Evelyn Hartley

October 9, 2025·54 min·4 clips

Richard Hartley found Evelyn's shoe in the basement and her glasses upstairs, but his daughter was gone.

Evelyn Hartley became a neat story she never really was. The host starts with the gap between true crime entertainment and the official investigation, where Netflix's Monster presents Evelyn as one of Ed Gein's confirmed victims. The investigation does not. Sarah Turney then returns to the mystery itself, naming Evelyn Grace Hartley and placing her as born in Charleston, Illinois, before the episode moves into the night she disappeared. The timing does a lot of work here. A neighbor, Elvin Sadock, said he heard three sharp screams around 7 p.m., about 15 minutes after the Rasmussens left for the game. His wife thought the screams sounded more serious. That difference matters because Evelyn was supposed to cover the baby with a blanket by 7.15 p.m., which supports the idea that she may have been taken earlier. Then Ed Hoffer's account makes the case harder to pin down. Known for years only as Mr. X, he reported seeing two men and a girl walking near the end of the blood trail. The girl seemed intoxicated and needed help walking. Hoffer later described the same people in a Buick speeding west, with one man driving and the other in the back seat beside the girl. Investigators trusted him after a polygraph. A Daily News report from 1954 complicated that, saying the driver was later identified as a male college student who was interviewed, polygraphed, gave an alibi, and was cleared, though the alibi was apparently never fully confirmed. Even that did not close the door. Turney treats the polygraph detail carefully, since passing one seems to have meant a lot to investigators in this case. The suspect pool did not stay small. Evelyn's father and Viggo Rasmussen were examined too, but both cooperated and were eventually ruled out. The homecoming game was more than backdrop. It meant more locals were out of their houses, and it overlapped with a conference involving 400 student leaders from across Wisconsin, giving reporters another theory that Evelyn's parents and friends rejected. What is left is not the tidy ending television prefers. It is a family's long, unresolved mystery, made worse when confident retellings turn uncertainty into closure.

As heard by us

A careful pushback against a tidy true-crime retelling.

Sarah Turney uses Evelyn Hartley to ask a harder question than many true-crime shows do: how much of what people watch is actually true, and what gets lost when a family’s painful mystery is turned into a neat fiction?

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the case behind a polished true-crime rewrite.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Voices for Justice