Zero Brightness - A Podcast About Horror Video Games · Ecstattic Studio

Zero Brightness Ep. 181: Why Josh Thinks You Should Play Returnal

·1 hr 20 min·5 clips

Josh describes a good run followed by shielded enemies and challenge rooms that made Returnal feel broken.

1. Zero Brightness Ep. 181 focuses on Josh's case for why Returnal is good and why it still frustrated him. 2. Josh Ali appears as the guest, and the host pushes him to defend Returnal with notes and named categories. 3. The episode asks whether Returnal's roguelike structure, bullet-hell combat, and story layers are worth the time sink. 4. Josh says Returnal launched on PS5 in 2021 and later came to Steam after a one-year console exclusive period. 5. He compares the game to Hades, which he played for a couple of hours before quitting because he does not like roguelikes. 6. Ali defines roguelikes as games built around one-run progression, knowledge, and permanent upgrades that can carry across attempts. 7. The two of them use Mystery Dungeon, arcade games, and arcade-style death mechanics to explain why the genre exists. 8. Josh says Returnal feels harsher than older games because it does not give the player a clear early freebie. 9. He describes almost 17 hours on Steam without beating the first boss, then a fresh PS5 run that lasted about two hours before he quit again. 10. A challenge room with locked doors and multiple bosses, plus shielded turrets in another run, convinced him the game could feel randomly broken. 11. Ali argues that the rooms are pre-made and the randomness lies in how they cycle, not in total layout generation. 12. Josh says the game's knowledge-check design still fails for him when RNG overrides skill and planning. 13. Ali counters that the risk-reward rooms become manageable once you learn which doors and drops to avoid. 14. Josh says Returnal's systems include parasites, malignancies, obolites, ether, weapon upgrades, and adrenaline levels. 15. He describes a chest moment where he had to decide whether to take a malignancy that might ruin a run or pay off later. 16. Both hosts agree that the controls, movement, dodge, haptics, and PS5 tuning feel exceptionally good. 17. The conversation stays argumentative but friendly, with both sides repeating that they understand the other person's experience. 18. The format is a long-form back-and-forth with game design talk, personal anecdotes, and direct pushback. 19. Listeners who like horror games, roguelikes, and system-heavy design will get the most out of this. 20. Listeners who want spoiler-free praise or quick recommendations may skip it.

As heard by us

A stubborn, systems-first case for why Returnal clicks.

Zero Brightness makes a stubborn case for Returnal, a PS5 roguelike that wears sci-fi horror and keeps asking whether the punishment earns the loop.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want someone to make Returnal sound worth the bruises.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Zero Brightness - A Podcast About Horror Video Games