What Catholics Believe

Faith of God? War for Independence? Libertarianism? Marijuana? Pelosi vs Francis. Gates' Experiments

·59 min·5 clips
Father Jenkins explains why the phrase 'you can't legislate morality' is actually the antithesis of truth for Catholics.
The program opens by addressing supporters who hold to the true Roman Catholic religion as taught before Vatican II and the New Mass. It then recites prayers to the Holy Ghost, asking for wisdom and consolation through Christ. Thomas Nagley welcomes listeners to What Catholics Believe and introduces Father William Jenkins as a traditional Catholic priest, superior of the Society of St. Pius V, and pastor of Manicula Conception Church in Norwood, Ohio. Prayer requests set the pastoral tone. Jenkins asks for prayers that someone be converted, accept the true faith, and become a heroic follower, even one who might reach martyrdom. The discussion then turns to Francis. Jenkins says it is puzzling that people can see Francis as lacking the faith while still regarding him as pope. He says prayers for Francis should include conversion to the faith. That point leads into Donald Trump. Jenkins says Trump is more of a Christian than Francis, tying that judgment to Trump's lack of modernist philosophy. In Jenkins' account, modernism adds twists, conditions, and philosophical distinctions that become a smokescreen against faith. Trump is presented as direct and almost crudely realistic. Even so, Jenkins says Trump does not have the right principles. He cites Trump's promotion of IVF, acceptance of abortion in some circumstances, and courting of the LGBT group. Jenkins treats those positions as politically expedient, whether or not Trump personally sees them as right. The closing thanks graduates, supporters, and viewers. Nagley and Jenkins describe the Christmas appeal as the major effort of the moment. The program ends with Our Lady of Fatima and a call to consecration, prayer, and penance.

As heard by us

A prayerful, polemical discussion of conversion, papal legitimacy, and political principle.

What Catholics Believe takes up a hard question inside traditional Catholic argument: how can a pope be spoken of as someone in need of conversion to the faith?

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want traditional Catholic polemic that presses the problem of praying for Francis's conversion while still calling him pope.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on