Odd stories, loose research, refill energy.
Atypically Topical treats strange subjects as fuel for relaxed back-and-forth: scams, shame, dating customs, sports history, disability, holidays, and grim historical figures. The mood stays casual even when the material turns dark, with recurring quizzes, Florida stories, dog interruptions, and a closing refill ritual.
PRESS PLAY
Atypically Topical is built around the pleasure of taking a strange subject seriously enough to research it, but not so seriously that the room goes quiet. The show moves through odd crime stories, historical scandals, dating customs, holidays, sports history, disability, public shame, and other topics that invite both curiosity and disbelief. Recent episodes show how flexible the format can be. An Easter episode folds together online romance-scam weirdness, holiday trivia, and facts about animals that seem to come back from the dead. A basketball episode reverses the usual setup and turns into a story about Senda Berenson Abbott and the early history of women's basketball. A dating episode uses old courtship customs to set up jokes, confusion, and cultural side notes. A terrible-men installment reaches into King Leopold II and the Congo, treating the brutality plainly while still leaving space for the conversational reactions. The show is not a polished lecture series. It is closer to an after-hours research exchange, with Mindy and Josh talking from the couch, checking assumptions, misreading words, circling back, and letting the room stay audible. Dogs interrupt. Wine gets mentioned. Work updates and life catch-ups sit beside stories about scams, basketball, holidays, and historical cruelty. Recurring segments keep the chaos recognizable. Questioning Florida brings in strange Florida items, Quiz Corner turns facts into a game, and the age game asks for a guess before revealing who is behind a story. The closing rhythm is just as familiar: raise the glasses and go grab a refill. That looseness is the appeal. Atypically Topical does not flatten strange material into a serious-casefile tone, and it does not treat history like homework. The hosts react with confusion, sarcasm, discomfort, and curiosity, often stopping to define a word, argue about a detail, or laugh at a sideways association. Darker topics are part of the territory, including scams, exploitation, violence, death, colonial abuse, and sexual violence references. The show is best for listeners who want unusual true-crime-adjacent stories and historical oddities delivered through informal banter rather than tight narration. It feels personal, imperfect, and specific, with the recurring bits and household background giving even grim subjects the shape of a conversation among people who know each other's timing.
Made for: For listeners who like strange history, unusual crime, trivia, and conversational comedy with a darker edge. It fits people who prefer reactive banter and recurring bits over formal narration.
What sets it apart: The show pairs grim or bizarre research with a casual living-room rhythm: Quiz Corner, Questioning Florida, age guesses, dog interruptions, and a refill signoff. That mix makes heavy subjects feel less like case files and more like odd stories traded aloud.
It's the show where the topics are topical, but not typical. Join hosts Mindy and Josh each week as they discuss strange and interesting topics such as unusual crimes, stalkers, murder, and more!
A basketball history swap pauses at 'frail and sickly,' so your raised eyebrow has company.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A loose Easter-leaning catch-up where online fraud, Selena Day, and fox-delivered eggs all find room at the table.
Atypically Topical returns with a loose Easter-leaning catch-up that mixes Selena Day, resurrection talk, and an online fraud story without pretending to be more polished than it is.
A reverse-format basketball history lesson finds comedy in Senda Berenson Abbott's unlikely path into the sport.
Basketball reaches Atypically Topical by way of a reverse storytelling setup, with one host carrying the history while the other questions, reacts, and keeps the room loose.
Quiz Corner turns national pride and shame into a loose, personality-driven detour through history, jokes, and room noise.
The episode starts in celebratory mode, with wine and a host's move into a new school psychology role, before letting the conversation drift toward shame.
A couch-side dating chat turns a courtship quiz into a grimly comic detour.
Dating lands as a loose living-room hang, with the host and Mindy on the couch easing from weekend chatter into dating stories and a quiz about Nordic courtship customs.
A couch-side history lesson makes Leopold's rubber quotas hard to separate from the human cost.
This single-episode review frames a relaxed living-room recording against the brutality of King Leopold II's rubber demands in the Congo. The hosts trace how villages were forced into rising quotas, how people could walk for days as rubber supplies dwindled, and how punishment…
Grave questions, carefully organized.
Paranormal talk with room to wander.
Oz reimagined, then argued with afterward.
Crime memory with prison-wall detail.
Irish true crime, evidence first.
True crime with forensic bite and blunt banter.
Atypically Topical opens with Selena Day, an Alamo Drafthouse "Selena movie party," and a quiz that asks about Westphalia, Germany, Easter Island, Chile, and Pennsylvania.
Atypical Topical frames basketball through Senda Berenson Abbott, the Lithuanian-born founder often called the mother of women's basketball, and through players like James Naismith in Springfield.
Governor Morris helped change “we, the people of the States” to “we, the people of the United States.”
Atypical Topical episode 106, titled “Dating,” opens with the hosts on a couch before moving into courtship customs from Europe, the Nordics, and Wales.
Chief Lontulu laid out 110 twigs to show how many people died in his village under King Leopold II.
A recurring rib-crushing dream prompts recognition when the panel describes the Alp's chest-sitting attacks in German folklore.
Atypically Topical episode 103 connects an osteotome used in childbirth procedures to the modern chainsaw.
The hosts catch up on personal life and hint at discussing unusual crimes and stalkers in future episodes.
Hosts Mindy and Josh engage in lighthearted banter about a Muppets version of Hamilton and other amusing topics.
Hosts Mindy and Josh engage in casual banter before discussing unusual crimes and stalkers.
Hosts Mindy and Josh chat about their Fourth of July recording, their dogs' reactions to fireworks, and their upcoming wedding food tasting.