Wonderful! · Rachel and Griffin McElroy

Wonderful! 399: We Keep You Warm With Our Coat Show

December 10, 2025·33 min·3 clips

Griffin and Rachel McElroy claim their podcast keeps listeners warm like a coat, baffling scientists who question their logic.

Wonderful starts zipped all the way up. Rachel and Griffin imagine the show as a warm, puffy, impossible coat made of fabric, spicy affection, and podcast physics. The scientists object, which mostly gives the bit more room to get sillier: late-night calls, happier listeners, and a rival podcast mix-up that somehow feels inevitable. Then Rachel takes over with The Spirit of Christmas, the 2016 movie they have mentioned before but never fully handled. Griffin gets the mood right away. The chat moves from Apple TV friction to YouTube availability, because the holiday miracle here is access. Rachel has notes. She follows the actress through a run of holiday movies, from Mingle All the Way to Royally Wrapped Christmas, and the titles keep getting better. A Paris Christmas Waltz sounds promising. A Christmas-tory stops the room. Then Great American Family pulls the conversation sideways, with Rachel laying out the Great American Country rebrand and its faith-based angle. Griffin catches the darker little note under it. Candace Cameron Bure comes in as context for why the network split from the Hallmark lane, but they do not turn it into a lecture. It stays curious and kitchen-table casual, with just enough side-eye to keep the context in view. The ending gets practical: The Stowaway, the receipt-in-a-card holiday move, and the last Adventure Zone graphic novel preorder. Then the coat bit returns for one more warm, faintly threatening goodbye before the Maximum Fun credits.

As heard by us

A warm, goofy winter ramble that moves from coat jokes into Christmas-movie chatter.

Rachel and Griffin keep the episode in a light, self-contained lane: coat jokes, winter chatter, and a long stretch of Christmas-movie talk. The best part is the quick bounce between them, especially when the banter slides from being "hot stuff" to The Spirit of Christmas,…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want your holiday chatter bundled up in sibling chaos.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Wonderful!