the idea that prisons are mainly for profit, and the hosts note that most prisons are not for profit.

    Sep 23, 2025·1h 7m·2 clips
  108. 108

    WWBUT 109 – Stuffed-Up Vader

    "Broke boy propaganda" gets tied to Dakota Johnson, Chris Evans, and Pedro Pascal in a debate about class and love.

    Aug 5, 2025·1h 11m·2 clips
  109. 109

    Episode 207 – Renfield

    Hidden gem

    Fake Geek Girls uses Renfield to compare Dracula’s control to labor exploitation, citing Marx, a bakery example, and the film’s repeated “boss” language.

    Jul 15, 2025·1h 35m·2 clips
  110. 110

    WWBUT 108 – Meat Guys

    Jun 24, 2025·1h 16m
  111. 111

    Episode 206 – Miss Congeniality

    Jun 3, 2025·1h 42m
  112. 112

    WWBUT 107 – A Vanilla Milkshake

    May 20, 2025·1h 9m
  113. 113

    Episode 205 – But I’m a Cheerleader

    May 6, 2025·1h 48m
  114. 114

    WWBUT 106 – Big Oof

    Apr 22, 2025·1h 15m
  115. 115

    WWBUT 105 – Who’s the Wizard Now?

    Feb 25, 2025·1h 25m
  116. 116

    WWBUT 104 – Sexy Lady Jail

    Jan 21, 2025·1h 12m
  117. 117

    Episode 202 – Over the Garden Wall

    Jan 7, 2025·1h 36m
  118. 118

    WWBUT 103 – We Need to Be Chewing

    Dec 10, 2024·1h 12m
  119. 119

    Episode 201 – Poor Things

    Nov 19, 2024·1h 43m
  120. 120

    WWBUT 102 – Mr. McMan

    Oct 16, 2024·55m
  121. 121

    WWBUT 101 – Big Pharma, Big Fan

    Aug 6, 2024·1h 4m
  122. 122

    Episode 199 – X-Men: From the Ashes with Nola Pfau

    Jun 20, 2024·2h 21m
  123. 123

    Episode 198 – Scott Pilgrim, Part 2 with Kat Overland

    Apr 30, 2024·2h 41m
  124. 124

    Episode 197 – Scott Pilgrim, Part One with Kat Overland

    Mar 19, 2024·1h 53m
  125. 125

    WWBUT 100 – Egg Guy

    Jan 16, 2024·1h 7m
  126. 126

    Episode 196 – Ken (Or: Barbie 2.0)

    Jan 2, 2024·1h 59m
  127. 127

    WWBUT 99 – That Boy Can MOPE

    Dec 19, 2023·58m
  128. 128

    Episode 195 – Barbie

    Dec 5, 2023·2h 22m
  129. 129

    WWBUT 98 – Vapers Gonna Vape, Vape, Vape, Vape, Vape

    Nov 14, 2023·1h 11m
  130. 130

    Episode 193 – Jaws

    Oct 31, 2023·1h 32m
  131. 131

    WWBUT 97 – Picking Apples in Papa’s Orchard

    Oct 17, 2023·1h 50m
  132. 132

    Episode 192 – Mrs. Davis

    Oct 3, 2023·2h 14m
  133. 133

    WWBUT 95 – Where Are the Gay Dinosaurs, Oppenheimer?

    Aug 15, 2023·54m
  134. 134

    Episode 192 – Interview With the Vampire

    Jul 25, 2023·1h 54m
  135. 135

    WWBUT 95 – We’re Still Talking About Midsommar

    The hosts discuss their recent viewing of RuPaul's Drag Race and compare it to other competition shows like Project Runway and America's Next Top Model.

    Jul 11, 2023·53m
  136. 136

    Episode 191 – Spice World

    Jun 27, 2023·2h 1m
  137. 137

    WWBUT 94 – Ariana Grande is Singing About bell hooks

    The hosts discuss revisiting comfort media and a Netflix documentary about the Waco cult.

    Jun 13, 2023·53m
  138. 138

    Episode 190 – Magic Mike XXL

    May 30, 2023·1h 28m
  139. 139

    WWBUT 93 – A Low Blow by the Lobos

    May 16, 2023·1h 25m
  140. 140

    Episode 189 – The Amber Spyglass

    May 2, 2023·2h 7m
  141. 141

    WWBUT 92 – Snake Content (Snontent)

    Apr 11, 2023·1h 24m
  142. 142

    Episode 188 – Letterkenny

    Mar 28, 2023·1h 46m
  143. 143

    WWBUT 91 – The Sousaphone is the Sexiest Instrument

    Mar 14, 2023·1h 14m
  144. 144

    Episode 187 – Mean Girls

    Feb 28, 2023·1h 40m
  145. 145

    WWBUT 90 – He’s Not Aging, He’s Animorphing

    Feb 7, 2023·1h 32m
  146. 146

    Episode 186 – American Gods

    Jan 31, 2023·2h 8m