Zacks Market Edge · Zacks Investment Research

Is the Warren Buffett Premium Over?

August 15, 2025·29 min·2 clips

Warren Buffett is stepping down as CEO in 2026—will Berkshire Hathaway's stock lose its premium without him?

This episode of the Value Investor Podcast with host Tracy Reineck analyzes Berkshire Hathaway's stock following Warren Buffett's announced departure as CEO. Reineck examines whether the company's historical market premium, tied to Buffett's leadership, is now diminishing. The discussion centers on Berkshire's current valuation, business segments, and future under incoming CEO Greg Abel. Berkshire Hathaway B shares are down 7% over the last three months, while the S&P 500 rallied 9.8%. The stock's price-to-book ratio is currently 1.5, down from a recent high of 1.8, but still above the 1.2 level where Buffett has historically authorized share buybacks. Zacks consensus estimates forecast earnings falling 6.7% to $20.53 per share in 2025. Second-quarter operating earnings fell 4% year-over-year, and the company took a $5 billion write-down on its Kraft Heinz investment. Insurance underwriting income fell 12%, while the BNSF railroad segment saw a 19% increase. A surprising insight is that Berkshire's cash holdings now represent 29.6% of the company, the highest level in decades, totaling $344 billion. The host notes that Buffett has not authorized share buybacks for five consecutive quarters, suggesting he may also view the stock as expensive. Despite its size, McLean—a food distribution company owned by Berkshire for over 20 years—remains obscure, with 2025 revenue potentially exceeding its reported 2017 figure of $50 billion. The episode questions whether Greg Abel can deploy this massive cash hoard as effectively as Buffett did during past crises like 2008. The tone is analytical and educational, breaking down complex financial data into digestible segments for individual investors. Reineck adopts a cautious, value-focused perspective, frequently referencing specific valuation metrics and segment performance. This episode is ideal for value investors and Berkshire Hathaway shareholders monitoring the transition away from Buffett's direct leadership. Listeners seeking speculative growth stories or definitive buy/sell recommendations might find the host's cautious, data-heavy approach less engaging.

As heard by us

A clean look at Berkshire after Buffett, with enough business detail to separate the legend from the machine.

The episode looks at Berkshire Hathaway as more than a ticker. It asks how much still rests on Warren Buffett and how much now sits with the business he built.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the Berkshire question without the hype.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Zacks Market Edge