Blocked and Reported is hosted by journalists Katie Herzog and Jesse Singal, who release numbered panel episodes alongside shorter premium previews and occasional live shows recorded on Substack. Most episodes follow a two-person panel format: the hosts trade commentary on recent headlines and online arguments, usually starting with personal banter before settling into a longer debate segment. Recurring subject matter includes gender-identity politics and trans policy, including contentious cases involving prisons and school boards, along with media criticism aimed at outlets like the New York Times and The Atlantic. The show returns repeatedly to skepticism about psychiatric diagnosis and the medicalization of everyday distress, and to publishing-industry controversies such as accusations of undisclosed AI-generated text in books and journalism. Guests appear periodically for extended interview segments; examples in the sample include Atlantic writer Helen Lewis discussing UK politics and Tourette's syndrome media coverage, and Unshrunk author Laura Delano discussing psychiatric treatment history. A running thread of media-industry gossip around writer Lindy West's personal and publishing life recurs across multiple premium episodes. The hosts generally approach stories with a contrarian, skeptical stance toward what they describe as overreach in progressive framing of news events, and the two do not always agree with each other on air. Production is conversational and lightly edited rather than scripted, with a fast, sarcastic back-and-forth style. The show suits listeners already following online media and culture-war debates who want detailed, argument-driven discussion rather than summary news coverage.