Witches, Magic, Murder, & Mystery · Megan and Kara

365. MYSTERY: Let's Talk About Atlantis

·27 min·1 clip

Lake Issyk-Kul is the world's eighth deepest lake, and a team found walls, beams, and a millstone underwater.

1. Witches, Magic, Murder, & Mystery centers this episode on Atlantis, Lake Issyk-Kul, and other submerged cities. 2. Kara and Megan host the discussion, and Kara drives the history while Megan reacts with questions about Plato, archaeology, and modern headlines. 3. The episode asks whether Atlantis was a real place, a moral story, or a pattern built from actual drowned cities. 4. The first major example is Lake Issyk-Kul in Kyrgyzstan, where underwater archaeologists worked along the northwestern shore at the Teru Agir Complex. 5. The divers used cameras and measuring tapes in cold, cloudy water and found fired brick walls, caved-in stone structures, and wooden beams. 6. A circular millstone used to crush grain suggested the site was not a passing stop but a working city. 7. The team also identified graves and described a Muslim necropolis from the 13th or 14th century. 8. Kara and Megan say the settlement belonged to a major Silk Road artery that moved silk, spices, metal, coins, and gossip between China and the Mediterranean. 9. They describe the city as a 'large commercial agglomeration,' which is their phrase for a busy, living place rather than a lost fantasy. 10. The story then shifts to Plato around 360 BCE and his dialogues Timaeus and Critias. 11. Plato's version comes through Socrates, Critias, Solon, and Egyptian priests, who place Atlantis beyond the pillars of Heracles near the Strait of Gibraltar. 12. In that account, Atlantis has concentric rings, walls plated in precious metals, bridges, canals, and a central temple to Poseidon. 13. The hosts note that Plato's Atlantis includes a powerful navy, conquests, and a single day and night of 'misfortune' when earthquakes and floods destroy the island. 14. They point out that Critias stops mid-sentence, which leaves Atlantis unfinished and makes the dialogue feel like a deliberate cliffhanger. 15. The episode then presents the skeptical view that Atlantis is a parable about arrogance, injustice, and the collapse of powerful societies. 16. Kara and Megan also cover the competing theory that Plato may have woven together older disasters, including the eruption of Thera near Santorini and the sinking of Helike in 373 BCE. 17. They mention that Helike was later found buried in an old lagoon, with ancient writers saying people could still see the tops of buildings beneath the water. 18. The show widens the frame further with Thonis-Heracleion, Pavlopetri, and Dwarka as other submerged places that keep the Atlantis pattern alive. 19. The tone is conversational, skeptical, and playful, with frequent interruptions, jokes about mispronouncing Greek names, and a back-and-forth format. 20. Listeners who like mythology, archaeology, and historical mysteries will probably enjoy this episode, while listeners wanting a strict proof-of-Atlantis argument may skip it.

As heard by us

A loose Atlantis episode that treats the myth with skepticism and some charm.

This episode takes Atlantis with a skeptical eye. Kara and Megan keep the pace loose and conversational as they move through Plato's version, then widen out to other flood stories and real sunken cities that do not need Atlantis attached to them.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want Atlantis with a skeptical, conversational take, this is your kitchen-table tour.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Witches, Magic, Murder, & Mystery