Conviction (Season Series)

Gimlet

13 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

Crime stories where the record does not rest.

The gist

Conviction follows cases where the official record leaves hard questions behind. Across seasons, it moves from Max B's hotel-room robbery case to the Quinneys' family rupture and Pedro Hernandez's case against police narratives.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About Conviction (Season Series)

Conviction is a serialized investigative anthology about criminal cases that keep producing questions after the official story has already been written. Its episodes move with the patience of long-form reporting. A season on Max B follows a Harlem rapper near a breakthrough, a plan around a bag of money, and a hotel-room robbery that turns fatal. The story does not reduce the case to guilt or innocence. It tracks how Charlie, Gina, Sims, Alan Plowden, and others enter a chain of decisions that grows harder to untangle with every interview. Another season, American Panic, begins with John Quinney's childhood memories and widens into family fracture, religious fear, allegations of abuse, and the long shadow of trauma. The show also spends time with Pedro Hernandez's case, Manny Gomez's campaign, Detective David Terrell's account, and the complaint records and police reports that complicate both sides. These are not brisk case summaries. They are built from tape, hesitation, contradiction, and the moments when someone's memory meets an institution's paperwork. A mother laughs while describing terror. A social worker ignores a warning she later regrets. A prison recording cuts out just when a claim becomes most important. Conviction pays attention to those gaps. It is especially strong at showing how criminal justice stories depend on who gets believed first, who has documentation, and who has to keep returning to court to resist a version of events. The tone stays grave without becoming theatrical. It gives space to grief, anger, uncertainty, and doubt. The result is true crime for listeners more interested in systems, testimony, and consequence than in a clean reveal.

Made for: For listeners drawn to investigative true crime, criminal justice reporting, and stories where interviews and documents complicate the official account. It suits patient listeners who can sit with ambiguity, trauma, and unresolved moral pressure.

What sets it apart: Conviction leans on raw tape and careful reconstruction instead of quick twists. Its anthology structure lets each season follow a different case while returning to the same central pressure: how power, memory, and paperwork shape justice.

In their own words

Max B is a Harlem rapper on the brink of stardom. One night he gets wind of a bag full of cash that’s sitting in an empty hotel room, and he starts scheming. It would be an easy score – in and out, no one gets hurt. But it doesn’t go down like that. It all ends in chaos, kidnapping and a dead body. This is the story of a rapper who risked it all for a bag full of money, a robbery where everything went wrong, a messy trial, and a sentence that makes you question who the justice system works for... and who it works against. Conviction is a podcast anthology series about crime and justice. Each story examines a new case and asks: Who does the justice system work for, and who does it work agains…

As heard by us

Based on 5 episodes we listened to · September 2026

Conviction tests accusations against records, recordings, and competing testimony, making uncertainty central to its season-based crime reporting.

Conviction follows criminal cases long enough for the official version and the lived one to rub against each other. In the Pedro Hernandez season, the reporting compares Manny Gomez's claims about Detective David Terrell with complaint records, an oversight official's…

Read our full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A police report says one thing; Conviction makes you sit with the person saying otherwise.

Press play if you want

  • competing accounts checked against complaint records, official reports, and imperfect recordings
  • an investigator's big theory questioned as carefully as the official story
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
criminal justice investigationspolice misconduct complaintshotel-room robbery casefamily trauma and allegationscourt pressure and plea bargainingwitness memory and testimonyinterrogation and interview tapedisputed official reports

Talks about

Best episodes of Conviction (Season Series)

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

Episode 2: Bring the MoneyFeb 28, 2023

A slow-burn crime story that turns one night of loose talk into hard consequences.

Episode 2 of The Conviction of Max B keeps tightening the screws on what begins as loose talk about a burglary plan. It moves from a basketball-court conversation to detective questioning without losing the thread, and the strongest stretches are the ones that make the details…

Introducing Crime ShowMay 18, 2021

A slow-burn true-crime setup where hope, doubt, and warning signs keep colliding.

Crime Show opens with a Sacramento school call that turns a classroom incident into a wider story about fear, care, and what adults can miss. Emma Cortland's calm narration keeps Judy Moise at the center as she describes the slide from a typical suburban life into worry over…

Episode 1: Meet the Quinneys (Season 2)Feb 25, 2020

A careful family-crime story that lets small domestic details carry the dread.

This special preview opens with John Quinney remembering a childhood ride in San Antonio in the 1980s, then moves into a marriage falling apart and a sudden accusation that changes the story's terms.

Right Past the Sun | S1 Ep6Feb 4, 2019

A prison interview becomes a test of memory, coercion, and what the tape cannot settle.

Right Past the Sun tracks Manny, John, and the narrator through a prison interview that leaves coercion, false accusations, and William Stevens hanging in the air.

No Wins | S1 Ep4Feb 4, 2019

A careful police-accountability story that lets complaint records and testimony collide.

The chapter shifts the argument from Manny's version of events to the complaints and records surrounding Detective David Terrell. Richard Emery's account of Terrell's complaint history gives the story some real weight, and those complaints are treated as evidence rather than…

Podcasts like Conviction (Season Series)

  • ChameleonAudiochuck | Campside Media

    True stories of scams, aliases, frauds, and lives built on lies.

  • Atlanta MonsteriHeartPodcasts and Tenderfoot TV

    Payne Lindsey and Tenderfoot TV revisit the Atlanta Child Murders and the wider Monster franchise.

  • DisgracelandDouble Elvis Productions

    Host Jake Brennan traces the crimes and scandals behind musicians from Elvis to Taylor Swift.

  • You Must Remember MansonKarina Longworth

    Karina Longworth narrates the Manson murders as a story about Hollywood's collapsing 1960s dream.

  • The Ballad of Billy BallsiHeartPodcasts

    iO Tillett Wright investigates her mother's boyfriend's unsolved 1982 East Village murder.

  • Wild BoysCampside Media / Sony Music Entertainment

    A wilderness hoax, a trusting BC town, and the brothers who fooled it.

Episodes

  1. 1

    Episode 2: Bring the Money

    A hotel room, a bag, and a gun.

    Feb 28, 2023·38m·3 clips
  2. 2

    Episode 1: Who’s 40 Grand Not Tempting To?

    Feb 21, 2023·40m
  3. 3

    Introducing Crime Show

    A school camera incident in Sacramento.

    May 18, 2021·38m·3 clips
  4. 4

    Preview: Believe The Children (Season 2)

    Mar 3, 2020·2m
  5. 5

    Episode 1: Meet the Quinneys (Season 2)

    The first episode of Conviction Season 2 introduces the Quinney family of San Antonio, Texas, whose lives unravelled after Melvin Quinney's wife Debbie left him the day after Thanksgiving 1989, claiming their daughter had been molested.

    Feb 25, 2020·25m·2 clips
  6. 6

    No Angels | S1 Ep7

    Feb 4, 2019·40m
  7. 7

    The Private Eye | S1 Ep1

    Feb 4, 2019·34m
  8. 8

    The Porsche | S1 Ep2

    Feb 4, 2019·39m
  9. 9

    No Wins | S1 Ep4

    Terrell's complaint file makes Manny's story harder to sort into hero and villain.

    Feb 4, 2019·38m·3 clips
  10. 10

    Right Past the Sun | S1 Ep6

    In episode 6 of Conviction, journalist Saki Knafo accompanies private investigator Manny Gomez and civil lawyer John Scola on a two-hour drive to Green Correctional Facility to interview witness William Stevens, who claims he was coerced by Detective David Terrell into falsely identifying Pedro Hernandez.

    Feb 4, 2019·34m·2 clips
  11. 11

    The Cop | S1 Ep3

    Feb 4, 2019·38m
  12. 12

    The Wrong Guy | S1 Ep5

    Feb 4, 2019·41m
  13. 13

    Conviction: Season 1 Trailer

    Jan 18, 2019·2m