We're Not Critics Podcast - formerly Movie Pain or Pleasure · Melanie and AJ

Episode 69 - The Golden Bachelor Episode One Reaction

December 22, 2023·20 min·1 clip
Gary's wife died just after they bought their dream lake house, setting up a heartbreaking start to his search for love.
Melanie starts with a warning about the audio. AJ is already asking for water because his throat is scratchy from too much coffee. The two settle in without pretending to be Bachelor people. They say they do not watch The Bachelor, and they do not love the whole idea of wanting to marry someone you barely know. The setup feels off to them, the kind of reality-TV premise that makes sense only if you stop asking questions. They compare it to the creepier corners of the franchise world. 90 Day Fiance comes up. Who Wants to Marry Millionaire comes up too. The joke keeps circling the same point: dating shows are one thing, but marriage-first reality TV is a different kind of strange. Melanie and AJ then drift into appearance jokes. They are careful not to turn it into clean body-policing. The point is simpler than that. The show is built on people looking at people, so they are looking back. That turns into a little disclaimer that everybody looks odd if you stare long enough. Human beings, they decide, are just weird-looking. Even the pretty ones. Except for angler fish. Then Kathy shows up and the energy shifts. Kathy is 70, a retired educator from Austin, and in their eyes she lands with immediate villain energy. They call her lawful evil and start imagining her as a teacher, which they agree would have been terrifying. The Matilda comparison pops out and sticks. The joke is that she means business. She is here to win. They do not see much chemistry between Kathy and Gary. What they do see is somebody who wants a rose and knows how to go after it. The episode keeps moving in that blunt, half-serious, half-silly mode. Melanie and AJ point out how everyone arrives with a little performance and a little backstory. Kathy gets the sharpest read because she seems to know the game a little too well. They talk about the way reality TV manufactures sincerity and how little of it is probably real. Still, they give the cast credit for showing up and playing along. The tone never really turns sentimental. It stays dry, a little rude, and suspicious of its own genre. Gary gets attention too. The hosts agree he fits the show well, and they note that he likes to kiss and makes out with a lot of women. Somewhere in the middle of all that, they wonder how his daughters and granddaughters feel about watching it happen. That opens a small softer lane, but only for a minute. The conversation snaps back to jokes and disbelief. By the end, the first episode has been treated like a social experiment with bad lighting. They close by inviting listeners into the show's orbit and framing the whole thing like a kind of cult membership, which is exactly the right amount of self-aware nonsense for what came before it.

As heard by us

A sharp, self-aware first reaction to The Golden Bachelor that stays lively despite uneven audio.

Melanie and AJ treat their first take on The Golden Bachelor as a case for reality TV's built-in showmanship: producer control, appearance over substance, and the unease they already attach to the genre.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play for a no-filter Golden Bachelor premiere reaction from two skeptics.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on