0% Capital Gains Tax vs. Roth Conversion vs.... a Cruise?

·38 min·3 clips

Nancy considers a risky 401k loan to boost her brokerage account, but Joe and Big Al reveal a surprising truth about her retirement readiness.

The episode opens with Nancy's question about taking a 401k loan to invest in a brokerage account, which Joe and Big Al quickly dismiss after analyzing her $900,000 in assets, $37,000 Social Security income, and $75,000 annual spending. They suggest she might consider small Roth conversions upon retirement instead. Next, Brian from Naperville asks whether asset allocation strategies account for the stabilizing effect of Social Security payments, equating them to Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS). The hosts acknowledge the cleverness but emphasize focusing on the shortfall between expenses and fixed income to determine portfolio demand. Joy writes in about inheriting $400,000, with her brother also inheriting a similar amount amid struggles with addiction; the hosts recommend a 60/40 stock/bond portfolio and caution against annuities. Joy herself, age 56 with substantial assets, is advised to view her entire portfolio holistically rather than compartmentalizing the inheritance. Mike from Texas has a $205,000 annual income stream and $1.3 million in traditional IRAs, wondering whether to do Roth conversions, invest in a brokerage, or go on a cruise. Joe and Big Al strongly recommend Roth conversions up to the 22% tax bracket, using cash to pay taxes. Finally, Skipper presents a complex scenario with $1.6 million in a taxable account and $2 million in retirement accounts, debating between Roth conversions and harvesting zero percent capital gains. The hosts lean toward prioritizing Roth conversions to avoid future high RMD taxes, unless diversification is needed. Throughout, the hosts blend humor with technical analysis, referencing pop culture like Gilligan's Island and personal anecdotes about drinks.

As heard by us

A grounded retirement-money discussion about taxes, inheritance, Social Security, bonds and one very specific cruise decision.

Retirement advice is at its clearest when tax strategy runs into a real household choice, and this episode stays in that useful territory. Nancy in Washington is looking at a 401(k) loan that would pay herself back at 9% interest, while Brian in Naperville, Illinois, asks…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Your retirement plan meets a 9% 401(k) loan, a $400,000 inheritance, Social Security-as-stability, and the lure of a cruise.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Your Money, Your Wealth