The Sodder Family Replay

December 25, 2025·36 min·3 clips

On Christmas 1945, George Sodder found his water frozen, ladder missing, and trucks dead while his children burned inside.

Smoke came first. Jenny woke George after it poured into their bedroom, and the host begins with that terrifying Christmas morning evacuation. Five children did not make it out. After that, the episode moves through the details private detectives later chased down, one by one. A man had reportedly watched the children from a parked car over multiple days before the fire. The phone line became a problem too. A repairman told the Sodders it had been cut intentionally, high above the ground and away from the pole. The timing was ugly: Jenny had answered a call around 12:30 AM, so the cut likely came after that. Then there was the ladder. It turned up about 75 feet from the house, sitting in a ditch instead of where the family needed it. Marion watched the top-floor window and did not see her siblings trying to escape. No one remembered hearing screams from inside the burning house. Other witnesses added stranger pieces. A bus driver reported seeing balls of fire tossed onto the roof around the time Jenny heard a thump above her. Lonnie Johnson later entered the story. According to the Register Herald, he pled guilty to the theft and said he had cut an electric line. Jenny doubted that because the lights were still on. She thought he may have cut the telephone line by mistake. About three months later, Sylvia found a hard rubber object near the burned house that army authorities allegedly identified as a pineapple bomb. The host does not force a clean ending. The episode stays grave, careful, and unsettled, which fits why the family never accepted a simple fire explanation.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Voices for Justice