What's He On About? Cricket Podcast · Charlie Harden

India Eventually Shake Hands! Englishmen React To Draw at Old Trafford and Preview 5th Test

·45 min·3 clips

England offered the draw, India refused, and the handshake row exploded at Old Trafford.

Episode 35 opens with a quick review of the Test and plenty of emotion still left in the room. This is clearly a post-match chat rather than a neat roundup. Charlie Kirk joins in, and he sounds genuinely wound up by the handshake debate and the wider moral-victory talk. The conversation jumps into that atmosphere before settling back onto the cricket itself. India’s 358 is the starting point, and the hosts work through how the match unfolded from there. England respond, the pitch gets flatter, and the discussion keeps circling back to whether the surface has become too flat for a proper contest. There is talk of India batting through long stretches, and the comparison with home conditions in England keeps resurfacing. It is the kind of discussion that starts with numbers and quickly turns into a judgment about what those numbers mean. That is very much the tone here. The show keeps asking whether England should be doing more with home advantage. It also keeps asking whether Dawson was let down by the match situation. There is a thread about needle, too, and whether some games need that edge to get players properly into the contest. Charlie leans hard into that idea. He says he does not have a problem with the tension in the series, and that point gets a proper run. The hosts move on to how some players thrive when the game gets a little nasty. Zach Crawley comes up as someone who might enjoy that environment. Then the focus swings back to Old Trafford and the familiar feeling of a deadlocked home draw. The pitch talk gets sharper from there. It is described as especially bad, and probably the worst in years from the perspective of the show. That leads naturally into the spirit-of-cricket discussion at the end of the match. There is still time for the hosts to joke about the whole thing becoming a forgotten argument once the next outrage rolls around. Even the final stretch keeps one eye on the absurdity of it all. The episode closes by folding everything back into the post-match chat, the guest appearance, and the wider cricket conversation.

As heard by us

A slightly frazzled post-Test chat that stays with the handshake, the pitch, and the fallout.

The episode stays with the Test throughout, moving from the handshake fuss to the flatter pitch, then through India's stubborn batting and England's reply.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the handshake fallout, the pitch debate, and the player ratings in one quick cricket debrief.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from What's He On About? Cricket Podcast