All Aussie Hour runs on a dependable arrangement. One host shows up with a story, and the other hears it and reacts. Mel and Josie swap those roles, and they have been talking into microphones together for a long time, by their own account going back to All Aussie Mystery Hour in 2018 and later The Zest Is History. The subject list is broad and very Australian. There are episodes about the Emu War, the strawberry needle spiking incident and the Whiskey Au Go Go fire, alongside Heath Ledger, Dave Grohl and one titled 'Aussie Rules Footy: People With Tight Shorts On Run Around A Lot'. The Whiskey Au Go Go episode shows how much detail a story can carry. Its thread runs through John Andrew Stewart, a known criminal jailed in 1936 for attempted murder, who later spread rumours to club owners, reporters and detectives about Sydney criminals wanting to extort Brisbane nightclubs. Toward the end of 1972, as the hosts tell it, he told a reporter an empty club would be firebombed first and the Whiskey Au Go Go next, during peak trade. The episode closes with the pair saying they may return to it if an inquest produces an answer. Even here the mood stays loose, and doing research that week earns a proud congratulation. The strawberry story is framed through the hosts' own history: it dates to September 2018, the year they launched their first podcast together. Other episodes lean warmer and more nostalgic. In the Heath Ledger conversation the pair stay on his teen film based on The Taming of the Shrew, say nobody else could have played the part and praise his chemistry with Julia Stiles. 'Emergency Mini Episode: Dave Grohl' is a different animal, an unplanned and chatty reaction to celebrity news that turns into a case for apologies in plain, personal words rather than sanitised PR phrasing. The hosts say having thoughts and feelings is the core of the podcast. Digressions are constant and clearly welcome. A description of emus as flightless, human-sized and alarming on foot turns into a verdict that Big Bird is a bit creepy, Cookie Monster is pure of soul and Oscar the Grouch owns his darkness. Life updates, from a sister's wedding to Kate's hens weekend to a drive back to Lajamanu, open several episodes. The frame stays consistent. Episodes include an acknowledgement of Country for Nipaluna and for Lajamanu on Gurindji country, where the show is recorded, followed by an intro line that starts in the croc-infested waters of the NT. The footy episode stops for a catch-up after a long hiatus, retelling where the pair came from for anyone who has lost track. They sign off together with 'that's it', sometimes adding 'hooroo'.