Witches, Magic, Murder, & Mystery · Megan and Kara

345. SPOOKY: Listener Ghost Stories, Vol. 19

·25 min·1 clip

A baby, a 3 a.m. alarm, and Marlboro Reds appear in the same haunted apartment.

Kara and Megan spend the episode on listener-submitted ghost stories. The setup is simple, but the unease comes through on its own. They start with a note from Bailey, who also signs as Rachel. She calls it a spiritual ghosty story and says it is sadder than spooky before the ghost stuff really begins. The hosts lean into that mix of feeling and fear. They give the warning its due, then let the story unfold without smoothing out the rough parts. The episode moves in short bursts of narration and reaction, so it feels like two friends reading strange mail at the kitchen table. The next story turns to a house built in 1992. It has a layout the listener can picture right away. Hallway footsteps become part of the routine once the kids are asleep. The presence fades in the daylight, which only makes it creepier. When the listener is alone, the feeling of someone close behind her lands hard. Kara and Megan keep circling back to the same question. Why does this keep happening when nobody else is there. They also leave room for the little jokes and side comments that keep the mood human. That balance keeps the episode from getting too heavy. By the end, the stories feel less like scares for their own sake and more like personal accounts the hosts are genuinely glad were sent in.

As heard by us

Personal ghost stories with warmth, humor, and a light chill.

This episode leans into listener ghost stories that feel personal and oddly plainspoken, which makes them land harder when they turn sad. Kara and Megan keep pace in real time, so the conversation stays loose and lived in instead of overworked.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Listener-submitted ghost stories with playful back-and-forth.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Witches, Magic, Murder, & Mystery