Pop culture picks, comic chaos, real draft stakes.
All Fantasy Everything is a comedy panel show built around drafting categories like giant stuff, famous dogs, mythical creatures, Seinfeld items, Jackass stunts, and Taylor Swift. The format gives the room just enough structure for fast interruptions, stray memories, mock strategy, and running bits to take over.
PRESS PLAY
All Fantasy Everything takes the familiar draft structure and applies it to whatever pop culture category the room can make funny. The premise is simple. The conversation is not. A topic like giant stuff becomes a path to blue whales, dinosaurs, math, and the strange humility of living at the same time as the biggest creature around. A draft of things to say before putting sunglasses on turns into stage banter, parody lyrics, bathroom stories, and the tiny pride of a perfectly timed one-liner. The show keeps pretending to be organized, which is part of the joke. Draft order matters, picks matter, and then someone says something sideways enough that the whole table chases it for a while. That rhythm makes the format feel both reliable and unstable. Recent episodes move from Jackass stunts to famous dogs, mythical creatures, Seinfeld items, things that go bad, and Taylor Swift, with guests bringing their own memories and pet arguments into the room. Ian Carmel is identified as the host, with Sean Jordan and David Borey recurring as friends and comedians in the panel. Their dynamic is quick and familiar. Corrections become punchlines. Repetition becomes momentum. A dumb distinction can suddenly get treated like a legal standard. The guest chair matters, too, because people like Laura Peek, Troy Walker, Jay Larson, Katherine Blanford, Shane Torres, Dana Schwartz, Lizzie Logan, Spencer Bland, and Alex Falcone all enter a show already moving at full speed. The result is not a clean countdown or a polished pop culture essay. It is a funny group deciding, loudly and with unnecessary conviction, what belongs on the board. Best for listeners who want comedy that feels spontaneous without losing its game.
Made for: Best for comedy fans who like fast panel banter, pop culture memory, and arguments over categories that barely need to exist. It also fits listeners who enjoy friends talking over each other with affection and precision.
What sets it apart: The draft format gives every episode a scoreboard, but the real draw is how quickly the panel turns definitions, callbacks, and throwaway details into shared bits. It feels less like a list show than a comedy room using lists as kindling.
All Fantasy Everything is a show where funny people and experts come together to fantasy draft pop culture, from music to movies to sandwiches, everything is in play. This is a Headgum podcast. Follow Headgum on Twitter, Instagram, and Tiktok. Advertise on All Fantasy Everything via Gumball.fm.
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
A fantasy-draft framework turns pop-culture picks into playful arguments, sharp tangents, and easy chemistry among Ian Carmel, Sean Jordan, David Borey, and guests.
All Fantasy Everything turns a fantasy draft into a sturdy frame for comic digression. Ian Carmel, Sean Jordan, and David Borey make picks, defend them, and give each choice enough room to trigger arguments and side stories.
A draft of famous dogs detours into JP Morgan eyebrows; you've found your people.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A blue whale's impossible scale sends a giant-stuff draft into a useful algebra detour.
A giant-stuff draft gives All Fantasy Everything a sturdy premise, then lets it wobble productively through blue whale scale, tiny krill, and personal math avoidance.
A sunglasses draft turns a weeks-old text reply into the room's sharpest social panic.
All Fantasy Everything turns the tiny ceremony of putting on sunglasses into a draft prompt, then lets the room worry at it until a delayed text reply becomes the line everyone can picture.
A Jackass-stunt draft rides loose names, nervous energy, and a panel eager to bend every setup sideways.
All Fantasy Everything turns Jackass stunts from the shows and movies into fantasy-draft fuel, with David holding the first pick and the first round treated like a bloodbath.
A dog draft slips into wrestling eyebrows, JP Morgan comparisons, and a FUBU jersey debate.
All Fantasy Everything opens on a draft of real and fictional dogs, then wanders into wrestling logic, eyebrow reads, and a phone search for a supposed JP Morgan resemblance.
A loose draft turns name games, Hanson arguments, and a buffet pick into a comedy pile-on.
Things That Go Bad lets a fantasy draft wander almost immediately, and that is largely the point. Ian Carmel, Sean Jordan, and David Boren are joined by Katherine Blanford and Shane Torres from Coastal Idiots, with the opening stretch turning a name-order dispute into Shanthren,…
A social-quote argument about Austin Powers becomes a funny test of what cultural importance sounds like.
All Fantasy Everything turns a quick argument over one word into a small pop-culture stakes game. Ian Carmel first frames Josh Gondelman's case as Mike Myers and Austin Powers being more important, or maybe more impressive, than anything Casey Affleck has done in a movie.
A sunglasses prompt turns into hood-based overcompensation and a serious beatboxing challenge.
All Fantasy Everything turns the narrow question of what to say before putting on sunglasses into a shared social puzzle, giving a tiny moment enough pressure for the joke to keep shifting.
Tiny debates, treated with heroic seriousness.
Host Ian Karmel, with comedians Sean Jordan and David Gborie, and guest Josh Gondelman, draft 'interactions with strangers' on All Fantasy Everything.
The hosts auction draft Nicolas Cage movies with guest Zach Harper.
Hosts Ian Karmel, David Gborie, and Sean Jordan are joined by guest Laura Peek to fantasy draft 'things to say before putting on sunglasses.' The episode features rapid-fire comedic banter, tangents on topics like athlete's foot, dolphin anatomy, and anxiety.
The hosts and a guest draft Winter Olympics events and athletes in a comedic fantasy draft format.
The hosts and guest Alec Flynn draft tall tales and legends in a fantasy draft format.
Comedians discuss hosting a podcast and introduce guest Lizzie Logan.
All Fantasy Everything drafts "giant stuff" with Alex Falcone while the show opens by promoting the Portland 10-year anniversary show at the Aladdin Theater on September 26.
All Fantasy Everything spends the episode drafting "things to say right before you put your sunglasses on," with an opening Trailblazin merch plug running through Sunday.
Sean Jordan, David Borey, and guest Spencer Bland use the "Jackass" draft to map how Big Brother magazine, Jeff Tremaine, and Johnny Knoxville turned a skate-zine world into MTV stunts.
["All Fantasy Everything's \"Famous Dogs\" episode on HeadGum opens with Ian Carmel announcing a draft of \"dogs.
The hosts and guest Troy Walker discuss drafting mythical creatures and the female orgasm in a comedic fantasy draft podcast.
Comedians draft items from Seinfeld episodes they'd like to own, with guest Jay Larson.
All Fantasy Everything hosts Ian Carmel, Sean Jordan, and David Boren are joined by comedians Katherine Blanford and Shane Torres of the Coastal Idiots podcast to draft 'things that go bad' in a three-round serpentine format.