What Gives? The Jewish Philanthropy Podcast · Jewish Funders Network

Yehuda Kurtzer - Jewish Identity in a Changing World

·1 hr 2 min·3 clips

He says the real crisis is “epistemic chaos” and a collapsing shared sense of reality.

1. What Gives? The Jewish Philanthropy Podcast episode centers on Yehuda Kurtzer and Jewish identity in a changing world. 2. Andres Focoidi hosts Yehuda Kurtzer, president of the Shalom Hartman Institute, and both matter because they connect Jewish communal life to public politics. 3. The episode asks whether Jewish community, liberal democracy, and individual identity can hold together during uncertainty. 4. Kurtzer starts with the 2024 general election and says he has been skeptical about election buildup since 2016. 5. He says Donald Trump is a “unique case,” but he is more worried about larger risks to democracy that go beyond one election. 6. He describes election-night coverage on NBC News as “so much talking” and “hot takes” before results, which he treats as a symptom of the moment. 7. Kurtzer calls the environment “epistemic chaos” and says there is “no common sense of reality anymore.” 8. He shifts to Jewish teaching and argues that Torah and Jewish analysis should not be reduced to the news cycle. 9. He says the more useful frame may be that instability, not stability, is the historical norm in Jewish history and world history. 10. He cites Francis Fukuyama’s 1989 “The End of History,” then notes that religion and nationalism turned out to be enduring rather than easily dismissed. 11. Kurtzer says the strategy should be to “fight like hell” for convictions rather than assume liberal democracy is the default condition. 12. He challenges exhausted activists by asking whether they have been fighting the right fight, instead of only reacting defensively. 13. He engages Pierre Saint-Vallon’s idea of the “era of negative politics,” where movements often define themselves by what they oppose. 14. He says Trump’s “Make America Great Again” and Harris’s “We won’t go back” are both past-oriented slogans rather than clear future visions. 15. He argues that liberal democratic movements need a positive vision, including a vision for liberal Zionism and an “inclusive, expansive” democracy. 16. Kurtzer says modern loneliness is tied to the weakening of collective life, but he distinguishes that from a simple critique of “the establishment.” 17. He says Shabbat creates “powerful psychological antidotes” through staying local, visiting neighbors, and sharing potluck meals. 18. The interview style is analytic, fast-moving, and cross-references political theory, Jewish texts, and lived communal examples. 19. Listeners interested in Jewish communal boundaries, Zionism, and liberal democracy will get the most from it. 20. Listeners wanting light biography or a purely ceremonial interview may skip it.

As heard by us

A careful Jewish conversation about identity, obligation, and the appeal of unfettered freedom.

The episode treats Jewish identity as a lived practice shaped by thinking, teaching, and learning, then carries that thread into change, belonging, and uncertainty.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a thoughtful conversation about Jewish identity, obligation, and independence under modern change, press play.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from What Gives? The Jewish Philanthropy Podcast