Canadian disappearances, with the unconfirmed parts marked plainly.
Crime and Mystery Canada talks through Canadian cases such as the disappearances of Michelle Wedge and Christina Calayca, weighing RCMP statements and published accounts against what remains unexplained. Danielle and a second voice keep it conversational, flagging shaky details, setting rumours aside and pausing on the human cost.
PRESS PLAY
Crime and Mystery Canada stays with Canadian cases, and the one it keeps coming back to is the disappearance. The titles make the pattern plain: 'Ep.68: The Disappearance of Michelle Wedge', 'Ep.67: The Disappearance of Rachel Bagnall and Jonathan Jette', 'Ep. 66:The Disappearance of Christina Calayca'. Two voices carry the conversation, with Danielle introducing the show. That introduction sets modest terms, disclaiming expertise, describing the speaker as simply an interested party, and warning that some episodes are serious while others are lighter. The modesty shows in the method. In the Michelle Wedge episode, reports of a car and a man seen inside it are raised and then doubted, set against an RCMP spokesperson who, interviewed on Information Morning, said the case is not classified as an abduction but remains an open criminal investigation. Nobody smooths over the contradiction; one voice admits to struggling to square the two. The Rachel Bagnall and Jonathan Jette episode handles sources the same way, drawing on MysteriesofCanada.com while wondering aloud whether the search dogs were really bloodhounds. Small turns in a search get their due, like a pair of sunglasses thought to be Rachel's that belonged to another hiker who had lost them earlier. The Christina Calayca episode works at the same close range, walking through the trails near the camp, their lengths, and how the people she was with searched on their own without asking others whether they had seen her. 'Ep. 64: Missing Children in Canada' is described on air as a change of routine, with preparation handed from one voice to the other. It takes up the case of a girl whom witnesses saw getting into a Ford Ranger truck, wonders why the case has not drawn the media coverage it should, and deliberately sticks to police statements, pointing anyone curious about the rumours toward social media rather than repeating them. The lens also widens beyond single cases. For 'Ep.42: Residential Schools in Canada Pt.2', Danielle speaks with Susan Levi-Peters, who describes being the first woman chief in her community, writing a book about shale gas, and speaking out on treaty rights and social justice. The reason given on air is direct: online comments about residential schools angered Danielle and seemed to come from people who did not know what the schools actually were. Weight is acknowledged rather than rushed. 'Ep. 65: Three Generations' pauses its story for an aside on why threatening letters and unwanted appearances leave women frightened, and the Christina Calayca episode closes with a moment of silence to honour lives lost. Kindness gets airtime too. One closing praises a young man named Owen for his way with cats, and another voices gladness for 'moments of kindness' in a case described as super heavy. Closings also point to the show's Facebook group and Instagram. What a listener gets is plain-spoken company through hard Canadian stories: what is known, what is missing, and an honest flag whenever a detail cannot be confirmed.
Made for: Suits a listener who wants Canadian missing-persons cases talked through in plain conversation, with doubtful details flagged and rumours kept out, and who is comfortable with material involving missing children and sexual assault.
What sets it apart: It is candid about its limits: expertise is disclaimed at the top, unconfirmed reports are labelled as unconfirmed, and social-media rumours are pointed to rather than repeated, while the attention stays firmly on Canadian cases and RCMP investigations.
A weekly podcast exploring the darker side of Canada. You can reach us at [email protected] or @crimeandmysterycanada on Instagram.
Those sunglasses looked like a clue; you'll appreciate the moment they become another hiker's lost property.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
Its strength is the unresolved tension between a missing-person file and an open criminal investigation.
Michelle Wedge's disappearance is handled as a careful, uneasy look at what remains unknown after a seven-and-a-half-year-old girl vanished in the Maritimes on July 2, 1975.
A planned three-day hike becomes deeply unsettling when a ten-day search finds no trace of the couple.
Rachel Bagnell and Jonathan Jette vanish during what was meant to be a three-day hike, leaving a found vehicle, a large search effort, and very little that fits a simple wilderness explanation.
A careful missing-person episode shaped by park trails, a delayed alarm, and the uncertainty of the first crucial hours.
Crime and Mystery Canada follows Christina's disappearance in a provincial park in northern Ontario with a steady focus on the uneasy stretch between realizing someone is missing and seeing an official response begin.
A Burke's Fall tragedy becomes a sober look at warning signs, intimidation, and the long shadow of violence.
Crime and Mystery Canada uses the 2018 tragedy in Burke's Fall, Ontario, as a grim entry point into a family killing that spanned three generations. Danielle keeps the focus on whether warning signs were missed or left unanswered.
A sober Canadian missing-child discussion shaped by police decisions, rumor control, and an unresolved search.
Crime and Mystery Canada follows a recent New Brunswick missing-child case as its central thread, while also leaving space for the discovery of the remains of 215 Indigenous children at a former residential school in British Columbia.
ABC Audio's Theranos fraud series that also introduces its other true-crime podcasts.
LA Times reporter Christopher Goffard traces con man John Meehan's fraud, abuse, and its Bravo TV adaptation.
Crime and Mystery Canada follows Michelle Wedge’s disappearance from Dominion Street in Moncton, New Brunswick, after July 2, 1975, when she was 7 and a half years old.
Crime and Mystery Canada covers the disappearance of Jonathan Jette, 34, and Rachel Bagnall, 25, who left Vancouver, British Columbia for a three-day Labor Day hike near Valentine Lake and were last documented at Tim Hortons in Squamish at 7:42 a.m.
Crime and Mystery Canada covers the disappearance of 20-year-old Christina Calayca, who left Toronto for Rainbow Falls Provincial Park in northern Ontario on Sunday, August 5, 2007.
Crime and Mystery Canada's “Three Generations” follows the Burke's Falls, Ontario case of Ula Tarunan, her son Paul, and her mother Raya, all killed in 2018 after years of warning signs around Mark Jones.
Crime and Mystery Canada links New Brunswick missing-children cases with the Kamloops Residential School discovery, citing a CTV News report that the site opened in 1893 and that ground-penetrating radar found 215 bodies.
Danielle and Polynel trace Peter Verigin’s rise as leader of the Doukhobors, a Russian Christian group committed to pacifism.
Crime and Mystery Canada examines Brian O'Neill's book Bodies in the Backyard and the Noel Winters case near St.
Host Danielle interviews Susan Levi-Peters about the history and impact of residential schools in Canada.
The episode discusses the unsolved disappearance of 20-year-old Maddie Scott from Vanderhoof, B.C., in 2011.
This episode explores the mysterious appearance of a man with amputated legs on a beach in Sandy Cove, Nova Scotia in 1863.
The hosts discuss the 30-year-old cold case of Charles Horvath Allen's disappearance in Canada.
This episode covers the solved cold case of nine-year-old Christine Jessup, who was abducted in 1984 in Ontario, Canada.
This episode covers the unsolved 1976 murder of Rona Duncan in North Vancouver.
This episode discusses the unsolved disappearance of Leonette Purcell in Nova Scotia in 2004.
This episode investigates the 1996 disappearance of 15-year-old Melanie Ittier in Northern Ontario.