War Movie Theatre | for Fans of Classic War Films and Cinema History · Robert Hutton & Duncan Weldon - War Movies Fans

Michael Collins

·1 hr 15 min·5 clips

Michael Collins premiered in 1996, before the Good Friday Agreement and while the IRA campaign was still ongoing.

Rob Hutton opens with a joke about cycling around Dublin because the police would not know them. That leads into a March rebrand for the show, Irish War of Independence Movie Theatre, or Fighting Irish Month if you prefer the more enthusiastic phrasing, with Michael Collins as the film under discussion. They approach it through memory, tone, and a healthy suspicion about what a history film is actually promising. The hosts point out a familiar problem: some listeners care about the details, while others mainly want the film to hold together. Duncan Weldon brings in Rogue Heroes as a comparison to show how specialist knowledge changes the viewing experience. From there, they land on the idea that Neil Jordan's film works if you accept its claim to be a true story and take the rest on trust. The archive visit gets singled out as tense, with discovery feeling possible at any second, and that near-discovery gives the episode one of its neatest pleasures. Bloody Sunday is the other fixed point. They note that Croke Park is the part that stayed in memory, even if some surrounding details have blurred. The armored vehicle crash is another image that still lands. They spend time on why some scenes survive and others fade, which is part of how old films show their shape. There is a dry joke about Julia Roberts being cut into the film, and the joke repeats often enough to become part of the rhythm rather than a throwaway aside. That rhythm matters because the hosts are not trying to pin down a sealed verdict; they are thinking aloud, qualifying themselves, and letting the film become clearer through comparison, memory, and the odd correction. As they go, the film grows more appealing in retrospect. One of them still thinks it may need another ten years before he is fully won over. They close by pointing listeners toward Barry Linden next week, followed by the website plug and the usual invitation to like and subscribe.

As heard by us

A dry, smart argument about Michael Collins, memory, and historical drama.

Michael Collins gives War Movie Theatre an argument worth having: what happens when a history film meets listeners who care deeply about the facts, while the hosts are content to judge it as drama first.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play for a dry, memory-led take on Michael Collins, where Bloody Sunday, Croke Park, and the archive-visit tension do most of the work.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from War Movie Theatre | for Fans of Classic War Films and Cinema History