Word In Your Ear

Rock’s fascination with the Third Reich exposed by Daniel Rachel

·36 min·3 clips
Daniel Rachel describes how watching Holocaust footage as a child collided with his love for the Sex Pistols' swastika-laden punk.
Word In Your Ear welcomes Daniel Rachel to talk about rock's fascination with the Third Reich. The conversation begins by stressing how visible that fascination once was, which makes it feel even stranger now. Today, it would look astonishing. Rachel and the hosts then move back through the history rather than lingering on the shock. Brian Jones appears through magazine covers, an SS uniform, a trampled doll, and Anita Pallenberg at his feet. The image is treated as something more than costume, because violence and spectacle are already built into it. Roxy Music comes up next, with the discussion focused on the borrowed style of the German uniform and how easily it could slide into fashion and pose. Punk changes the temperature. Malcolm McLaren is presented as deliberately bringing the swastika into punk to shock and horrify people. The conversation also notes that he was bar mitzvahed and grew up in a Jewish environment in Stoke Newington. Bernie Rhodes stands in contrast. His maternal line were survivors of the Holocaust, and he refused any use of the swastika by The Clash or by himself. That divide helped break the partnership apart. Caroline Coon enters as another firm critic of McLaren. The discussion keeps widening, even detouring through Golders Green, a Jewish area, and the logic of using Nazi dress to antagonize people. Rachel is careful to say he is not asking anyone to burn records or stop listening. He wants the history laid out plainly. The judgment is left open. The episode closes on Holocaust memory, on victims beyond Jews, and on the idea that rock and roll has brilliance, but also downfalls it must face with a compassionate and humanitarian duty.

As heard by us

Rock history, Nazi imagery, and the line between provocation and harm.

Word In Your Ear treats rock's fascination with the Third Reich as a serious subject rather than a shock tactic, tracing it through Brian Jones in an SS uniform, Malcolm McLaren's swastika use in punk, Bernie Rhodes' refusal, and Daniel Rachel's history.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

When rock history gets ugly, this is the conversation that keeps the context in view.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on