Am I the Bolcast?

Mike Carrozza

89 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

Commander etiquette with the sleeves rolled up.

The gist

Am I the Bolcast? turns Magic: The Gathering into a loose, funny table conversation about Commander, collection habits, deck choices, and social friction. Mike Carrozza steers interviews, mailbag stories, and card-by-card tangents with a warm sense of when the bit should keep going.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About Am I the Bolcast?

Am I the Bolcast? sits in the noisy middle of Magic: The Gathering culture, where Commander decks, social rules, pet cards, and personal taste all matter at once. Mike Carrozza leads the room with a fast, affectionate interview style that can wander for a while before landing hard on a card interaction or table-politics dilemma. The show is loose. It is not vague. Recent episodes spend real time on what newer players notice first, why certain precons click, how tokens and prowess can make a deck feel like an RPG party, and why a single commander can signal danger before anyone draws a card. Mailbag stories give the series its moral engine. A player retaliates after a Great Henge gets destroyed, someone brings poison-adjacent tension into a changing playgroup, and the table has to decide when removal is normal gameplay and when it feels personal. The joke is the hook, but the social read is the point. Guests widen the lane without pulling the show away from Magic. Hunter Saling of Business Casual and Tyler from Stars Hollow bring fresh-player perspective and outside creative energy. Command Zoe, Brian Kibler, Efren from CardSphere, Abrupt Decay, and Nick Wolf each give the conversations a different texture, from Commander seriousness to collection management to music-scene overlap. Sponsor reads and plugs are part of the rhythm, not a separate polished wrapper. Cardsphere, Bonebox Games, EDHREC, deck boxes, foils, obscure singles, and local game store habits all become ingredients in the same ongoing conversation. The show can be silly in the way a long night at the game store is silly: over-specific, self-aware, and a little too excited about cardboard. It also keeps returning to generosity. Being new does not make someone less interesting, and being competitive does not erase the need to read the table. That balance gives the show its charm. It is a podcast for players who want Commander talk with jokes still attached.

Made for: Best for Magic: The Gathering players who already enjoy Commander, card minutiae, table-politics stories, and hobby-adjacent guests from music. Newer players can follow the emotional beats, but the card talk assumes comfort with the game’s vocabulary.

What sets it apart: The show treats Commander disputes like funny little morality plays without sanding off the card-specific detail. Its guest episodes feel less like formal interviews and more like a game-store conversation that keeps finding another card, band, deck box, or bad table memory to inspect.

In their own words

The Magic: The Gathering podcast based on the EDHREC's column Am I The Bolas?Hosted By:Mike Carrozza aka "Mark Carbonza"Morgan Sanchez [superproducer/genius]

As heard by us

Based on 5 episodes we listened to · September 2026

Detailed Magic talk becomes a lively guide to deck building, playgroup etiquette, and the social decisions behind every game.

Am I the Bolcast? turns games of Magic: The Gathering into conversations about judgment, etiquette, and the pleasures of building a deck. Host Mike Carrozza moves easily between guest interviews and mailbag discussions with co-hosts Morgan Sanchez and Michael Solani, keeping the…

Read our full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A missed upkeep trigger becomes courtroom evidence when your Commander grudges need a ruling.

Press play if you want

  • to hear Mike Carrozza judge whether a player was the villain at the table
  • to compare new players' deck discoveries with the cards that first clicked for you
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Commander etiquettemailbag table disputesnew-player Magic experiencesdeck brewing and commanderscard trading and collectionsMagic guests from creative scenesplaygroup power dynamics

Talks about

Best episodes of Am I the Bolcast?

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

Bolcast 77 - Jumping Back into Being New to Magic with Hunter Saling of Business CasualApr 15, 2026

A chatty Commander hang that keeps returning to useful deck details.

Mike Carrozza keeps things loose with Hunter Saling in a catch-up that circles back to getting back into Magic and what that feels like in practice.

Bolcast 76 - Being New to Magic with Tyler from Stars HollowApr 8, 2026

A friendly, slightly loose Magic chat that makes being new part of the appeal.

The episode starts with sponsor reads, then settles into a friendly Magic conversation about learning the game, a rabbit deck that can snowball quickly, and the appeal of being new to Magic.

Bolcast 72 - Mailbag: Retaliation with Efren from CardSphereMar 13, 2026

A loose Commander chat with enough table politics and reality-TV detours to keep it moving.

This Magic: The Gathering episode is at its best when it settles into Commander grudges, power-level etiquette, and the uneasy etiquette of deciding when to swing back at the table.

Bolcast 71 - Hullbreacher Trauma and Mischievous Arena Opponents with Abrupt DecayMar 4, 2026

A scrappy Magic hangout shaped by rules talk, music fandom, and a little pettiness.

Am I the Bullcast spends its time in a pretty tight Magic conversation with Abrupt Decay, the Alberta hardcore band Mike Carrozza has clearly wanted on the show for a while.

Bolcast 70 - Adjusting to Playgroup Changes with Nick Wolf, Crossword Creator for EDHRECFeb 25, 2026

A useful Commander discussion about how new players and old habits can reshape a table.

The episode begins by revisiting Lorwyn commanders before settling into a listener question about a Commander pod that changed once newer players arrived and old assumptions about poison, control, and disruption no longer fit.

Podcasts like Am I the Bolcast?

Episodes

  1. 1

    Bolcast 88 - The Last One

    Mikey C Caroza announces a break from Am I the Bolcast, saying he is tired and cannot give the Magic show enough care.

    Sep 2, 2026·1h 18m·2 clips
  2. 2

    Bolcast 87 - An Affection for Mill with Tyler Day aka RopeArrow

    Aug 19, 2026·1h
  3. 3

    Bolcast 86 - Collect a Bounty with Lyght and Medusa from GasLyght Gatecrash Girlbite

    Jul 16, 2026·1h 7m
  4. 4

    Bolcast 85 - Commander IS the Peeve with Comedian and Author Sam Tallent

    Jul 8, 2026·55m
  5. 5

    Bolcast 84 - Guitars and Legacy with Drew from See You Next Tuesday

    Jun 24, 2026·1h 17m
  6. 6

    Bolcast 83 - Embracing the Bolas! with Rick Woods from See You Next Tuesday

    Jun 17, 2026·1h 13m
  7. 7

    Bolcast 82 - A LOST EPISODE RECOVERED! with PINDURSKI

    Jun 10, 2026·47m
  8. 8

    Bolcast 81 - Tyler Bucks Pulls from the Mailbag!

    Jun 3, 2026·1h 21m
  9. 9

    Bolcast 80 - Threats with Fox from See You Next Tuesday!

    May 20, 2026·1h 25m
  10. 10

    Bolcast 79 - LGS Demons with Cole from Hero's Blade Vibe Check

    Apr 29, 2026·1h 15m
  11. 11

    Bolcast 78 - Mike and Michael are Really Good at Mailbags

    Apr 22, 2026·1h 5m
  12. 12

    Bolcast 77 - Jumping Back into Being New to Magic with Hunter Saling of Business Casual

    Hidden gem

    Mike Carrozza opens the show in his usual half-chaotic, half-delighted mode.

    Apr 15, 2026·1h 16m·5 clips
  13. 13

    Bolcast 76 - Being New to Magic with Tyler from Stars Hollow

    Hidden gem

    Mike opens with sponsor reads and then settles into a relaxed conversation about being new to Magic.

    Apr 8, 2026·59m·4 clips
  14. 14

    Bolcast 75 - The Cards No One Plays! A Mailbag Ep with Mikey and Celani

    This episode is a mailbag discussion about five Magic the Gathering cards that are legal in the Commander format but have never been played in any of the 1.76 billion decks analyzed.

    Apr 1, 2026·1h 29m
  15. 15

    Bolcast 74 - Taking Commander Too Seriously with Commander's Herald Head Writer Command Zoe

    This episode of Am I the Bullcast features an interview with Commander's Herald head writer Command Zoe about taking Commander format too seriously, while promoting sponsors Cardsphere and Bonebox Games.

    Mar 25, 2026·1h 1m
  16. 16

    Bolcast 73 - Rolling a "Real" D20 with Magic Hall-of-Famer Brian Kibler

    This episode features an interview with Magic Hall-of-Famer Brian Kibler, preceded by sponsor promotions for card trading and gaming accessories.

    Mar 18, 2026·53m
  17. 17

    Bolcast 72 - Mailbag: Retaliation with Efren from CardSphere

    Hidden gem

    Mike Carrozza hosts with Morgan Sanchez and guest Efren from Cardsphere.

    Mar 13, 2026·1h 9m·5 clips
  18. 18

    Bolcast 71 - Hullbreacher Trauma and Mischievous Arena Opponents with Abrupt Decay

    Hidden gem

    Mike Carrozza opens the door for Abrupt Decay and keeps the chat loose.

    Mar 4, 2026·1h 24m·5 clips
  19. 19

    Bolcast 70 - Adjusting to Playgroup Changes with Nick Wolf, Crossword Creator for EDHREC

    Hidden gem

    Mike opens by admitting he was wrong about the Lorwyn commanders.

    Feb 25, 2026·1h 20m·5 clips
  20. 20

    Bolcast 69 - Bracket Bonanza with Tyler Bucks

    Feb 11, 2026·1h 8m
  21. 21

    Bolcast 68 - Focusing the New Guy with Legendary Creature Podcast

    Feb 3, 2026·1h 32m
  22. 22

    Bolcast 67 - Mailbag - Fetching a King

    Jan 28, 2026·57m
  23. 23

    Bolcast 66 - We're Back in the New Year with Carolyn Wang aka @Caro_IRL

    Jan 21, 2026·1h 7m
  24. 24

    Bolcast 65 - Goodbye 2025 - Year in Review and Resolutions

    Dec 23, 2025·1h 2m
  25. 25

    Bolcast 64 - "We're All Jeff!" - A mailbag episode with Jason Alt!

    Dec 9, 2025·1h 15m
  26. 26

    Bolcast 63 - Should we ignore Game Changers? Featuring special guest Stephen Bahl!

    Dec 2, 2025·1h 5m
  27. 27

    Bolcast 62 - Mailbag - Sorry, Ken! Again. Sorry. Ken. Featuring Bolcast editor Ken Peddle!

    Nov 25, 2025·47m
  28. 28

    Bolcast 61 - Mailbag - Mike has Finally Watched The Lord of The Rings

    Nov 18, 2025·1h 2m
  29. 29

    Bolcast 60 - Restrictions are Creative! with Olivia Gobert-Hicks!

    Nov 11, 2025·1h 10m
  30. 30

    Bolcast 59 - Mailbag - Is Michael the Bolas?

    Nov 5, 2025·55m
  31. 31

    Bolcast 58 - Breezing Through Phases with Cas Hinds aka StrixhavenDropout

    Oct 29, 2025·1h 4m
  32. 32

    Bolcast 57 - Precons? For New Players? with Culture Critic Reyna Cervantes

    Oct 21, 2025·1h 20m
  33. 33

    Bolcast 56 - Mailbag with Celani - Armageddon The Land Deck

    Oct 14, 2025·48m
  34. 34

    Bolcast 55 - Mailbag - Tony, Tony, Tony

    Oct 7, 2025·58m
  35. 35

    Bolcast 54 - Mailbag from RopeArrow! Embracing the Villain while Millin'

    Sep 30, 2025·47m
  36. 36

    Bolcast 53 - The Salties Rebuttal and Michael Celani Returns

    Sep 23, 2025·1h 11m
  37. 37

    Bolcast 52 - Dropping From an Event with Video Game Writer Ashley Cooper!

    This episode of the Magic: The Gathering podcast 'Am I the Bullcast' features an interview with video game writer Ashley Cooper about her journey with the game, with host Mike Caroza introducing the show and sponsors.

    Sep 16, 2025·1h 10m
  38. 38

    Bolcast 51 - Sandwich Story Time with GirlPod!

    Sep 2, 2025·50m
  39. 39

    Bolcast 50 - Magic Misogyny with GirlPod!

    Aug 26, 2025·1h 8m
  40. 40

    Bolcast 49 - Am I The Mailbag? - A Salty Retreat with Michael Celani (again!)

    Aug 19, 2025·1h 9m
  41. 41

    Bolcast 48 - Impact of Powerful Commanders with TorioftheVast of Scrybabies

    Aug 12, 2025·57m
  42. 42

    Bolcast 47 - Am I The Mailbag? - Killing The Ur-Dragon with Michael Celani

    Aug 5, 2025·31m
  43. 43

    Am I The Bolcast? 46 - Visible Saltiness with Michael Celani aka GamesfreakSA

    Jul 29, 2025·59m
  44. 44

    BONUS EPISODE - The Restless with Winslow Dumaine

    This bonus episode features a conversation about Winslow Dumaine's Kickstarter-funded board game The Restless, while explaining a temporary break in the regular podcast schedule.

    Jul 18, 2025·1h 18m
  45. 45

    Am I The Bolcast? 45 - Charm Offensive Politicking with Lua Stardust

    Jul 15, 2025·1h 1m
  46. 46

    Am I The Bolcast? 44 - Mailbag 03 - Mean Mikey Mailbag

    Jul 8, 2025·25m
  47. 47

    Am I The Bolcast? 43 - Buying Low from Your LGS with Sierkovitz of 17Lands and Magic Numbers

    Host Mike Carrozza discusses Magic the Gathering topics with Sierkovitz from 17Lands, focusing on limited formats and ideas for Wizards of the Coast.

    Jul 1, 2025·1h 6m
  48. 48

    Am I The Bolcast? 42 - Mailbag 02 - Mike Gets to Tell You His Pet Peeves

    Jun 24, 2025·48m
  49. 49

    Am I The Bolcast? 41 - Playing the Bolas with Logan aka SeraphSix

    Jun 17, 2025·1h 24m
  50. 50

    Am I The Bolcast? 40 - Mailbag 01 - Forestwalk the Walk

    Jun 10, 2025·41m
  51. 51

    Am I The Bolcast? 39 - Who's a Good Boy? with Dan Sheehan

    Jun 3, 2025·1h 23m
  52. 52

    Am I The Bolcast? 38 - Plan Your Turn with Spikefeeder Alex

    May 20, 2025·56m
  53. 53

    Am I The Bolcast? 37 - Reputation with Ian Flannery aka ComedIanMtg

    May 6, 2025·1h 21m
  54. 54

    36 - Art of Bulk Cards Need Love Too with Vorthos Mike

    Apr 22, 2025·1h 22m
  55. 55

    35 - Dying on the Mill Hill with YOUR Commander Mechanic

    Apr 8, 2025·1h 32m
  56. 56

    34 - Bad Faith Bracketeeting with Matt Morgan of EDHRECast

    Mar 25, 2025·1h 40m
  57. 57

    33 - Deafness and Magic and Combos and Grudges with Wedgi of Commander Spellbook

    Mar 11, 2025·1h 15m
  58. 58

    32 - Goin' Hard in 1v1 and Rolling Dice with Ryan Nicholas aka Tronisbad

    The hosts celebrate a belated birthday, discuss recent events in Chicago, and express gratitude to their community for attending meet-ups and live recordings.

    Feb 25, 2025·1h 6m
  59. 59

    31 - In the Tank with Spencer Crittenden

    This episode of Am I the Bullcast, a Magic the Gathering podcast, features hosts Mike Carozza and Morgan Sanchez discussing upcoming Chicago shows and setting up an interview with Spencer Crittenden.

    Feb 11, 2025·1h 23m
  60. 60

    30 - Sore Losers with MTGMuddstah

    Jan 28, 2025·1h 15m
  61. 61

    29 - A Hot Take Tweet with Nile Joan Rivers

    Jan 14, 2025·1h 26m
  62. 62

    28 - Too Many Moving Parts with Spike Feeder Aaron (and special guest judge Jake Browne)

    Dec 17, 2024·1h 23m
  63. 63

    27 - Not Playing to Win with Emma Partlow

    Dec 3, 2024·1h 21m
  64. 64

    26 - A Wee Bit O'Stax with Quinn and Cole of Hero's Blade Vibe Check

    Nov 19, 2024·1h 19m
  65. 65

    25 - Magic Art Commission Dos and Don'ts with Jack Hughes

    Nov 5, 2024·1h 10m
  66. 66

    24 - Defending Group Hug with Michael Almond of The Social Contract: An EDH Podcast

    Oct 22, 2024·1h 9m
  67. 67

    23 - Focused Threat Assessment with CCOBrando

    Oct 8, 2024·51m
  68. 68

    22 - Hot Pepsi Armageddon: Live at Commander Sealed

    Sep 24, 2024·59m
  69. 69

    21 - White with Davy (@DavyFJones)

    Sep 10, 2024·1h 14m
  70. 70

    20 - Silly Decks and Shenanigans with AD DeFazio

    Aug 27, 2024·1h
  71. 71

    19 - Knowledge Pool and No Plans for Board Wipes with Mr. Bevers

    Aug 13, 2024·53m
  72. 72

    18 - Playing to Win with Angelo Guerrera aka TheJesGuy

    Jul 30, 2024·1h 8m
  73. 73

    17 - Grubby Sleeves (and more) with Sam of Rhystic Studies

    Jul 16, 2024·1h 15m
  74. 74

    16 - Being a Woman in Magic with Beth Queenofcardboard

    Jul 2, 2024·1h 11m
  75. 75

    15 - Walking Away with Joey Schultz of EDHRECast

    Jun 18, 2024·1h 15m
  76. 76

    14 - Indecisive Targeting with The Howling Salt Mine

    Jun 4, 2024·1h 16m
  77. 77

    13 - A Particular Amonkhet Rare with The Howling Salt Mine

    May 21, 2024·1h 19m
  78. 78

    12 - How Long Do You Take Per Turn? with Jake Browne

    May 7, 2024·1h 9m
  79. 79

    11 - Farewell and Wasting Time with Jason Alt

    Apr 23, 2024·1h 10m
  80. 80

    10 - Being Mindful of Your Playstyle with CCORyan of Commander Cookout

    Apr 9, 2024·56m
  81. 81

    09 - Not a Group Hug Deck! Please! with Kurohitsuki

    Mar 26, 2024·1h 20m
  82. 82

    08 - Challenge Accepted with Emmara, Goddess of Blunder

    Mar 12, 2024·1h 18m
  83. 83

    07 - Distracted Players with Cal Jones (@MTGCal)

    Feb 27, 2024·1h 11m
  84. 84

    06 - "Long Turn, No Win" with Shivam Bhatt!

    Feb 13, 2024·1h 5m
  85. 85

    05 - Pulling Punches with Rachel Weeks!

    Jan 30, 2024·1h 1m
  86. 86

    04 - Know Your Deck with Jimmy Wong

    Jan 16, 2024·1h 1m
  87. 87

    03 - Experiences for the Table with VeggieWagon

    Jan 2, 2024·40m
  88. 88

    02 - Rule Zero Commanders with Dan Sheehan

    Dec 19, 2023·39m
  89. 89

    01 - "Easy" Commanders with Dana Roach

    Nov 30, 2023·44m