When We Were Young - an 80s and 90s pop culture podcast · When We Were Young podcast

“It’s Not The Years, Honey, It’s The Mileage” - Indiana Jones Part 1

·1 hr 23 min·5 clips

One host says Raiders is “amazing in parts” but still leaves them “underwhelmed.”

1. When We Were Young turns to Indiana Jones Part 1 and centers the discussion on Raiders of the Lost Ark. 2. Chris, Seth, and Becky host the episode and frame the trilogy through their own 80s-and-90s pop-culture memories. 3. The episode asks what Indiana Jones was meant to be and why Raiders still matters after 1981. 4. The hosts open with the franchise’s serial-movie roots and George Lucas’s idea from 1973. 5. They say Lucas was already writing Star Wars in 1973 and wanted Indiana Jones to echo 1930s and 1940s cliffhanger serials. 6. They name serial-era characters like Brick Bradford, Hop Harrigan, Chick Carter, Brenda Starr, and Congo Bill. 7. The script history includes Philip Kaufman, who first developed the film and chose the Ark of the Covenant. 8. The name changed from Indiana Smith to Indiana Jones because Spielberg disliked “Indiana Smith,” and Lucas had named his dog Indiana. 9. Spielberg wanted a fast, cheaper shoot with 87 shooting days and a $40 million budget after going over on Jaws. 10. He also treated the movie as a chance to make a serial-like adventure with fewer takes and less dependence on expensive effects. 11. Casting talk becomes one of the episode’s main stories, with Bill Murray, Nick Nolte, Steve Martin, Chevy Chase, Jeff Bridges, Sam Elliott, Harry Hamlin, and Tom Selleck all named. 12. The hosts explain that Magnum P.I. kept Tom Selleck from taking the role, even though a writer’s strike briefly created a path back. 13. Karen Allen’s experience gets attention because she was disappointed by how much backstory and dialogue were cut from Marion Ravenwood. 14. The episode gives the film’s release context, including Raiders opening on June 12, 1981 and taking place in 1936. 15. The plot setup includes Jones chasing the Ark of the Covenant, a wooden chest tied to the stone tablets of the Ten Commandments. 16. The hosts mention the film’s reception, including Gene Siskel’s praise, Pauline Kael’s criticism, and the movie’s $212 million domestic gross. 17. The conversation is casual, joking, and highly referential, with side comments about Hawaii sandcastles, On Golden Pond, and the Disney ride. 18. The tone shifts between nostalgia, trivia, and blunt personal reaction, and one host says Raiders is “amazing in parts” but still leaves them “underwhelmed.” 19. Listeners who love Spielberg trivia, casting history, and 80s adventure films will get the most out of it. 20. Listeners wanting a strict scene-by-scene Raiders breakdown may want a different episode.

As heard by us

A funny, memory-led look at why Indiana Jones felt like required viewing.

The episode keeps returning to Indiana Jones as a childhood marker, not some untouchable relic, and that choice gives the discussion its shape.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

For your next Indiana Jones rewatch, start with the arguments, not the whip, and let the nostalgia do the digging.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from When We Were Young - an 80s and 90s pop culture podcast