PRESS PLAY
We all want to drink from the same Cup of Justice... and it starts with learning about our legal system.With tales from the newsroom and the courtroom, co-hosts Mandy Matney, Liz Farrell and Eric Bland invite you to gain knowledge, insight, and tools to hold public agencies and officials accountable. Beginning as bonus episodes to the Murdaugh Murders Podcast with analysis of the trials of Alex Murdaugh and co-conspirators, Cup of Justice launched as its own show in January of 2023 and debuted at #1 on Apple its very first day and continues to be a top rated pod globally.Mandy Matney...
Based on 5 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Cup Of Justice connects true-crime cases to courtroom procedure and the experience of families pressing institutions for answers.
Cup Of Justice keeps its attention on the collision between criminal cases and the institutions expected to handle them. Mandy Matney, Liz Farrell and Eric Bland move from family testimony to court proceedings, asking who held authority and what officials disclosed.
Scott Spivey's family read the news for answers; you'll want Mandy, Liz and Eric asking questions.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A difficult two-matter recap finds its sharpest point in the courtroom reasoning.
Soundbite puts two hard matters involving power and child sexual abuse material in the same frame: former South Carolina representative Robert John May III, who goes by R.J., has pleaded guilty to federal charges, while Judge James Benjamin Gosnell denies wrongdoing in his own…
A holiday check-in turns into a procedural look at disputed records, legal compulsion, and the people called the "knife fighters."
Cup Of Justice begins with Easter and Passover greetings, a brief note that a soldier shot down over Iran had been rescued, and the hosts' understanding that the CIA had been sending misinformation.
A South Carolina accountability episode links the Micah Francis and Scott Spivey matters to 911 failures and institutional distrust.
Police accountability in Horry County, South Carolina, gives this episode its center. The hosts treat the Micah Francis and Scott Spivey matters as signs of a deeper trust problem around the Horry County Police Department, then widen the lens to what that means when someone has…
A family tries to reclaim Scott's story after law enforcement keeps them at a distance.
Scott's family frames the episode around a shattering loss of trust in law enforcement. They describe being kept at a distance while early accounts cast him as the suspect and aggressor, leaving relatives to piece together a violent case through media reports, Facebook posts,…
A LunaShark Premium preview pairing Hulu-related member materials with accessible jury-trial and defamation context.
LunaShark's Premium preview positions Hulu's Murdoch Death in the Family as the anchor for a broader member bundle, with curated materials connected to each of the eight episodes and a busy legal-news cycle around it.
Law, explained where the news gets complicated.
A murder case with America on trial.
Supreme Court law without the courthouse voice.
Legal fury, reproductive justice, court by court.
Animal cases, legal stakes, real consequences.
This episode explores the historical context of St.
This episode features an interview with Kimberly Taylor, CEO of JAMS, discussing mediation and arbitration as alternatives to traditional courtroom battles, focusing on contracts and compromise.
This episode discusses the arrest of South Carolina Judge James B.
This episode covers JP Miller's arraignment on federal cyberstalking and lying charges related to the death of his wife Micah Miller, while also promoting a book about the Murdoch dynasty and announcing a fan meetup.
This episode promotes a new investigative travel podcast while sharing personal family updates and commentary on celebrity news.
A host discusses their recent dismissal from a lawsuit with prejudice and expresses frustration about ongoing misinformation and potential defamation from online sources.
This episode discusses Stephen Smith's legacy while exploring legal topics like Stand Your Ground laws and citizens' arrest, alongside personal anecdotes from a family gathering.
This episode discusses the upcoming retrial of Michael Colucci for the 2015 murder of his wife Sarah Lynn, focusing on how his attorney's health and case delays may have advantaged him as a wealthy defendant.
This episode features an interview with Jonny McCoy, who shares his personal journey from being a victim of police misconduct to becoming an advocate fighting corruption through legal action against the Horry County Police Department.
This episode discusses First Amendment issues, scandals, and sexual harassment, while also promoting Hulu's Murdoch series and sharing personal anecdotes about dermatology.
This episode analyzes unexpected arguments in the Murdaugh case Supreme Court appeal, focusing on the court's surprising stance against the state and critiques of Justice Toll and Judge Newman.
This episode discusses legal developments including Liz's deposition by Greg Parker's attorneys, a lawsuit filed by Weldon Boyd, and commentary on Dick Harpootlian's criticisms, all related to the Murdoch Death in the Family case.
This episode discusses the ongoing legal saga involving Alex Murdaugh and the Parker litigation, exploring how journalists are caught in the crossfire and examining the role of lawyers in high-stakes cases.
This episode features Sarah Turney discussing her sister's 2001 disappearance and her advocacy work through the 'Voices for Justice' podcast.
This episode discusses the burdens of the Parker lawsuit, including the time and financial costs of litigation and discovery abuses, while also touching on holiday greetings and personal grievances.
This episode discusses the horrific details of a South Carolina legislator's arrest in a pedophilia case and the retrial of Michael Colucci, aiming to be a turning point in justice.
This episode discusses a judge's denial of Stand Your Ground immunity to Weldon Boyd and explores its implications for justice, presented by the True Sunlight podcast team.
This episode celebrates the podcast's 150th show milestone while discussing the Hulu series 'Murdoch Death in the Family' and its portrayal of the Murdoch family saga and murders.
This episode features attorney Mark Tinsley discussing the Murdaugh cases, their Hulu adaptation, and the pursuit of truth in this high-profile legal saga.
This episode discusses the state's response to murderer Alex Murdaugh's appeal and includes a mention of Nancy Mace, focusing on updates in the high-profile true crime case.
This episode features author Kate Moore discussing her book about Elizabeth Packard, a 19th-century woman wrongfully committed to an asylum for expressing her opinions, highlighting themes of resilience and women's rights.
This episode discusses the Stand Your Ground hearing in the Spivey case, the arrest of journalists in Minnesota, and Alex Murdoch's Supreme Court appeal, highlighting legal and journalistic issues.
This special bonus episode marks the 10-year anniversary of Stephen Smith's unsolved murder, focusing on seeking justice and answers for his family while reviewing case developments.
This episode features an interview with journalist Matt Shaer, exploring the balance between entertainment and justice in true crime podcasting, his work on shows like Over My Dead Body and Suspect, and the ethical challenges in the genre.
A South Carolina journalist recounts her experiences with the powerful Murdoch family, her book about exposing crimes, and her law firm's commitment to fighting for justice.
This episode discusses the controversial dismissal of Michael Colucci's murder charge for the 2015 strangulation death of Sarah Lynn Moore Colucci due to prosecutorial misconduct, and the ongoing fight for justice led by her daughter.
The hosts discuss their Halloween costumes, including a Taylor Swift witch and a time traveler to the Gilded Age, while touching on themes of misogyny and historical adaptation.
This episode discusses claims of citizen's arrest and other absurd developments in the Murdaugh case, while also exploring who is seeking a new trial.
This episode discusses an off-duty deputy in South Carolina who held teenagers at gunpoint, exploring the community's response and pressure on politicians while connecting it to the hosts' work on the Murdoch case.
This episode features Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Maggie Freleng discussing the myth of objectivity in journalism and the urgent need for criminal justice reform.
This special year-end episode of Cup of Justice recaps powerful 2025 moments, featuring interviews with journalists, detectives, exonerees, and others discussing justice, accountability, and victim-centered reporting.
This episode discusses David Pascoe, a South Carolina attorney general candidate, and his efforts to combat corruption and political protectionism in the state's justice system, highlighting past cases involving shady deals and judicial misconduct.
This episode examines the role of victims' voices in the Bryan Kohberger case and criticizes South Carolina Attorney General Alan Wilson for alleged corruption and inaction in cases like Scott Spivey's.
This episode discusses JP Miller's federal arraignment and potential defense funding while looking ahead to 2026, interspersed with personal holiday anecdotes and media recommendations.
This episode introduces a new investigative travel podcast that explores destinations by uncovering their real history, talking to locals, and addressing challenging questions beyond typical tourism.
This episode discusses two shocking cases: an off-duty sheriff's deputy pointing a gun at teenagers in South Carolina and RJ May pleading guilty to sharing child sex abuse videos.
This episode features an interview with Pulitzer Prize-winning author Gilbert King about his work on wrongful convictions, the justice system, and his impactful podcast/book Bone Valley.
This episode discusses the latest legal developments in the Alex Murdaugh case, including a new filing that suggests his guilt, and features insights from Alicia Kelley who plays Liz Farrell in Hulu's 'Murdaugh: Death In the Family'.
This episode features an interview with true crime podcaster Stephanie Tinsley about her investigation into the 2007 murder of Danny Harris in Memphis, uncovering hidden secrets and corruption in the case.
This episode discusses a person exploiting the investigation into Stephen's death by spreading unverified claims online, while expressing support for Sandy Smith and criticizing those who interfere with proper investigative procedures.
The podcast discusses South Carolina's Supreme Court power dynamics and Attorney General Alan Wilson's THC enforcement actions, while also covering personal health struggles with elective surgeries.
This episode discusses how Greg Parker's legal team is using aggressive legal tactics to harass journalists covering the wrongful death lawsuit between the Beach family and Parker's Kitchen.
The host reflects on taking a restorative break from covering dark justice system stories, celebrates 100 episodes of True Sunlight Podcast, and previews upcoming trial coverage including Michael Colucci's retrial and other cases, while teasing premium content for members.
The episode dives into the chaos surrounding Becky Hill's new felony charges, including misconduct and perjury related to the Murdaugh trial, while critiquing media ethics and defending the fairness of the trial.
This episode of Cup of Justice discusses flaws in the U.S.
Soundbite recaps the federal cases against R.J.
Cup Of Justice #175 centers on Mandy Matney's contested deposition in the Greg Parker civil conspiracy case, with the hosts saying the real fight is over security and location.
["Cup Of Justice #129 focuses on the Scott Spivey shooting investigation in Horry County, South Carolina, and the hosts describe it as another failure in local law enforcement.", "Mandy Matney, Liz Farrell, and Eric Bland revisit Horry County 911 dispatch, the Connor Cook boat-crash call, and the claim that seconds matter when callers are trying to get help.", "They walk through Weldon Boyd's 911 call while chasing Spivey, Bradley Williams's phone activity during that call, and the legal split between Highway 9 and Camp Swamp Road.", "The episode also targets Horry County Police's public statements about Brandon Strickland, FBI and SLED involvement, and local media coverage, including Isaac Bailey's warning that South Carolina tourists may not be safe."]
Cup Of Justice focuses on the killing of 33-year-old Scott Spivey on a rural Horry County road in September 2023 and the family’s claim that the response was mishandled from the start.
Cup Of Justice uses a Lunashark Premium preview to bundle media literacy, legal literacy, and behind-the-scenes membership perks around Hulu's Murdoch project.
The episode discusses a legal agreement in Micah Miller's estate case and promotes the host's law firm.
Co-host Eric Bland promotes his memoir and discusses a bizarre interview with J.P.
The episode introduces the True Sunlight podcast, which investigates criminal cases and systemic corruption, highlighting its mission to expose truth and empower listeners.
This episode discusses the upcoming Colucci trial and provides legal analysis, continuing coverage of high-profile criminal cases.
This episode promotes a new travel podcast and a law firm, but the show Cup of Justice focuses on legal analysis and accountability in high-profile cases.