Great Lakes true crime, carefully told.
Already Gone covers unsolved murders, missing-person cases, and historical crimes across Michigan, the Great Lakes region, and nearby states. Its strength is restraint: local detail, court records, local reporting, and clear separation between confirmed facts and rumor.
PRESS PLAY
Already Gone is a Michigan-rooted true-crime show with an archival sense of place. It is built around cases that still leave marks on families, neighborhoods, and police files. The show’s recent run includes Tamara Greene, Amber Arnett, Craig Sytsma, Tammy Tracey, North Fox Island, and the multi-part “Don’t Talk to Strangers” coverage of child murders and related cases in Oakland County and Detroit. The tone is sober. It does not rush toward the most shocking detail. Instead, it starts with names, homes, school days, family routines, ordinary roads, and the small pieces of context that make a victim more than a case label. Geography carries real weight here. Birmingham is not just an upscale suburb, Detroit is not just a backdrop, and North Fox Island is understood through its isolation, shoreline, history, and access. The show often widens from a single crime into the systems around it. Public-records costs, redactions, missing answers, court outcomes, prior warnings, reward lines, task-force leads, and local journalism all become part of the record. That procedural patience gives the storytelling its authority. It also gives the grief room to breathe. In the Craig Sytsma episode, a rural road and earlier dog attacks become evidence of preventability. In the Amber Arnett episode, a last text to family opens onto trauma, addiction, vulnerability, and a mother forced into her own search. In the Oakland County material, the show returns again and again to what was known, what was assumed, and what official channels still have not made available. It can be blunt about institutional failure. It is careful about rumor. That balance matters, especially in older cases where memory, fear, and withheld records compete with documented fact. Already Gone is best for listeners who prefer measured true crime, regional history, and victim-centered reporting over sensational pacing. It is grim material, handled with restraint.
Made for: For true-crime listeners who prefer measured reporting, local history, and procedural detail over spectacle. It especially suits people interested in Michigan, Detroit, the Great Lakes region, cold cases, and unresolved investigations.
What sets it apart: Already Gone stands out for its regional depth and its attention to the paper trail: public-records requests, court records, local journalism, geography, and the limits of official disclosure. It treats rumor as rumor and gives documented facts room to carry the weight.
Great Lakes. True Crime. Host Nina Innsted covers lesser-known cases from MICHIGAN and the Great Lakes Region. #TrueCrime #unsolved #Michigan
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Nina Innsted connects Michigan cases to records, local memory, and the people left carrying their consequences.
Already Gone treats Michigan crime as a matter of record and memory. Nina Innsted delivers mostly narrated case accounts, while the multi-part "Don't Talk to Strangers" series shows her working at serialized true crime scale.
When Michigan's official files go dark, Nina Innsted keeps you with the unanswered questions.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A murder case set against Detroit's Kilpatrick-era political fallout.
The episode keeps Green at the center, and that is where it feels strongest. It lets the killing stay unresolved for long enough to build tension instead of rushing past it, while the Detroit political backdrop gives the case some useful weight.
A measured finale where the price of answers becomes part of the case.
The finale returns to Birmingham and frames the John McKinney murder as part of the wider Oakland County child killings, where concern, rumor, and official silence shaped what could be known.
A careful true crime account that treats the earlier warnings as part of the story, not background noise.
This episode handles the fatal dog attack in rural Michigan with a careful, grounded pace. Craig Sytsma is treated as a person at the center of a loss, not just a case name, and the story moves cleanly through Thomas Road, the attack, and the effort to piece together what…
A measured, devastating look at a community still living with unanswered child murders.
Metro Detroit's 1976 child-murder cases give the episode its weight, and it makes that scale clear early: nine children killed in fifteen months, three cases resolved, and six still unanswered.
A sober true-crime story about violence, grief, and the long shadow left on a family.
Already Gone treats Nicole Sanchez's case as more than a crime story. It lingers on the grief and consequence that follow a brutal killing, from a life marked by promise to the family still living with that loss two decades later.
A sober account of the Oxford shooting and the legal accountability that followed.
This is a sober account of the Oxford High School shooting and the legal reckoning that followed. It starts with the attack itself and keeps returning to the question that still hangs over the case: how a 15-year-old could walk out of a school bathroom with a pistol and, within…
A clear, interview-led look at a notorious Michigan case.
This November bonus episode stays closest to the case when it sticks to Rod Sadler's account. It walks through Ron Bailey's crimes, the serial killer question, and the possibility of more victims without trying to hurry any of it along, which suits the material.
True stories of scams, aliases, frauds, and lives built on lies.
Payne Lindsey and Tenderfoot TV revisit the Atlanta Child Murders and the wider Monster franchise.
Host Jake Brennan traces the crimes and scandals behind musicians from Elvis to Taylor Swift.
Karina Longworth narrates the Manson murders as a story about Hollywood's collapsing 1960s dream.
iO Tillett Wright investigates her mother's boyfriend's unsolved 1982 East Village murder.
A wilderness hoax, a trusting BC town, and the brothers who fooled it.
Tamara Greene's murder is still unsolved.
Children were the target.
Craig Sytsma, a 46-year-old Livonia engineer and cancer survivor, died after a July 23, 2014 mauling by two Cane Corso dogs in Metamora Township, Michigan.
This episode examines the 1977 disappearance and murder case of Timothy King in Birmingham, focusing on the police investigation and the Blue Gremlin vehicle lead.
This episode investigates the disappearance of Amber Arnett in Lansing, Michigan, exploring how trauma, addiction, and systemic failures intersect in her case.
This episode explores a 1977 copycat murder case in Detroit involving 10-year-old Valerie Bishop, following a pattern of child murders in Oakland County.
This episode covers the unsolved murder case of Tammy Tracy from Rockford, Illinois, a cold case that has haunted her family for decades.
This episode covers the unsolved murder and sexual assault of children in Michigan, focusing on the history of North Fox Island and the investigation into Francis Sheldon.
This episode revisits the Oakland County child murders, a series of unsolved abductions and killings in Metro Detroit from 1976-1977.
This episode investigates the disappearance of Jennifer from Mount Morris Township, Michigan, on Leap Day 2000, exploring the community context and evidence suggesting she is dead.
This episode discusses the Oakland County child killer case, focusing on the unsolved murders of children in Michigan.
This episode discusses the unsolved murder of 12-year-old Mark Stebbins and the pattern of child abductions in Oakland County in the 1970s.
This episode recounts the 2010 heroin overdose death of Shelby Perkins, the subsequent conviction of her boyfriend Mitchell Perner for reckless homicide, and his controversial early release in 2022.
This episode explores the Babysitter Murders case involving teenage girls in Oakland County, transitioning to a personal recollection of Ferndale and its F&M store.
The fear still hangs around.
This episode examines the tragic murder of Nada Huranieh, a Syrian immigrant in Michigan, focusing on her life, domestic violence, and the trial of her son Muhammad Altan Tawi.
This episode features a casual interview collaboration between hosts from three true crime podcasts discussing cold cases and unsolved mysteries.
This episode explores the 2013 disappearance of Jessica Heeringa from a Michigan gas station, connecting it to other crimes while focusing on the victims rather than the perpetrator.
Nicole Sanchez had dreams, talent, and promise.
Oxford had warnings.
November brings an author interview.
This episode investigates the 1998 disappearance of Stacey Colbert from Chicago, detailing her life and the ongoing search for justice.
This episode covers the 1991 Royal Oak post office shooting and the disappearance of Jennifer.
The episode covers the unsolved hit-and-run death of Kelly Boyce Hurlburt in Traverse City, Michigan, with interviews and appeals for new leads.
A true crime podcast covering lesser-known cases from Michigan and the Great Lakes region.
Host Nina Innsted discusses the Oakland County child killings with an anonymous author, focusing on the investigation rather than the crimes themselves.
This episode explores the life and crimes of Dr.
This episode explores the first assisted suicide by Dr.
This episode covers the disappearance of 17-year-old Zion Foster from Detroit in January 2022.
This episode features a guest podcast about the unsolved disappearance of seven-year-old Carla Rodriguez in Las Vegas.
This episode investigates the disappearance of Kim Dijon from Warren, Michigan in 2014.
This episode covers the 1981 disappearance of Lonnie Ray Rogers in Pennsylvania, focusing on her daughter's fight for justice.
This episode covers the case of Roger Sweet, a violent offender released early due to COVID-19, and the disappearance of Jennifer.
Host discusses missing persons statistics and best practices for families and law enforcement.
This episode covers the unsolved disappearance of Bianca Green and the murder of Patrice Wilson, both linked to Jameer Miller, highlighting domestic violence.