VS (Poetry Foundation) · Poetry Foundation

Omotara James vs. The Speaker

April 29, 2025·1 hr 6 min·4 clips

Omotara James describes growing up Black, fat, and Cockney-accented in America — invisible to everyone, legible to no one.

A puppy starts the room. Ajene tells how he took in a stray little puppy named Charlie, then found out he was Debo when the dog went back to his owner. Brittany draws her line, too. April Fool's jokes turn into a quick read on trust, anger at being played, and the friends' easy comic rhythm. The opening feels loose, but it leads somewhere sharper: what happens when someone receives the thing you made. The guest talks about revision as conscience. A draft may start with the speaker, but revision is where the reader enters the room. The question is not just polish. It is whether the poem leaves someone hanging from a cliff, or whether it gives them consolation, witness, understanding, and meaning. Some poems did not make it through that test. Even strong-sounding work was cut when it could not carry the responsibility or offer a space worth entering. The guest pushes against spectacle. Trauma can be in the poem, but the poem has to know what it is doing with trauma, and what the writer might become complicit in. The host hears that clearly. Readerly care is treated as part of the relationship between maker, speaker, audience, and work, not as self-censorship. Nobody is asking for softness only. The point is tougher: do not exploit the reader, do not exploit trauma, and do not confuse provocation with purpose. The close comes back home. Charlie gets a tender farewell, the team is thanked, and the show leaves with the same affectionate looseness it came in with.

As heard by us

A warm, serious craft conversation about revision, trust, and what a poem asks of its reader.

Omotara James vs. The Speaker turns on a sharp craft question: what does a poem owe the person reading it? James speaks with uncommon clarity about revision as an ethical act, describing poems she removed because they sounded good but did not yet make meaning, offer care, or…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a poetry interview that starts with a puppy and ends with ethics, press play.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from VS (Poetry Foundation)