Dark cases, haunted jokes, strange exits.
Creep Street Podcast treats the strange as both a campfire story and a comedy room. Episodes move from ghost ships and farmhouse murders to hostage-radio sketches, psychic meltdowns, and holiday schemes gone sinister.
PRESS PLAY
Creep Street Podcast is an audio funhouse for the eerie, the gruesome, and the ridiculous. Its center of gravity is horror-adjacent true crime and unexplained history, but its personality comes from the way dread keeps colliding with comedy. The MV Joyita episode lingers on the impossible logic of a battered, floating ship left behind with supplies still aboard. The Hinterkaifeck episodes turn a rural murder case into a slow accumulation of attic noises, missing keys, footprints, scraps of food, and the awful thought that someone may have been inside the home before the violence. The Pamela Werner episode leans into rumor, suspicion, and a city trying to name a killer when evidence refuses to cooperate. These are not tidy mystery-box stories. They are stories about what remains ugly, strange, or unresolved after the facts have been counted. The show can be stark. It can also be deeply silly. Recent sketch episodes stage a chamber-music broadcast during a hostage situation, a psychic reading that goes catastrophically wrong, Santa pitching a festive recruitment scheme, and a press briefing that cannot stop denying what it keeps revealing. That range is the point. Creep Street uses heightened narration, grotesque imagery, and quick comic turns to keep the listener off balance. A solemn passage about vanished passengers may sit near a fake History Channel bit about terrible seamanship. A farmhouse investigation may be preceded by a joke scene that turns horror-movie tropes inside out. The show suits listeners who like paranormal and true-crime storytelling but do not need it delivered with straight-faced reverence. It is for people comfortable with grisly detail, deadpan absurdity, and the abyss as something worth staring into, then heckling. The result is less a polished documentary feed than a dark neighborhood tour: murder houses, ghost ships, psychic parlors, bad institutions, suspicious attics, and jokes waiting in the shadows.
Made for: For listeners who like true crime, paranormal history, and horror sketches with a comic edge. It suits people who can handle grim material when it is filtered through theatrical storytelling and absurd timing.
What sets it apart: Creep Street Podcast stands out by letting dread and sketch comedy occupy the same space. It can tell a grim unresolved case with gothic intensity, then pivot into a bizarre fake broadcast or satirical scene without losing its identity.
Creep Street Podcast is an exploration of the absurd—the unsettling recognition of the fragile veneer of reality, and what may be beyond it. A world indifferent, chaotic, and haunted by eldritch forces. It does not seek comfort in easy answers, nor does it indulge in the naive reassurance that all mysteries can be solved. Instead, it embraces the abyss, staring unflinching into the void where folklore, horror, and true crime intertwine. Also, there's jokes... New Epsiodes Every Thursday!
A haunted farmhouse gets the case-file treatment, after a cold open about dangerously bad butter.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A theatrical opening gives way to Pamela Werner's murder and the gap between rumor and evidence.
Pamela Werner's murder sits behind an opening that is almost perversely theatrical. A request for a suspect sends the detectives into gloomy talk of snowflakes, and a John Deere adds to the grim absurdity. Then the episode turns to Pamela's body.
A revenant runs a 5K before Berwick's story trades race commentary for dread.
A revenant runs a 5K with sponsors, a trackside reporter and hounds in pursuit. The play-by-play treats a loose arm like another race update. That joke makes the turn to Berwick's dead more unsettling: the later story dwells on a body that has not decayed, giving the grisly…
Adam Seltzer tests Chicago ghost stories against firsthand accounts and his own odd experience at the Congress Hotel.
Dylan Hackworth welcomes Adam Seltzer to the Creep Street Podcast for a conversation about Chicago ghost stories and how Seltzer decides which ones belong on a tour. His first question is practical: can he bring a group to the site?
Quiet narration for stories that stay awake.
Haunted history with banter and receipts.
Film verdicts first. Then the ghosts.
Original horror where the ordinary goes quietly wrong.
Plainspoken fear with unfinished explanations.
Fast horror stories with a final chill.
A detective investigates the murder of a girl named Pamela Werner, encountering philosophical musings from a cynical partner.
A comedic podcast episode where hosts pretend to be a cult leader performing impossible miracles as a prank.
The hosts of Creep Street apologize for their absence due to health issues and announce a summer break, while teasing upcoming content about the Demon House of Detroit and Jellyfish UFOs.
Creep Street Podcast speaks with Adam Selzer, founder of Mysterious Chicago, about Chicago hauntings, archival research, and his work as an author and tour guide.
A comedic parody of a History Channel documentary about the mysterious abandoned ship MV Joyita.
During a chamber music broadcast, the hosts are taken hostage at gunpoint and calmly continue the show while reading demands from their captors.
A psychic's consultation with a newlywed takes a terrifying turn when she foresees a gruesome fate for his marriage.
A satirical press briefing where the Secretary of War repeatedly denies oil motives while discussing military strikes on Venezuela.
Santa pitches a multi-level marketing scheme called YuleLife to a child instead of giving a traditional gift.
Maria Baumgartner arrived at Hinterkaifeck seeking honest work and became the case’s overlooked victim.
Creep Street Podcast’s “The Shadow Over Hinterkaifeck: Part One” reconstructs a 1922 Bavarian farm tragedy involving the Gruber family and six deaths.
Creep Street Podcast’s "Pamela Werner: The Fox Tower Murder" follows Pamela Werner’s 1937 killing in Peking and the later debate over who did it.
Creep Street Podcast’s “The Revenants of Berwick & Melrose” opens with a fake race broadcast about Lord Vellum of Berwick-on-Tweed, the 314th Midnight Reverend 5K, and a pack of Hellhounds chasing a decomposing noble through town.
A comedic ad for a paranormal emporium that humorously ties UFO paranoia to home protection, referencing the 1968 Spain UFO incident and current New Jersey drone sightings.
A Christmas-themed skit where a father is forced to sit on Santa's lap, leading to a tense revelation that Santa is someone from a convenience store.