WW2 Pod: We Have Ways of Making You Talk

How To Commemorate WW2

·42 min·4 clips

Angela Finlay grew up with a photo of her German general grandfather on the desk in rural Hampshire.

The episode begins with hosts Al Murray and James Holland introducing guests Angela Finlay and Henry Montgomery. Angela explains her background: born in the US and raised in rural Hampshire, she grew up with a photo of her German general grandfather on her mother's desk, which she later realized was problematic. She describes internalizing anti-German sentiment from media and school lessons on the Holocaust, leading to shame about her heritage. A turning point came in her 40s when watching the film 'Downfall' triggered an emotional reaction, prompting her to google her grandfather and discover his surrender photo. This sparked a journey to uncover his past, approaching it without judgment to understand how ordinary people can commit atrocities. Henry Montgomery shares his experience as the grandson of Field Marshal Montgomery, recalling a traumatic childhood memory of public attention during a royal tournament. He discusses Monty's controversial post-war reputation and his own later efforts to know his grandfather better. The conversation broadens to commemoration, with Angela noting Germany's progression from silence to a culture of memorials, though family-level pain persists. James highlights the importance of reconciliation, citing veterans' messages to 'not let it happen again'. Angela advocates for broadening remembrance to include all war victims, citing figures like 24 million Russian and 30 million Chinese deaths. The hosts and guests discuss the dangers of complacency in modern society, referencing Eisenhower's 1953 speech about freedom needing daily refreshment. Angela emphasizes teaching about 'othering' in schools as a root cause of conflict. Henry reflects on Monty's trauma and his focus on rebuilding after the war. The episode concludes with reflections on intergenerational trauma, the complexity of history, and the ongoing process of reconciliation.

As heard by us

A WW2 commemoration discussion that becomes a family reckoning.

How To Commemorate WW2 treats remembrance as something harder than ceremony, asking how to honor a war whose dead cannot be folded neatly into one national story.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want remembrance work that starts with a family portrait and gets morally complicated fast.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from WW2 Pod: We Have Ways of Making You Talk