Butler's Insurance Litigation Podcast

37 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

Insurance litigation craft, from appellate rules to fire scenes

The gist

This Butler law firm feed carries several series at once, from Carol Rooney's All About Appellate webinars on Florida and Texas procedure to Aaron Jacobs's Subro Sense, where guests including forensic engineers explain how losses get traced. The material stays technical and procedural, built on rules, case law and claim-file decisions.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About Butler's Insurance Litigation Podcast

Butler's Insurance Litigation Podcast works as one feed for several of the Butler law firm's audio series, and those series sound noticeably different from one another. What ties them together is subject matter: insurance claims, the litigation that follows them, and the procedural rules that shape the outcome. All About Appellate is the most formal strand. These are recorded webinars presented by Carol Rooney, a partner and board-certified appellate attorney, complete with slides carrying code words that Florida adjusters record for continuing-education credit. Her titles keep returning to two jurisdictions, as in 'Appellate Standards of Review Under Florida and Texas Law' and 'All About Appellate | Federal Appeals in Florida and Texas', alongside coverage and declaratory judgment appeals and annual case law updates. The summary judgment session shows how fine the grain gets. Rooney works through Florida's revised rule, the requirement to serve a response at least 20 days before the hearing, and the need for an affidavit or declaration when a party says it cannot yet present essential facts. She treats hearsay-based affidavits as grounds for an objection and, on the Texas side, discusses the presumption that a corporate employee has personal knowledge of facts learned on the job. Some advice is immediately usable, such as submitting a detailed proposed order to the trial court. Subro Sense, hosted by Aaron Jacobs of Butler's subrogation and recovery team, runs on conversation instead. Jacobs opens 'Subro Sense Podcast S03E02 | Hey Google! Where did the fire start?' with a childhood memory of Disney's Carousel of Progress before turning to smart-home data. That episode, with guests Bob House and Nick Mahoney of SEA, Ltd., includes an account of a basic home-style camera that captured the earliest stage of a fire in one particular car. Jacobs also floats using thermostat humidity readings to estimate how long a leak ran in a seldom-occupied second home. 'Subro Sense Season 3 | Subrogation at Sea' pairs him with Craig Sylvester of Jensen Hughes, a mechanical engineer who was a Navy salvage diver, on vessel fires, hull materials and joint evidence inspections. Jacobs adds a pointed caution about marina contracts, which can carry exculpatory clauses and explicit subrogation waivers. Other titles stretch the range to releases, deductible coordination, mediation, the made whole rule and the gap between RCV and ACV. A third format appears in 'Batten Down The Hatches: Issues to Consider With Florida's 2022 Storm Season Upon Us', where Tampa attorneys Thomas Wiley Hodges and David Maldoff trade questions about windstorm roof claims. They cover hurricane versus windstorm deductibles, Florida's 25% re-roofing rule, matching arguments and homeowners association letters pressing for uniform roofs. The register throughout is instructional and plainspoken, with cases cited by name and rule language read closely, and the Subro Sense vessel episode ends with a disclaimer that none of it is legal advice. For a first listen, the storm season conversation is the easiest way in; the appellate webinars reward a listener prepared to follow rule text line by line.

Made for: Suits a listener who handles insurance claims or litigation and wants procedure-level detail on Florida and Texas appellate practice, subrogation recovery and property loss investigation, delivered as practical guidance rather than news.

What sets it apart: Instead of one format, the feed combines lecture-style appellate webinars that keep their continuing-education mechanics, lawyer-and-engineer subrogation conversations about evidence such as smart-home data and vessel fire scenes, and attorney exchanges on Florida storm claims. Its steady pairing of Florida and Texas law gives the appellate material a specific jurisdictional focus.

In their own words

Butler is a civil litigation firm. We are unique because our practice is devoted entirely to defense and insurance litigation. At Butler, our goal is to stay on top of the latest alerts, trends and news so that we can provide you with the most up to date information possible. Stay tuned in for more Butler Podcasts coming soon.

Why you'd press play

Deposition objections have a clock, and Carol Rooney wants you watching it.

Press play if you want

  • to catch a Florida or Texas preservation issue before it follows you into an appeal
  • to weigh the odds and precedent risks before deciding an appeal is worth pursuing
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Florida and Texas appellate proceduresummary judgment and affidavit evidencesubrogation and recovery strategyforensic fire investigationmarine and vessel lossesFlorida windstorm and roof claimsinsurance coverage and case law updates

Talks about

Best episodes of Butler's Insurance Litigation Podcast

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

All About Appellate - Summary Judgment Standard and Appellate Review Under Florida and Texas LawJul 20, 2022

A focused summary-judgment review on keeping affidavits admissible, concise, and anchored to material facts.

Carol Rooney's webinar treats summary judgment as a matter of evidentiary discipline, with Florida and Texas practice as the frame. The focus stays close to affidavits: personal knowledge, admissible evidence, hearsay, and the need to keep material facts at the center when…

Batten Down The Hatches: Issues to Consider With Florida's 2022 Storm Season Upon UsJun 27, 2022

A clear, practical look at policy language, repair thresholds, and evidence in Florida windstorm roof claims.

Florida windstorm roof claims are framed here as a practical mix of policy wording, repair calculations, and evidence. Thomas Wiley Hodges and David Maldoff start with the basic coverage question, including how windstorm, hail, and hurricane deductibles can differ, before…

Subro Sense Podcast S03E02 | Hey Google! Where did the fire start?May 6, 2021

Smart-home and industrial data become evidence when investigators need to locate a fire's origin.

A fire investigation turns into a sharp look at the digital evidence left behind by connected systems. Aaron Jacobs, identified as a partner with Butler's subrogation and recovery team, leads the discussion through PLC controllers, offline industrial data, cloud-stored alarm…

Subro Sense Season 3 | Subrogation at SeaMar 9, 2021

A steady, practical look at vessel-loss investigations, from underwater inspection to chain of custody.

Subro Sense moves subrogation onto the water, where a vessel loss can involve a land-based repair facility, a wet slip, or a boat already underway.

All About Appellate - Annual Case Law Update: Florida and TexasDec 28, 2020

A practical 2020 case-law briefing for insurance professionals tracking Florida and Texas rulings.

Carol Rooney's 2020 case-law update frames Florida and Texas insurance rulings as a practical guide to appellate pressure points. The episode moves across post-loss compliance, confession of judgment, bad faith, sanctions, attorney's fees, proposals for settlement, and the duty…

Podcasts like Butler's Insurance Litigation Podcast

Episodes

  1. 1

    All About Appellate - Summary Judgment Standard and Appellate Review Under Florida and Texas Law

    Carol Rooney’s Butler’s Appellate Podcast webinar explains summary-judgment standards and appellate review under Florida and Texas law.

    Jul 20, 2022·55m·3 clips
  2. 2

    Batten Down The Hatches: Issues to Consider With Florida's 2022 Storm Season Upon Us

    Hidden gem

    Thomas Wiley Hodges and David Maldoff use Butler's Insurance Litigation Podcast to break down Florida windstorm roof claims, with deductible language, replacement cost, and ordinance-or-law coverage as the first questions.

    Jun 27, 2022·31m·3 clips
  3. 3

    Subro Sense Podcast S03E02 | Hey Google! Where did the fire start?

    Hidden gem

    ["Butler's Subro Sense episode Hey Google!

    May 6, 2021·34m·3 clips
  4. 4

    Subro Sense Season 3 | Subrogation at Sea

    Aaron Jacobs and Craig Sylvester examine vessel subrogation claims, from fuel-vapor explosions and shore-power failures to collisions, marina damage, and submerged evidence.

    Mar 9, 2021·43m·2 clips
  5. 5

    All About Appellate - Annual Case Law Update: Florida and Texas

    Carol Rooney's Butler's Appellate Podcast reviews more than 30 significant Florida and Texas insurance-law cases from 2020.

    Dec 28, 2020·51m·4 clips
  6. 6

    Subro Sense Season 2| Holiday Havoc "Fireplace & Chimney Fire Losses"

    Hidden gem

    Aaron Jacobs and Tom Burgess examine fireplace and chimney fire claims through Rick Anawalt’s J.S.

    Dec 22, 2020·22m·1 clip
  7. 7

    Subro Sense Season 2 | Holiday Havoc "Christmas Tree & Light Fires"

    Aaron Jacobs and Tom Burgess of Butler's subrogation and recovery team examine Christmas tree and Christmas light fires through insurance investigation and recovery.

    Dec 22, 2020·20m·1 clip
  8. 8

    Subro Sense Season 2 | Holiday Havoc Part 1

    Hidden gem

    Aaron Jacobs and Tom Burgess examine cooking-fire subrogation claims involving grease, turkey fryers, grills, stovetops, tenants, guests, and fire-suppression systems.

    Dec 16, 2020·21m·1 clip
  9. 9

    All About Appellate - 2020 Appellate Issues at Trial (Florida and Texas)

    Hidden gem

    Carol Rooney, a Butler partner and board-certified appellate attorney, presents the third webinar in the 2020 All About Appellate series on preserving trial issues under Florida and Texas law.

    Nov 20, 2020·52m·3 clips
  10. 10

    All About Appellate - APPELLATE WRITS, MOTION PRACTICE AND SANCTIONS UNDER FLORIDA AND TEXAS LAW

    Carol Rooney’s Butler’s Appellate Podcast webinar covers Florida and Texas appellate writs, motion practice, and sanctions for insurance practitioners.

    Sep 24, 2020·49m·3 clips
  11. 11

    Subro Sense - The ABC's of RCV and ACV

    Hidden gem

    Aaron Jacobs and Raymond Franks explain how replacement cost value, actual cash value, and depreciation affect insurance subrogation claims.

    Sep 3, 2020·32m
  12. 12

    SUBRO SENSE PODCAST - Forensic Investigation of Subrogation Claims During COVID-19

    Hidden gem

    Aaron Jacobs interviews Tripp Wagner of Jensen Hughes about how COVID-19 changed forensic investigations for insurance subrogation claims.

    May 5, 2020·29m·2 clips
  13. 13

    All About Appellate: Summary Judgement Standard and Appellate Review Under Florida and Texas Law

    Hidden gem

    Carol Rooney's Butler's Appellate Podcast webinar explains summary-judgment requirements and appellate review under Florida and Texas law, including Florida Rule 1.510 and Texas Rule 166a.

    Mar 23, 2020·50m·3 clips
  14. 14

    All About Appellate | Case Law Update 2019 - Significant Rulings, Trends and Caselaw (Florida and Texas)

    Carol Rooney, a board-certified appellate attorney and Butler partner, reviews significant 2019 insurance rulings from Florida and Texas for insurance professionals, practitioners, litigators, and adjusters.

    Dec 30, 2019·54m·3 clips
  15. 15

    Subro Sense Podcast | CONSIDERATIONS IN FIXED FUNDS/LIMITED POOL SCENARIOS

    Hidden gem

    Aaron Jacobs and Robert Meyer examine how liability carriers should handle multiple claims when policy limits cannot satisfy all claimants.

    Dec 6, 2019·27m·1 clip
  16. 16

    INSURANCE COVERAGE & DECLARATORY JUDGMENT APPELLATE ISSUES

    Hidden gem

    Carol Rooney, a Butler partner and board-certified appellate attorney, presents a 2019 webinar on insurance coverage and declaratory-judgment appeals under Florida and Texas law.

    Oct 16, 2019·55m·4 clips
  17. 17

    SUBRO SENSE PODCAST | Unpacking Product Claims Against Amazon

    Oct 7, 2019·17m
  18. 18

    SUBRO SENSE PODCAST | MADE WHOLE RULE: LESSONS LEARNED FROM THE 9/11 WORLD TRADE CENTER LITIGATION

    Hidden gem

    Aaron Jacobs, Scott Katz, and Jessica Skareen explain how the made-whole rule affected property insurers’ subrogation claims arising from Silverstein Properties’ World Trade Center litigation.

    Aug 12, 2019·26m·1 clip
  19. 19

    All About Appellate | Federal Appeals in Florida and Texas

    Hidden gem

    Carol Rooney, a Butler partner and board-certified appellate attorney, explains federal appeals in insurance cases arising in Florida and Texas.

    Jun 17, 2019·1h 4m·5 clips
  20. 20

    Subro Sense Podcast EPISODE 3 | UNIQUE FACTORS AND CONSIDERATIONS IN A SUBROGATION RELEASE

    Hidden gem

    Aaron Jacobs and Matt Freeman explain why a subrogation release can undermine a settlement after years of litigation and a 14-hour mediation.

    Jun 6, 2019·27m·2 clips
  21. 21

    All About Appellate | Interlocutory Appeals, Cross-Appeals and Appellate StaysÂ

    Hidden gem

    Carol Rooney, a board-certified appellate attorney and Butler partner, explains Florida procedures for challenging non-final orders before final judgment.

    Apr 10, 2019·36m·2 clips
  22. 22

    Subro Sense | Coordination of Insured's Interests and Deductible

    Hidden gem

    Aaron Jacobs hosts Ying Si of McLaren's and Lisa Weinstein of Southport Financial Services on coordinating insured interests across subrogation, liability defense, and claims handling.

    Apr 8, 2019·29m·2 clips
  23. 23

    Strategies & Techniques in Mediation

    Aaron Jacobs and Jerry Albrecht of Albrecht Mediation discuss subrogation mediations, emphasizing that controlling emotion is easier in property-damage cases than in personal-injury disputes.

    Feb 6, 2019·27m·1 clip
  24. 24

    Appellate Issues at Trial

    Hidden gem

    Carol Rooney, a board-certified appellate-practice specialist, explains how Florida and Texas lawyers preserve trial errors for appellate review.

    Sep 27, 2018·37m·2 clips
  25. 25

    Appellate Standards of Review Under Florida and Texas Law

    Hidden gem

    Carol Rooney, a board-certified appellate attorney and Butler partner, explains how Florida and Texas standards of review affect appeals, settlement leverage, and reversal prospects.

    Jun 19, 2018·40m·2 clips
  26. 26

    Litigating First-Party Property Bad Faith Lawsuits

    Hidden gem

    Butler's Insurance Litigation Podcast presents part two of a Florida webinar on litigating and defending first-party property bad-faith lawsuits.

    Apr 24, 2018·1h 3m·4 clips
  27. 27

    ATTORNEY'S FEES AND TAXABLE COST

    Hidden gem

    Carol Rooney, a board-certified appellate attorney and partner with Butler Y.

    Mar 28, 2018·1h·4 clips
  28. 28

    QUICK INVESTIGATING TIPS FOR FIRE SPRINKLER CLAIMS

    Hidden gem

    Butler's Insurance Litigation Podcast presents a practical guide to investigating fire sprinkler subrogation claims through system type, building age, property location, and weather history.

    Mar 22, 2018·54m·3 clips
  29. 29

    FIRST-PARTY PROPERTY BAD FAITH IN FLORIDA

    Hidden gem

    Matt Labisky of Butler, Weimuller, Katz, Craig explains Florida first-party property bad faith through Blanchard, Camerata, Barton, and related cases.

    Mar 20, 2018·1h·4 clips
  30. 30

    HANDLING ASSIGNMENT OF BENEFIT ("AOB") CLAIMS IN THE WAKE OF HURRICANES IRMA AND HARVEY

    Oct 9, 2017·13m
  31. 31

    HANDLING ASSIGNMENT OF BENEFIT ("AOB") CLAIMS IN THE WAKE OF HURRICANES IRMA AND HARVEY

    Oct 6, 2017·13m
  32. 32

    The Art of Advocacy- Persuasive Writing and Oral Arguments

    Oct 3, 2017·47m
  33. 33

    INSURERS, POLICYHOLDERS, AND DEFENSE LAWYERS: THE INS AND OUTS OF THE TRIPARTITE RELATIONSHIP

    Aug 22, 2017·52m
  34. 34

    Extraordinary Writs:  Certiorari, Prohibition, and Mandamus.Â

    Jun 23, 2017·29m
  35. 35

    Preserving Error For Appeal in Florida State Courts 2017

    A CLE webinar on preserving error for appeal in Florida state courts, part of a series for attorneys and adjusters.

    Apr 7, 2017·45m
  36. 36

    CORPORATE REPRESENTATIVE DEPOSITIONS

    Jan 3, 2017·4m
  37. 37

    HANDLING ASSIGNMENT OF BENEFIT ("AOB") CLAIMS

    Oct 17, 2016·23m