Causing a Scene with Sara and Natalie

150 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

Pop culture with the group chat still open.

The gist

Causing a Scene with Sara and Natalie is a loose, fast-moving pop-culture hangout built around what is on screens and in the group chat. Reality TV, Taylor Swift, sports weekends, family travel, and emotional check-ins all share the same messy conversational lane.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About Causing a Scene with Sara and Natalie

Causing a Scene with Sara and Natalie sounds like a pop-culture group chat that hit record before anyone had time to organize the agenda. The show is built around television, celebrity stories, reality franchises, sports moments, and the daily life that surrounds watching all of it. Its best episodes move fast. A discussion can begin with cold Florida weather, a Dallas family visit, a delayed trip to Cabo, or a Paris breakthrough, then swing into The Traitors, RHOSLC, Mormon Wives, The Bachelorette, American Idol, or Taylor Swift. The rhythm is reactive and personal. The voices are not trying to be detached critics; they are watching, worrying, laughing, second-guessing, and texting through the same cultural moments their listeners are following. Reality TV gets special attention, especially when a show feels ethically messy or emotionally uncomfortable. Mormon Wives and The Bachelorette spark concern about producers, casting choices, probation, public pressure, and what happens when people who look depleted are still kept on screen. That seriousness sits beside lighter, very specific tangents. There are riffs on Indiana Hoosiers joy, a father cussing at refs, Super Bowl disappointment, Wayne Gretzky visual comparisons, Abercrombie orders, new glasses, hair humidity, and the strange drama of heater smell. The show also makes space for more vulnerable material. Episodes touch on mental health, therapy, homesickness, parenting young kids, being away from family, and the effort to say no when a recording day does not feel right. It can be blunt. It can be scattered. That is the texture. Causing a Scene is strongest when it turns television into a social-emotional event, where a recap is never only a recap and a celebrity headline can sit right next to a life update. It suits listeners who prefer messy immediacy over polished criticism.

Made for: For listeners who follow reality TV, Taylor Swift, sports-adjacent chatter, and celebrity conversation through a personal lens. It especially fits people who like recaps mixed with friendship dynamics, family updates, and unfiltered reaction.

What sets it apart: The show treats television and pop culture as part of everyday emotional life, not as a separate beat. Its appeal comes from the quick pivots between screen criticism, personal vulnerability, and highly specific tangents.

In their own words

Lights, Camera, Action! Join Causing a Scene every week to talk all things on-screen. Sara Gretzky & Natalie Buck are here to educate you on what you should be watching, and maybe not watching!

As heard by us

Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026

Sara Gretzky and Natalie Buck catch the moments when sports fandom spills into television, memory, personal allegiance, and friendly argument.

Causing a Scene with Sara and Natalie turns sports into part of an unruly conversation between Sara Gretzky and Natalie Buck, where television reactions and personal updates can suddenly give way to hockey casting or full-throated Indiana Hoosiers enthusiasm.

Read our full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A Wayne Gretzky perm theory is your cue to bring your TV opinions to the group chat.

Press play if you want

  • Sara and Natalie's Dancing with the Stars excitement, down to their fondness for corny game-show energy
  • Taylor Swift tour-documentary talk with a Paris debrief that feels like a friend's voice note
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
reality TV reactionsTaylor Swift coverageThe Traitors and RHOSLCMormon Wives and The Bachelorettesports weekends and Indiana Hoosiersfamily, travel, and home updatesfriendship check-inscelebrity casting and screen drama

Talks about

Podcasts like Causing a Scene with Sara and Natalie

  • Modern LoveThe New York Times

    Love, as it turns up in phone calls and closets.

  • The Popcast with Knox and JamieKnox McCoy and Jamie Golden

    Pop culture trivia, argued fast and with affection.

  • Still BufferingSydnee McElroy, Rileigh Smirl and Teylor Smirl

    Pop culture, personal stakes, and room for a tangent.

  • Projeto HumanosIvan Mizanzuk

    A Brazilian journalist spends years reinvestigating unsolved child disappearances in Paraná.

  • MamilosB9

    Cris Bartz and Juva Lauer alternate debate and interview episodes on Brazilian social issues.

  • The Wright ShowBloggingheads.tv

    Big political questions, examined through their practical details.

Episodes

  1. 1

    Sara's Hospital Chronicles

    ·55m
  2. 2

    Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, Cancellation of Bachelorette, TFP VS. Dakota

    ·32m
  3. 3

    Great Television, Horrible Husband

    ·55m
  4. 4

    USA vs. CA + Savannah Guthrie vs. FBI + Natalie vs. Umbilical Cords

    ·56m
  5. 5

    The Wedding Week is Here!!

    ·59m
  6. 6

    Olympic Prep, Elizabeth Smart + Traitors Recap

    ·38m
  7. 7

    Beckhams, Taylors Texts & American Idol

    ·58m
  8. 8

    Traitors, RHOSLC Reunion, and the Hoosiers

    ·1h
  9. 9

    The Year of the Horse

    ·43m
  10. 10

    Eras Tour Documentary, Paris, and Our Favorite 2025 Memories!

    ·52m
  11. 11

    Diddy, Rachel Zoe, and Rhode Island?

    ·1h 6m
  12. 12

    From Thanksgiving to Madame Morrible and Whitney Leavitt: A Holiday Catch-Up

    ·42m
  13. 13

    SAXON NOOOOO!

    ·58m
  14. 14

    The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, Task, and Whitney Leavitt’s Exit

    ·52m
  15. 15

    Dissecting the Default Parent

    ·46m
  16. 16

    RHOSLC, Busy Holiday Schedules, and DWTS!

    ·52m
  17. 17

    Stephanie Koenig Causes a Scene!!!

    ·40m
  18. 18

    Causing a Scene with Tay Lautner

    ·45m
  19. 19

    CANCELLED!

    ·1h 2m
  20. 20

    Mayci Neeley Causes a Scene!!

    ·49m
  21. 21

    WWHL Recap and Soul on Fire!

    ·37m
  22. 22

    Aka Charlie Sheen and WWHL!!

    ·34m
  23. 23

    Dancing with the Stars, London, and Peaches!!

    ·45m
  24. 24

    Taylor Frankie Paul, DWTS, and The High School Catfish

    ·51m
  25. 25

    Taylor's Engagement, The Dallas Cowboys, and Elizabeth Banks

    ·43m
  26. 26

    Hormones, Amanda Knox and the Dutchie!!

    ·36m
  27. 27

    Freakier Friday and Amanda Knox

    ·50m
  28. 28

    The Life of a Showgirl!!!!!!!

    ·1h 5m
  29. 29

    Tim Riggins and a Chevy Truck

    ·1h 1m
  30. 30

    Saint Louis, Lena Dunham, and Amy Bradley

    ·39m
  31. 31

    The Worst Episode Ever

    ·44m
  32. 32

    Homesick for Texas

    ·55m
  33. 33

    Causing a Scene with Hayden Cohen

    ·39m
  34. 34

    Summer Scaries and Call Her Alex

    ·42m
  35. 35

    Karen Read, Love Island, and The Cup

    ·41m
  36. 36

    Daddy Lundqvist, Sirens, and AJLT

    ·50m
  37. 37

    The Bride Tells All

    ·1h 11m
  38. 38

    Wedding Prepping and Water Fasting

    ·1h 3m
  39. 39

    How to be Selfish in 2025

    ·1h 6m
  40. 40

    This One's for the Girls with Martina McBride!

    ·56m
  41. 41

    JonBenet Ramsey and Luigi Mangione

    ·52m
  42. 42

    Thanksgiving and Wedding Scaries

    ·54m
  43. 43

    WHY IS RHONY SO BAD?!

    ·53m
  44. 44

    Martha Stewart Season!!

    ·53m
  45. 45

    Bravo, Zach Bryan's Breakup, and STMS Season

    ·38m
  46. 46

    Bridezilla Meets the Menendez Brothers

    ·1h 6m
  47. 47

    Causing a Scene with Caroline Manzo

    ·36m
  48. 48

    Nobody Wants This, Hollywood Friend Groups and Diddy

    ·57m
  49. 49

    Causing a Scene in Park City

    ·53m
  50. 50

    Rerun: Jackie Oshry Causes A Scene!

    ·49m
  51. 51

    The Perfect Couple, Tampons, and One Tree Hill

    ·50m
  52. 52

    Sicily at School, Fantasy Football, and Chimp Crazy

    ·49m
  53. 53

    "He Went Away to Camp"

    ·53m
  54. 54

    It Ends with Us Review and Taylor at Wembley

    ·47m
  55. 55

    It Ends with Us, RHONJ finale,Carrie Underwood, and House of the Dragon

    ·51m
  56. 56

    Jason Kennedy Causes a Scene!!

    ·51m
  57. 57

    TITS OUT FOR PARIS!!

    ·46m
  58. 58

    Jana Kramer Causes a Scene

    ·40m
  59. 59

    What is Happening in the World?!

    ·47m
  60. 60

    Love Island with Francesca Mariano

    ·57m
  61. 61

    The Dallas Cowboys gals, Travis at Wembley, RHONJ

    ·49m
  62. 62

    House of the Dragon, Summerhouse, and Jake Gyllenhaal

    ·49m
  63. 63

    The Washcloth Gate

    ·48m
  64. 64

    Natalie's Solo Episode!

    ·33m
  65. 65

    The Pop Apologists Cause a Scene!!

    ·49m
  66. 66

    Live from the Studio!!

    ·56m
  67. 67

    Disney Adults, Anne Hathaway, and Challengers

    ·54m
  68. 68

    Kate Casey Causes A Scene

    ·59m
  69. 69

    Sicily and The Tourtured Poet Have Arrived

    ·59m
  70. 70

    Delta Airlines, Coachella, and Tortured Poets

    ·50m
  71. 71

    Causing A Scene about Vanderpump with Taylor Strecker

    ·56m
  72. 72

    Mercury is Retrograding in Palm Royale

    ·37m
  73. 73

    Apples Never Fall

    ·59m
  74. 74

    "Not About Kate"

    ·54m
  75. 75

    "Where is Kate " with Royal Expert Kristen Meinzer

    ·56m
  76. 76

    Getting The ICK, Kate Middleton, and Dune 2

    ·56m
  77. 77

    This One's For The Brides!

    ·1h 20m
  78. 78

    Love is Blind!!

    ·1h 1m
  79. 79

    VIVA LAS VEGAS, Galentines, and Traitorrr Joes

    ·53m
  80. 80

    Housewives and Mob Wives with Jamie-Lynn Sigler

    ·1h
  81. 81

    American Nightmare, Lessons In Chemistry, and Football

    ·1h 9m
  82. 82

    The Emmys, Saltburn, and Drops of God

    ·1h 1m
  83. 83

    Causing A Scene about Jo Koy, Monica, and Lord Stanley

    ·55m
  84. 84

    Vision Boarding Into 2024

    ·41m
  85. 85

    GOODBYE 2023!!

    ·44m
  86. 86

    WICKED REVIEW!!

    The host discusses her upcoming wedding, including a courthouse legal marriage and a Cabo ceremony, while reviewing the musical WICKED.

    ·59m
  87. 87

    Q&A with Nattie B.

    ·44m
  88. 88

    Natalie's Honeymoon Recap

    ·49m
  89. 89

    Chicks Causing a Scene with Fran Mariano

    ·52m
  90. 90

    My Pipes, My Choice

    ·47m
  91. 91

    "WHEN ARE YOU HAVING KIDS?!"

    ·40m
  92. 92

    Crying with your Kids

    ·48m
  93. 93

    Going to Space, Aimee Lou Wood, and Rebranding Summer House

    ·44m
  94. 94

    Your Friends and Neighbors!!

    ·47m
  95. 95

    A Body in The Snow: The Trial of Karen Read

    ·1h 11m
  96. 96

    Growing Through Grief with Jack Ciapciak

    ·51m
  97. 97

    The Oscars, Running Point, and Q&A

    ·1h 2m
  98. 98

    Is swearing on your Grandchildren OK?

    ·54m
  99. 99

    White Lotus and Jonathan Mark!!

    ·1h 22m
  100. 100

    Fixing Famous People

    ·1h 10m
  101. 101

    Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, Cancellation of Bachelorette, TFP VS. Dakota

    Hidden gem

    The host explains the reason for a brief podcast hiatus and addresses listener confusion about their departure.

    Mar 24, 2026·32m·2 clips
  102. 102

    Great Television, Horrible Husband

    Hidden gem

    Causing a Scene with Sara and Natalie explains that the podcast will continue as an occasional hobby while Sara and Natalie pursue expanding professional commitments.

    Feb 25, 2026·55m·3 clips
  103. 103

    USA vs. CA + Savannah Guthrie vs. FBI + Natalie vs. Umbilical Cords

    The hosts catch up on personal topics and discuss the Super Bowl, while teasing stories about USA vs Canada, Savannah Guthrie vs FBI, and Natalie vs umbilical cords.

    Feb 11, 2026·56m
  104. 104

    Olympic Prep, Elizabeth Smart + Traitors Recap

    The hosts discuss their travel plans to Dallas, family updates, and tease upcoming topics including Olympic prep, Elizabeth Smart, and a Traitors recap.

    Feb 6, 2026·38m
  105. 105

    Beckhams, Taylors Texts & American Idol

    Natalie and Sarah discuss Natalie's experience attending the Indiana Hoosiers' national championship football game with her dad.

    Jan 28, 2026·58m
  106. 106

    Traitors, RHOSLC Reunion, and the Hoosiers

    Hidden gem

    Sara and Natalie open with Nikki Glaser at the Golden Globes, praising her "power stance," Sean Penn jokes, and the kind of outfit changes they think work better for female hosts.

    Jan 15, 2026·1h·2 clips
  107. 107

    The Year of the Horse

    Hidden gem

    Sarah Gretzky explains how her heart rate hit nearly 200 in AFib and a prayer dropped it to 90.

    Jan 8, 2026·43m·2 clips
  108. 108

    Eras Tour Documentary, Paris, and Our Favorite 2025 Memories!

    Sarah says Paris forced her to be "alone with myself" in a hotel room, and that feeling turned into a confidence boost after years of mom routines.

    Dec 18, 2025·52m·2 clips
  109. 109

    Diddy, Rachel Zoe, and Rhode Island?

    Hidden gem

    Sarah Gretzky opens by sharing a text that said she was “so full of hate right now,” and Nathalie answers that she was really “full of emotions that are valid.” The two connect that exchange to intrusive thoughts, OCD-style rumination, and the nightly habit of replaying conversations before bed.

    Dec 11, 2025·1h 6m·2 clips
  110. 110

    From Thanksgiving to Madame Morrible and Whitney Leavitt: A Holiday Catch-Up

    Dec 4, 2025·42m
  111. 111

    The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, Task, and Whitney Leavitt’s Exit

    Nov 20, 2025·52m
  112. 112

    Dissecting the Default Parent

    Nov 13, 2025·46m
  113. 113

    RHOSLC, Busy Holiday Schedules, and DWTS!

    Nov 6, 2025·52m
  114. 114

    Stephanie Koenig Causes a Scene!!!

    Oct 30, 2025·40m
  115. 115

    Causing a Scene with Tay Lautner

    Oct 23, 2025·45m
  116. 116

    CANCELLED!

    Oct 16, 2025·1h 2m
  117. 117

    Mayci Neeley Causes a Scene!!

    Oct 9, 2025·49m
  118. 118

    WWHL Recap and Soul on Fire!

    Oct 2, 2025·37m
  119. 119

    Aka Charlie Sheen and WWHL!!

    Sep 25, 2025·34m
  120. 120

    Dancing with the Stars, London, and Peaches!!

    Hidden gem

    Sarah returns from London with Peaches, a puppy named Peaches Sunflower Gretzky, and says the dog was the answer to "either a baby or a dog people." Natalie and Sarah connect the decision to V's fear of dogs, the family's rescue-breeder search, and Sarah's comment that the puppy makes the house feel "revived." The conversation then shifts to London, where Sarah talks about the Cotswolds, Hyde Park, Soho Farmhouse, and a lunch spot built in 847 AD.

    Sep 19, 2025·45m·2 clips
  121. 121

    Taylor Frankie Paul, DWTS, and The High School Catfish

    Sep 11, 2025·51m
  122. 122

    Taylor's Engagement, The Dallas Cowboys, and Elizabeth Banks

    Sep 4, 2025·43m
  123. 123

    Hormones, Amanda Knox and the Dutchie!!

    Aug 28, 2025·36m
  124. 124

    Freakier Friday and Amanda Knox

    Aug 21, 2025·50m
  125. 125

    The Life of a Showgirl!!!!!!!

    Aug 14, 2025·1h 5m
  126. 126

    Tim Riggins and a Chevy Truck

    Aug 7, 2025·1h 1m
  127. 127

    Saint Louis, Lena Dunham, and Amy Bradley

    Jul 24, 2025·39m
  128. 128

    The Worst Episode Ever

    Jul 17, 2025·44m
  129. 129

    Homesick for Texas

    Jul 10, 2025·55m
  130. 130

    Causing a Scene with Hayden Cohen

    Jul 3, 2025·39m
  131. 131

    Summer Scaries and Call Her Alex

    Jun 26, 2025·42m
  132. 132

    Karen Read, Love Island, and The Cup

    Jun 19, 2025·41m
  133. 133

    Daddy Lundqvist, Sirens, and AJLT

    Jun 12, 2025·50m
  134. 134

    Sara's Hospital Chronicles

    Jun 5, 2025·55m
  135. 135

    Q&A with Nattie B.

    Natalie hosts her first solo Q&A episode, explaining co-host Sarah's absence due to hospitalization and answering listener questions.

    May 29, 2025·44m
  136. 136

    Natalie's Honeymoon Recap

    May 22, 2025·49m
  137. 137

    Chicks Causing a Scene with Fran Mariano

    Fran Mariano discusses her decision not to change her last name after marriage and the identity crisis that can come with name changes.

    May 15, 2025·52m
  138. 138

    My Pipes, My Choice

    May 8, 2025·47m
  139. 139

    "WHEN ARE YOU HAVING KIDS?!"

    May 1, 2025·40m
  140. 140

    Crying with your Kids

    A host shares a personal story about the emotional crash after family visits and the struggle of balancing family attachment with marriage.

    Apr 24, 2025·48m
  141. 141

    Going to Space, Aimee Lou Wood, and Rebranding Summer House

    Apr 17, 2025·44m
  142. 142

    Your Friends and Neighbors!!

    Apr 10, 2025·47m
  143. 143

    A Body in The Snow: The Trial of Karen Read

    Apr 3, 2025·1h 11m
  144. 144

    SAXON NOOOOO!

    Mar 27, 2025·58m
  145. 145

    Growing Through Grief with Jack Ciapciak

    Jack Ciapciak discusses his experience with grief and healing on the Causing a Scene podcast.

    Mar 13, 2025·51m
  146. 146

    The Oscars, Running Point, and Q&A

    Mar 6, 2025·1h 2m
  147. 147

    Is swearing on your Grandchildren OK?

    Feb 27, 2025·54m
  148. 148

    White Lotus and Jonathan Mark!!

    Feb 20, 2025·1h 22m
  149. 149

    Fixing Famous People

    Feb 13, 2025·1h 10m
  150. 150

    The Bride Tells All

    Feb 6, 2025·1h 11m