What Gives? The Jewish Philanthropy Podcast · Jewish Funders Network

Sarah Hurwitz - Reclaiming Jewish Identity and Peoplehood

·52 min·1 clip

We can spend all this time trying to bail out a tsunami with buckets, or we can build an ark.

Sara Hurwitz argues that Jewish identity cannot survive as a public-relations project. Andres Pokojny opens by asking why she felt compelled to write again. Her answer rests on a wider historical claim. She says anti-Judaism is built into the theological traditions of half the world's population, so Jews should not expect a simple image-repair campaign to fix the problem. She uses a vivid comparison: buckets cannot bail out a tsunami. The task, in her view, is to build an ark. The interview then turns toward parents who are baffled that their children seem to be tearing themselves apart despite years of Jewish education and ritual. Hurwitz tells them not to assume they failed. She argues that phones and social feeds are flooding young people with images and rhetoric that ordinary family practice cannot easily counter. She describes the old anti-Jewish message in modern form. Jews are still being cast as powerful, depraved, and conspiratorial. That is why, she says, identity has to be substantial. If a person does not know enough about Jewish tradition, they will have very little to say when confronted with claims about the Jewish God, law, or Israel. Slogans and self-deprecating jokes will not do the job. The conversation also widens into the problem of competing definitions. Hurwitz points to anti-Semites on one side and Jewish extremists on the other. Both can flatten Jewish and Zionist identity into something distorted. When a negative version of Zionism is presented to a college student and then echoed by an Israeli government minister, the confusion deepens. For Hurwitz, that makes the work of reclamation urgent. The point is not only to defend Jews. It is to give them enough depth to know who they are before others define it for them. The episode ends on a call for memory, confidence, and communal grounding.

As heard by us

A serious case for Jewish identity, grounded in history and communal footing.

Sara Hurwitz makes a plain case for Jewish identity built on substance rather than apology. Andres Pokojny lets her trace anti-Judaism from its long theological roots to the pressures young Jews face now, where social media, rhetoric, and distorted politics all land at once.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Need a sober take on Jewish identity under pressure?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from What Gives? The Jewish Philanthropy Podcast