A car full of clues, and an investigation that still leaves the family carrying the weight.
Paola Miranda Rosa Part 2 follows the discovery of her car in a park she knew well, with her phone, keys, cooler, and sand-filled sandals still inside.

Warm voices, cold cases, hard questions.
Coffee and Cases Podcast follows disappearance cases, suspicious deaths, and long-running mysteries with a warm but skeptical back-and-forth. Its strength is the careful return to small details: a parked car, a phone call, a search route, a piece of evidence that does not sit right.
PRESS PLAY
Coffee and Cases Podcast is built for listeners who want true crime explained carefully, not rushed past. The show focuses on missing people, cold cases, suspicious deaths, and strange circumstances that still leave families without a clear answer. Its episodes often begin with an ordinary moment. Someone goes to a park, stops at an ATM, walks across a parking lot, takes a phone call, or enters a quiet building before sunrise. Then the normal day breaks open. Allison Williams and Maggie Dameron guide the story through that break with a conversational style that keeps checking the logic as it goes. They linger on details that could sound small until the context changes them. Sandy sandals in a car matter. An unlocked vehicle blocking a trailhead matters. A payphone that may or may not have been tested matters. So does the difference between a family being told to wait and a family knowing something is wrong. The show is especially attentive to how early assumptions can shape an investigation, from Paola Miranda Rosa's car to the search for Megan. It gives space to frustration without turning the cases into spectacle. There is empathy here, but also a steady impatience with explanations that do not fit the evidence. The back-and-forth helps make complicated timelines easier to follow. One voice pushes the case forward while the other asks the question many listeners are already thinking. That makes the show approachable even when the subject matter is heavy. Episodes from the vault, including Angela Hammond, Laureen Rahn, and Sherry Lynn Marler, show the same interest in memory, family response, and the hard first hours after someone disappears. The Missy Bevers episode leans into the eerie power of surveillance footage and the unsettling calm of an unknown figure inside a church. Robert the Doll lets the show move into paranormal territory while still tracing real people, places, and relationships around the legend. Across the catalog, Coffee and Cases Podcast keeps returning to the same central idea: unresolved cases deserve attention because someone may still know the missing piece.
Made for: For true-crime listeners who prefer careful timelines, family-centered stakes, and conversational analysis over sensational pacing. It suits people drawn to missing-person cases, disputed evidence, and unresolved questions.
What sets it apart: The show stands out for repeatedly testing investigative assumptions in plain language, then tying each detail back to the people affected. Its duo rhythm makes complex cold cases feel clear without smoothing over the uncertainty.
Coffee and Cases is a true crime podcast where we like our coffee hot and our cases cold. Join us (Allison and Maggie) weekly to dive into the unknown and the unsolved.
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Allison Williams and Maggie Dameron pair clear case timelines with practical scrutiny of evidence, police decisions, and families' unresolved questions.
Coffee and Cases Podcast turns unresolved disappearances into careful, conversational case reconstruction. Allison Williams and Maggie Dameron move between narration and pointed exchanges, pausing over what families knew, when police acted, and which physical or digital traces…
Paola's family heard the car wasn't fingerprinted; your 'wait, what?' has company here.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A car full of clues, and an investigation that still leaves the family carrying the weight.
Paola Miranda Rosa Part 2 follows the discovery of her car in a park she knew well, with her phone, keys, cooler, and sand-filled sandals still inside.
A disappearance built from routine, bank records, and the pressure of the first 48 hours.
Paola Miranda Rosa anchors the story in ordinary moments that turn unsettling: a family member's house, a familiar morning, and an ATM stop at about 5:55 a.m.
A small-town disappearance anchored by reported details, a parked car, and a sketch.
The episode gives the case a quiet ache by centering a small-town couple whose future once seemed settled before one of them disappeared. It keeps its footing in reported facts: Rob's account, the drive to the police station, the vehicle left behind, the destroyed transmission,…
A Key West doll story that lets house history, museum rules, and the letter ritual do the heavy lifting.
This episode presents Robert the Doll as a Key West story, but it also gives real attention to the Otto family history behind the setting. It follows Jean and Ann Parker Otto from New York to Key West after Minnie Otto fell ill, then notes how the house came to be known as the…
An unlocked car and late-found devices deepen the mystery around Megan Marone's disappearance.
Megan Marone's disappearance opens in a subdued, uneasy register: a quiet stay at the Red Lion Inn, then the discovery of her unlocked Subaru blocking a park entrance.
A southern Vermont disappearance story lingers when Paul Jepson's trail ends at a crossroads.
The Bennington Triangle comes through as a pocket of southern Vermont where disappearance stories seem to build their own weather. The episode is strongest when it stays with the practical details that will not settle, including a man who appears to vanish from a bus while his…
A missing-child case told through the first urgent hours of the search.
This episode stays with Sherry's disappearance and the first hours of the search, which gives the story a narrow, urgent frame. It is strongest when it moves with Raymond and Betty as they realize Sherry is missing, then widens to Greenville police and a community that answers…




Evidence first, rumors on trial.


Allison and Maggie of Coffee and Cases explore the 1984 disappearance of 12-year-old Sherry Lynn Marler in Greenville, Alabama.
Allison and Maggie explore the Bennington Triangle, a 1,200-square-mile area in Vermont infamous for unexplained disappearances from 1945 to 1950.
In this update, the hosts continue the story of Little Miss Panasoffkee's identification as Maureen Miner Rowan and her daughter Anne's struggle with her father's attempts to re-enter her life.
This episode recounts the mysterious disappearance of Amy Lynn Bradley from a cruise ship in 1998, exploring the dark side of vacation and the ocean's secrets.
A solo episode of Coffee and Cases during social distancing, sharing a personal story about the host's grandmother and the historical Battle of Somosierra.
This episode recounts the mysterious disappearance of Amy Lynn Bradley from a cruise ship in 1998.
A podcast episode introducing the cold case of an unidentified man known as One-Eyed Jack, found dead on an Alaskan highway nearly 50 years ago.
Coffee and Cases' Paola Miranda Rosa Part 2 follows the 48-hour search after her car was found at Wekiva Springs with her phone, keys, cooler, and sand-filled sandals.
Coffee and Cases follows Paola Miranda Rosa, a 31-year-old Osceola County paralegal who was last seen after lunch with her grandmother on December 17, 2021.
["Angela Hammond, a 20-year-old Clinton, Missouri bank worker and Central Missouri State University student, vanished on April 4, 1991 while four months pregnant.", "From a Food Barn payphone at Jefferson and 2nd Street, she described a dirty man in overalls and a green Ford F-150 with a fish mural on the back window.", "Rob Schaefer heard her scream, chased the truck until his transmission failed, and later police used her account to sketch a suspect who did not match it well.", "The episode then tests ex-boyfriend rumors, Kenneth McDuff and Larry Dwayne Hall theories, and a 30th-anniversary mistaken-identity letter linked to another Angie in Clinton."]
This episode recounts the mysterious murder of Missy Bevers at a church in Midlothian, Texas, where a person dressed in police tactical gear was captured on security cameras before her arrival.
A mother receives mysterious early morning phone calls that she hopes are from her missing daughter, Laureen Rahn.
Coffee and Cases Podcast explores Robert the Doll, a three-foot-tall stuffed doll made by Germany's Steiff company around 1904 and owned by Key West artist Robert Eugene 'Gene' Otto, who gave the doll his own first name and carried it everywhere from childhood into adulthood.
Coffee and Cases revisits the 2022 disappearance and death of Megan Marohn, a 42-year-old English teacher from Del Mar, New York, who vanished at Janet Long Coat Park in Lee, Massachusetts on March 27, 2022.